European Aviation Safety Agency
Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-08
Import of aircraft from other regulatory system, and
Part-21 Subpart H review
RMT.0278 — 7.9.2016
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This Notice of Proposed Amendment (NPA) addresses a regulatory coordination issue mainly related to the
import of aircraft into the European regulatory system and the revision of Part-21 Subpart H.
This NPA proposes amendments to Part-21 and Part-M in order to guarantee their consistency with regard to
the issuance of a Certificate of Airworthiness (CofA) and an Airworthiness Review Certificate (ARC) for aircraft
being imported from other regulatory systems. These aircraft can be either foreign registered aircraft or
European aircraft not subject to Article 1.2 of the Basic Regulation.
The proposed changes are expected to eliminate difficulties encountered by stakeholders and Member States in
the process of obtaining/issuing a CofA and ARC for aircraft being imported from another regulatory system
while ensuring alignment with ICAO.
Part-21 is also amended to establish consistency in the case of newly manufactured foreign aircraft.
Applicability Process map
Affected Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014; Concept Paper: No
regulations Regulation (EU) No 748/2012; Terms of Reference: 1.2.2013
and decisions: ED Decision 2015/029/R; ED Decision Rulemaking group: Yes
2012/020/R
RIA type: Light
Affected Aircraft owners; continuing Technical consultation during
stakeholders: airworthiness management NPA drafting: No
organisations (CAMOs); maintenance
Duration of NPA consultation: 3 months
organisations; airworthiness review
staff (ARS); national aviation Review group: Yes
authorities (NAAs) Focused consultation: No
Driver/origin: Level playing field Publication date of the Opinion: 2017/Q3
Publication date of the Decision: Upon adoption of
Reference: ICAO Doc 9760, ICAO Annex 8
the Opinion by
the Commission
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 1 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
Table of contents
Table of contents
1. Procedural information .................................................................................................................. 3
1.1. The rule development procedure................................................................................................... 3
1.2. The structure of this NPA and related documents......................................................................... 3
1.3. How to comment on this NPA ....................................................................................................... 3
1.4. The next steps in the procedure .................................................................................................... 3
2. Explanatory Note ........................................................................................................................... 5
2.1. Overview of the issues to be addressed......................................................................................... 5
2.2. Objectives ...................................................................................................................................... 5
2.3. Summary of the RIA ....................................................................................................................... 6
2.4. Overview of the proposed amendments ....................................................................................... 6
3. Proposed amendments ................................................................................................................ 10
3.1. Draft regulation (draft EASA opinion) .........................................................................................10
3.1.1. Changes to Annex I (Part-21) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012 ................................ 10
3.1.2. Changes to Annex I (Part-M) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014 ............................... 15
3.2. Draft acceptable means of compliance and guidance material (draft EASA decision) ...............16
3.2.1. Changes to AMC/GM to Annex I (Part-21) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012 ............ 16
3.2.2. Changes to AMC/GM to Annex I (Part-M) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014 .......... 23
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)............................................................................................ 28
4.1. Issues to be addressed .................................................................................................................28
4.1.1. Safety risk assessment ................................................................................................................... 30
4.1.2. Who is affected? ............................................................................................................................ 30
4.1.3. How could the issue/problem evolve? .......................................................................................... 30
4.2. Objectives ....................................................................................................................................30
4.3. Policy options...............................................................................................................................30
4.4. Analysis of impacts per criteria ...................................................................................................33
4.4.1. Safety impact ................................................................................................................................. 33
4.4.2. Environmental impact .................................................................................................................... 34
4.4.3. Social impact .................................................................................................................................. 34
4.4.4. Economic impact ............................................................................................................................ 34
4.4.5. General Aviation (GA) and proportionality issues.......................................................................... 35
4.4.6. Impact on ‘better regulation’ and harmonisation ......................................................................... 35
4.5. General justifications to select the preferred option for each item from the issue analysis .......35
4.6. Conclusions ..................................................................................................................................38
4.7. Monitoring and evaluation ..........................................................................................................38
5. References.................................................................................................................................... 40
5.1. Affected regulations ....................................................................................................................40
5.2. Affected CS, AMC and GM ...........................................................................................................40
5.3. Reference documents ..................................................................................................................40
6. Appendices ................................................................................................................................... 41
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 2 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
1. Procedural information
1. Procedural information
1.1. The rule development procedure
The European Aviation Safety Agency (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Agency’) developed this
Notice of Proposed Amendment (NPA) in line with Regulation (EC) No 216/20081 (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Basic Regulation’) and the Rulemaking Procedure2.
This rulemaking activity is included in the Agency’s 5-year Rulemaking Programme under
RMT.0278.
The text of this NPA has been developed by the Agency based on the input of the Rulemaking
Group RMT.0278. It is hereby submitted for consultation of all interested parties3.
The process map on the title page contains the major milestones of this rulemaking activity to
date and provides an outlook of the timescale of the next steps.
1.2. The structure of this NPA and related documents
Chapter 1 of this NPA contains the procedural information related to this task. Chapter 2
(Explanatory Note) explains the core technical content. Chapter 3 contains the proposed text
for the new requirements. Chapter 4 contains the regulatory impact assessment (RIA) showing
which options were considered and what impacts were identified, thereby providing the
detailed justification for this NPA.
1.3. How to comment on this NPA
Please submit your comments using the automated Comment-Response Tool (CRT) available
at http://hub.easa.europa.eu/crt/4.
The deadline for submission of comments is 7 December 2016.
1.4. The next steps in the procedure
Following the closing of the NPA public consultation period, the Agency will review all
comments. The outcome of the NPA public consultation will be reflected in a comment-
response document (CRD).
1
Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 February 2008 on common rules in the
field of civil aviation and establishing a European Aviation Safety Agency, and repealing Council Directive 91/670/EEC,
Regulation (EC) No 1592/2002 and Directive 2004/36/EC (OJ L 79, 19.3.2008, p. 1).
2
EASA is bound to follow a structured rulemaking process as required by Article 52(1) of the Basic Regulation. Such
process has been adopted by the EASA Management Board (MB) and is referred to as the ‘Rulemaking Procedure’. See
MB Decision No 18-2015 of 15 December 2015 replacing Decision 01/2012 concerning the procedure to be applied by the
Agency for the issuing of opinions, certification specifications and guidance material (‘Rulemaking Procedure’).
3
In accordance with Article 52 of the Basic Regulation and Articles 6(3) and 7 of the Rulemaking Procedure.
4
In case of technical problems, please contact the CRT webmaster (
[email protected]).
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 3 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
1. Procedural information
The Agency will publish the CRD concurrently with the opinion. The opinion will contain the
proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) No 1321/20145 and Regulation (EU) No 748/20126
and will be submitted to the European Commission (EC), to be used as a technical basis in
order to prepare an EU regulation.
The Decision containing acceptable means of compliance (AMC) and guidance material (GM)
will be published by the Agency when the related implementing rule(s) (IRs) are adopted by
the Commission.
5
Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014 of 26 November 2014 on the continuing airworthiness of aircraft and
aeronautical products, parts and appliances, and on the approval of organisations and personnel involved in these tasks
(OJ L 362, 17.12.2014, p. 1).
6
Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012 of 3 August 2012 laying down implementing rules for the airworthiness and
environmental certification of aircraft and related products, parts and appliances, as well as for the certification of design
and production organisations (OJ L 224, 21.8.2012, p. 1).
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 4 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
2. Explanatory Note
2. Explanatory Note
2.1. Overview of the issues to be addressed
Stakeholders pointed out that requirements in Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014 (Part-M) and
Regulation (EU) No 748/2012 (Part-21) with regard to the issuance of a CofA and an
airworthiness review certificate (ARC) were not adequate, unclear or impossible to be fulfilled
in certain occasions when aircraft were imported from a different regulatory system (i.e. a
regulatory system other than the system established by the Basic Regulation). This is the main
part of this rulemaking activity.
Additionally, Part-21, Subpart H needs some minor non-technical amendments, for instance to
align the ‘Restricted Certificate of Airworthiness’ and ‘Certificate of Airworthiness‘ forms (EASA
Forms 24 and 25 respectively) with ICAO provisions, which require the identification of the
aircraft category within the Airworthiness Certificate. Also some changes are proposed to
guarantee coherence between point 2 of Article 9 of Regulation (EU) No 748/2012 and
Subpart H for newly manufactured foreign aircraft.
For more detailed analysis of the issues addressed by this proposal, please refer to the RIA
Section 4.1. ‘Issues to be addressed’.
2.2. Objectives
The objectives of the EU in the field of civil aviation are defined in Article 2 of the Basic
Regulation. This proposal will contribute to the achievement of these objectives by addressing
the issues outlined in Chapter 2.1 above.
The specific objectives of this proposal are:
— to mitigate potential safety risks linked to the fact that the aircraft did not comply with
the EU rules prior to being registered/imported, and to facilitate a common
understanding of the approach to be followed, in terms of recognition of other
certificates and/or records issued by other stakeholders for the aircraft involved;
— to clarify current ambiguities in the rules related to issuance of CofA in order to
achieve standardised implementation and equal treatment in all Member States.
The scope of this NPA is limited to the aircraft being imported into the European system, i.e.
which are becoming subject to the Basic Regulation and its implementing rules. When the
term ‘import’ is used in this NPA, also in the current text in Part-21 or Part-M, it is not used in
the context of the aircraft registration process, which is regulated under national rules, but in
the context of the issuance of an Airworthiness Certificate for an aircraft which before did not
fall under the scope of the Basic Regulation. For information, the term ‘transfer’ is used for
aircraft changing registration between two Member States.
In principle, the aircraft registered in a Member State7 (so called ‘European-registered’) are
subject to the Basic Regulation and its implementing rules. However, this is not the case for
7
Member State in the context of this NPA refers to Member States of the EU and the States referred to in Article 66 of the
Basic Regulation.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 5 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
2. Explanatory Note
European-registered aircraft if their regulatory safety oversight has been delegated to a third
country and they are not used by a Community operator (refer to Article 4.1 (b) of the Basic
Regulation). A typical example may be a European-registered aircraft which is dry-leased out
to a ‘foreign’ operator and its oversight delegated between ICAO contracting States under the
provisions of Article 83 bis of the Chicago Convention. While these aircraft are not subject to
European rules during the leased out period, they would have to follow the process subject to
this NPA at the end of the leasing contract in order to comply with the Basic Regulation and be
granted with an European Airworthiness Certificate and Airworthiness Review Certificate. The
same as if a used aircraft was being imported from a foreign country.
A similar situation would be aircraft subject to Part-T (i.e. foreign-registered aircraft dry-
leased-in by an EU-licenced air carrier, refer to regulation (EU) 2015/1536) if and when
changing to a European registration: at the moment of import, this aircraft would need to
follow the requirements proposed in this NPA (once they are adopted as European law) in
order to obtain a CofA and an ARC in accordance with Part-21 and Part-M8.
It is also worth mentioning that in the case of aircraft imported from countries with which the
European Union has signed a Bilateral Aviation Safety Agreement, the process regulated by
the implementing rules emanating from the Basic Regulation may not be applicable. These
aircraft are not impacted by the amendments proposed with this NPA.
2.3. Summary of the RIA
The detailed regulatory impact assessment is contained in Chapter 4 of this NPA.
2.4. Overview of the proposed amendments
Note: In November 2015 the Agency published NPA 2015-17 ‘Airworthiness review process’,
containing a revised regulatory approach to the Airworthiness review. Both rulemaking
activities, the one addressed in NPA 2015-17 and the one addressed with this NPA, are
interrelated, but some discussions are specific to each topic. Therefore, the Agency planned two
separate rulemaking tasks. The regulatory amendments proposed in the next chapter of this
NPA are referring to the current rules, without taking into consideration the regulatory
amendments proposed in NPA 2015-17. However, the Agency will consider the external
comments received to both NPAs when producing the corresponding Opinions/Decision.
The proposed amendments to Annex I (Part-M) of Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014, Annex I
(Part-21) of Regulation (EU) No 748/2012, as well as to their associated AMC/GM, are the
following:
— Paragraph 21.A.174(b)(3)(i) is amended to require that aircraft being transferred within
Member States need a valid ARC and a copy of the CofA, which was not explicit before.
In parallel, 21.A.179, 21.B.320, 21.B.326 and 21.B.327 are amended to facilitate the
transfer of aircraft between Member States, being proposed that it would only be an
8
To be fully precise, non-EU aircraft used by EU operators other than licensed air carriers, are also subject to the BR, but
no specific implementing rules in the field of continuing airworthiness apply to them. I.e., if these aircraft are being
imported into the EU, they would need to follow the import process described in this NPA.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 6 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
2. Explanatory Note
administrative process when transferring aircraft which are already compliant with the
EU rules.
— The case of application for an airworthiness certificate for an aircraft which have already
had an airworthiness certificate issued in accordance with Part-21 but this certificate
has become invalid, has been addressed in the newly proposed 21.A.174(e). In this case,
the process described in M.A.904 would need to be followed for submission of the
application for the CofA.
— The reference in the last point of 21.A.174(b)(3) to a ‘recommendation for the issuance
of a certificate of airworthiness’, as required documentation for the import of a used
aircraft originating from a non-MS, is removed. This ‘recommendation’ is only
mentioned in this paragraph, but the current rule does mention what is the basis for it
and who should develop it. In the proposed text, the process for import is better
defined and the roles clearly allocated.
— Another mandate identified in the terms of reference (ToR) of this rulemaking activity
was to develop requirements for ‘State aircraft’ (aircraft referred to Article 1 point (2)(a)
of Regulation (EC) No 216/2008) that are outside the scope of this regulation, but will be
introduced (‘imported’) into the system subject to Regulation (EC) No 216/2008, i.e. as
European civil aircraft9. These requirements are developed in a new point (4) in
21.A.174(b) of Part-21, which describes a process similar to the import of civil aircraft
from another non-Member State. M.A.904(a) of Part-M is also amended accordingly.
21.B.326 and 21.B.327 are also amended as needed.
— The proposed new 21.A.174(d) of Part-21 covers the case when the exporting authority
does not issue an airworthiness statement for the aircraft being exported. When the
airworthiness statement is provided and there is no reason to question its content, the
importing authority can rely on it during the importing process. When the statement is
missing, this NPA proposes the introduction of an ‘evaluation programme’ to be
provided by the applicant to the importing authority together with the application for
the issuance of the CofA. The ‘evaluation programme’ facilitates the agreement
between the importer and importing authority on the definition and depth of the
aircraft’s airworthiness assessment to be conducted. M.A.904(f) of Part-M is also added
accordingly. The proposed newly developed GM 21.A.174(b)(3)(ii) and (d) describes the
intent of the airworthiness statement to be issued by the exporting authority and the
exceptional cases on which an importing authority may accept an aircraft being
imported without the airworthiness statement. The contents of the inspection to be
performed during this evaluation are listed in the new GM M.A.904(f). Various AMCs
linked to 21.A.174 of Part-21 are also proposed to establish means of compliance for
the ‘evaluation programme’ requirement, while AMC M.A.904(b) is updated for
consistency reasons to address the ‘evaluation report’.
9
Aircraft conducting ‘State operations’ are excluded from applicability of the Basic Regulation while carrying out these
operations in accordance with Article 1 point (2)(a). If the same aircraft also carries out other type of operations which
are not excluded from the applicability of the Basic Regulation, this aircraft must have already an airworthiness certificate
issued in accordance with the Basic Regulation (and applicable implementing rules) and, therefore, does not need to
follow the ‘import process’.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 7 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
2. Explanatory Note
The case of the missing airworthiness statement had already been considered by the
Agency at the opportunity of the notification of a derogation by Denmark in 2006,
accepting in essence an alternative approach aiming to achieve the same objectives as
those expected with the ‘evaluation report’.
— A new GM 21.A.174(b)(4) and (d) contains a flowchart for the import process,
distinguishing the different potential cases covered in this NPA: a normal import, an
import without an airworthiness statement and the import of a ‘State aircraft’.
— Changes proposed in NPA 2015-17 to paragraph 21.A.179 are carried over on this NPA
with a couple of minor changes: firstly, the title of the paragraph is changed accordingly,
and secondly, the text is changed to read that the airworthiness certificate is transferred
with the aircraft in case that the aircraft remains on the same register and the person
responsible for the airworthiness of the aircraft changes (instead of the case of change
of owner). This may be relevant when the owner of the aircraft and the person
responsible for the airworthiness are different.
— With regard to the airworthiness review conducted in order to make a
‘recommendation’ to the importing competent authority and considering that the
airworthiness review for import has some peculiarities compared to a ‘standard’
airworthiness review, it is proposed that the airworthiness review staff should be
authorised for this process by their continuing airworthiness management organisation
(CAMO), once being competent and experienced enough to follow the process of
M.A.904 of Part-M. This change is proposed in paragraphs in M.A.707(a)(3) and
M.A.707(b) of Part-M, and related AMC M.A.707(a)(3).
— A particular point requiring special attention while conducting an airworthiness review
for import is to properly assess the aircraft configuration. It is important to determine
that the design of any aircraft change or repair is in accordance with Part-21 and, in
addition, to establish that several design changes and repairs are compatible.
For an aircraft already subject to the European regulatory system, the person
responsible for its continuing airworthiness is the one deciding to modify the aircraft
with an approved change or repair, and for this to consider the potential impact on the
aircraft taking into consideration other already embodied modifications.
At the time of import of a used aircraft, this NPA requests that this assessment is
conducted at once for all modifications and repairs embodied, as part of the M.A.904
process. M.A.904(a)(2) of Part-M is amended accordingly. New GM M.A.304 and
GM M.A.904(a)(2) have been developed to provide adequate explanations to the
process. Appendix V to AMC M.A.704, paragraph 4.4., containing considerations for a
CAMO exposition for organisations issuing recommendations for ARCs to competent
authorities, is also amended.
— AMC M.A.904(a)(2) is proposed to be amendment by deleting the items already covered
in a ‘standard’ airworthiness review and operational checks, and focussing on items
which are more relevant for imported aircraft while covering the case of a missing
airworthiness statement.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 8 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
2. Explanatory Note
— The airworthiness review of imported aircraft also led to amend M.A.710(a)(8) of
Part-M. This is to provide coherence for the process of importing an aircraft for which
an airworthiness review compliant with M.A.710 is required. M.A.710 of Part-M
requires that the aircraft maintenance has been conducted in compliance with Part-M.
However, this is not possible for aircraft being imported, for which their airworthiness
have been managed to comply with a different regulatory regime. These aircraft were
not subject, up to that moment, to the Basic Regulation nor its implementing rules.
— With regards to newly manufactured foreign aircraft, 21.A.174 of Part-21 contained the
possibility that the statement of compliance with an EASA approved design was made
by a foreign authority. In fact, this should be the case only when a foreign
manufacturing system has been considered equivalent as per point 2 of Article 9 of
Regulation (EU) No 748/2012, which derogates from Part-21 manufacturing processes.
Therefore, the requirement establishing the need of a statement of compliance with an
EASA approved type design, and to be made by the foreign authority is moved to
Article 2, and would only be of relevance in the case of manufacturing as per point 2 of
Article 9.
— Finally, GM 21.B.325(a) is amended in order to provide instructions on how to
adequately fill-in Block 4 ‘category’ of Forms 24 and 25 (certificate of airworthiness
(CofA) and restricted certificate of airworthiness (RCofA) forms). This guidance
replicates the same instructions as those provided already by the Agency in a letter
addressed to the Member States in 2004, expanding the use of the Block 4 also to
RCofA. The instructions provided in this NPA are, compared to the instructions in the
letter, updated to be in line with the current list of aircraft certification specifications
published by EASA.
— GM 21.B.325(b) is also amended for coherence.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 9 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
3. Proposed amendments
The text of the amendment is arranged to show deleted text, new or amended text as shown
below:
(a) deleted text is marked with strike through;
(b) new or amended text is highlighted in grey;
(c) an ellipsis (…) indicates that the remaining text is unchanged in front of or following the
reflected amendment.
3.1. Draft regulation (draft EASA opinion)
3.1.1. Changes to the cover regulation of Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012
A new point 3 is added to Article 2 as follows:
3. The application for an airworthiness certificate for a new aircraft, whose manufacturer has
demonstrated its production capability in accordance with point 2 of Article 9, will be accompanied by
a statement signed by the exporting authority confirming that the aircraft conforms to a design
approved by the Agency.
3.1.2. Changes to Annex I (Part-21) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012
21.A.174 is amended as follows:
21.A.174 Application
(…)
(b) Each application for a certificate of airworthiness or restricted certificate of airworthiness shall
include:
(…)
(2) with regard to new aircraft:
(i) a statement of conformity:
– issued under point 21.A.163(b); or
– issued under point 21.A.130 and validated by the competent authority; or
– for an imported aircraft, a statement signed by the exporting authority that
the aircraft conforms to a design approved by the Agency;
(i) when the aircraft has been produced under Part-21, a Form 52 issued under point
21.A.163(b), or issued under point 21.A.130 and validated by the competent authority;
(ii) a weight and balance report with a loading schedule;
(iii) the flight manual, when required by the applicable certification specifications for
the particular aircraft;
(3) with regard to used aircraft:
(i) originating from a Member State:
— an valid airworthiness review certificate issued in accordance with Part-M; and
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 10 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
— a copy of the certificate of airworthiness or restricted certificate of airworthiness
with the former registration.
(ii) originating from a non-member State:
(…)
— a weight and balance report with a loading schedule corresponding to the aircraft
current configuration.
(…)
— a recommendation for the issuance of a certificate of airworthiness or restricted
certificate of airworthiness and an airworthiness review certificate following an
airworthiness review in accordance with M.A.904 of Part-M.
(4) with regard to aircraft which were excluded from the applicability of the Regulation (EC)
No 216/2008 in accordance with Article 1 (2)(a), being only operated as ‘State aircraft’ for
the Member State that will receive the application:
(i) a weight and balance report corresponding to the aircraft current configuration,
(ii) the flight manual, when such manual is required by the applicable airworthiness code
for the particular aircraft type,
(iii) historical records to establish the production, modification, and maintenance standard
of the aircraft, including all limitations associated with a restricted certificate of
airworthiness under 21.B.327(c),
(iv) a recommendation for the issuance of an airworthiness review certificate following an
airworthiness review in accordance with M.A.904 of Part-M,
(v) unless the airworthiness status of the aircraft is established by the former ‘State
aircraft’ aviation authority and declared in an airworthiness statement acceptable to
the competent authority of the Member State of registry, the application shall allow
determining the airworthiness status of the aircraft at the time of transfer. This shall
be achieved when
(A) The competent authority of the Member State of registry is satisfied that the
issue of an airworthiness statement has not been denied by the former ‘State
aircraft’ aviation authority because of airworthiness concerns.
(B) Evidence as to what approved design the aircraft was initially built and delivered
is available.
(C) A continuing airworthiness management organisation appropriately approved in
accordance with point M.A.711(b) of Annex I (Part-M) to Commission Regulation
(EU) No 1321/2014 develops an evaluation programme detailing the required
inspection and investigation activities to be conducted to compensate for the
missing airworthiness statement by the former ‘State aircraft’ aviation authority.
The evaluation programme shall specify the activities to be performed to identify
the status of the aircraft with regard to EASA approved type design,
modifications, repairs and maintenance. This programme shall be accepted by the
competent authority before the evaluation is conducted.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 11 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
(D) The results of the evaluation programme have been summarised in an evaluation
report, appropriately considered during the required airworthiness review in
accordance with M.A.904 of Part-M, and supplied to the competent authority
together with the recommendation for the issuance of an airworthiness review
certificate.
(c) Unless otherwise agreed, the statements referred to in points (b)(2)(i), and (b)(3)(ii) and
(b)(4)(v) shall be issued no more than 60 days before presentation of the aircraft to the
competent authority of the Member State of registry.
(d) By way of derogation from the first paragraph of 21.A.174(b)(3)(ii), in exceptional cases an
application without a statement reflecting the airworthiness status of the aircraft may be made,
provided that:
(1) The competent authority of the Member State of registry is satisfied that the airworthiness
statement has not been denied by the former State of registry because of airworthiness
concerns.
(2) Evidence as to what approved design the aircraft was initially built and delivered is
available.
(3) A continuing airworthiness management organisation appropriately approved in
accordance with M.A.711(b) of Annex I (Part-M) to Commission Regulation (EU)
No 1321/2014 develops an evaluation programme detailing the required inspections to
compensate for the missing assessment and airworthiness statement by the former State
of registry. The programme shall specify the activities to be performed to identify the
status of the aircraft with regard to the EASA approved type design, modifications, repairs
and maintenance. This programme shall be accepted by the competent authority before
the evaluation is conducted.
(4) The results of the evaluation programme have been summarised in an evaluation report,
appropriately considered during the required airworthiness review in accordance with Part-
M, and provided to the competent authority together with the recommendation for the
issuance of an airworthiness review certificate (ARC).
(e) By way of derogation from 21.A.174(b)(3)(i), an application may be made for an airworthiness
certificate for an aircraft originating from a Member State for which, in accordance with
21.A.181, its airworthiness certificate is no longer valid. In this case a recommendation for the
issuance of an ARC, following the process described in M.A.904 of Annex I (Part-M) to
Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014, shall be provided with the application.
21.A.179 Transferability and re-issuance within Member States is amended as follows.
21.A.179 Transferability and re-issuance within a Member States
(a) Where the person responsible for the continuing airworthiness ownership of an aircraft has
changed:
1. if it and the aircraft remains on the same register, the airworthiness certificatecertificate
of airworthiness, or the restricted certificate of airworthiness conforming to a restricted
type-certificate only, shall be transferred together with the aircraft;.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 12 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
2. if the aircraft is registered in another Member State, the certificate of airworthiness, or the
restricted certificate of airworthiness conforming to a restricted type-certificate only, shall
be issued:
(i) upon presentation of the former certificate of airworthiness and of a valid
airworthiness review certificate issued under Part M; and
(ii) when satisfying point 21.A.175.
(b) Where ownership of an aircraft has changed, and the aircraft has a restricted certificate of
airworthiness not conforming to a restricted type-certificate, the airworthiness certificates shall
be transferred together with the aircraft provided the aircraft remains on the same register, or
issued only with the formal agreement of the competent authority of the Member State of
registry to which it is transferred.
The current 21.B.320 is amended as follows:
21.B.320 Investigation
(a) Except for the issuance of airworthiness certificates described in 21.B.326(b) and 21.B.327(a)(2),
tThe competent authority of the Member State of registry shall perform sufficient investigation
activities for an applicant for, or holder of, an airworthiness certificate to justify the issuance,
maintenance, amendment, suspension or revocation of the certificate or permit.
(…)
The current 21.B.326 is amended as follows:
21.B.326 Certificate of airworthiness
The competent authority of the Member State of registry shall issue a certificate of airworthiness for:
(…)
(b) used aircraft originating from a Member State: 1 upon presentation of the documentation
required in 21.A.174(b)(3)(i) and upon satisfying the language requirements in 21.A.175.
demonstrating that:
(i) the aircraft conforms to a type design approved under a type-certificate and any
supplemental type-certificate, change or repair approved in accordance with this
Annex I (Part-21); and
(ii) the applicable airworthiness directives have been complied with; and
(iii) the aircraft has been inspected in accordance with the applicable provisions of Annex I
(Part-M) of Regulation (EC) No 2042/2003;
2. when the competent authority of the Member State of registry is satisfied that the aircraft
conforms to an approved design and is in a condition for safe operation. This may include
inspections by the competent authority of the Member State of registry.
(c) used aircraft originating from a non-Member State or ‘State aircraft’:
1. upon presentation of the documentation required in 21.A.174(b)(3)(ii) or (b)(4),
demonstrating that:
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 13 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
(i) the aircraft conforms to a type design approved under a type certificate and any
supplemental type certificate, change or repair approved in accordance with this
Annex (Part-21); and
(ii) the applicable airworthiness directives have been complied with; and
(iii) the aircraft has been inspected in accordance with the applicable requirements of
Annex I (Part-M) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014;
2. when the competent authority of the Member State of registry is satisfied that the aircraft
conforms to an approved design and is in a condition for safe operation. This may include
inspections by the competent authority of the Member State of registry.
The current 21.B.327 is amended as follows:
21.B.327 Restricted certificate of airworthiness
(…)
(…)
2. used aircraft originating from a Member State: (i) upon presentation of the documentation
required in 21.A.174(b)(3)(i) and upon satisfying the language requirements in
21.A.175.demonstrating that:
(A) the aircraft conforms to a design approved by the Agency under a restricted type
certificate or in accordance with specific airworthiness specifications and any
supplemental type-certificate change or repair approved in accordance with this
Annex I (Part 21); and
(B) the applicable airworthiness directives have been complied with; and
(C) the aircraft has been inspected in accordance with the applicable provisions of
Annex I (Part-M) of Regulation (EC) No 2042/2003;
(ii) when the competent authority of the Member State of registry is satisfied that the
aircraft conforms to the approved design and is in a condition for safe operation. This
may include inspections by the competent authority of the Member State of registry.
3. used aircraft originating from a non-Member State or ‘State aircraft’:
(i) upon presentation of the documentation required in 21.A.174(b)(3)(ii) or (b)(4),
demonstrating that:
(A) the aircraft conforms to a design approved by the Agency under a restricted type
certificate or in accordance with specific airworthiness specifications and any
supplemental type-certificate change or repair approved in accordance with this
Annex I (Part-21); and
(B) the applicable airworthiness directives have been complied with; and
(C) the aircraft has been inspected in accordance with the applicable requirements of
Annex I (Part-M) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014;
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 14 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
(ii) when the competent authority of the Member State of registry is satisfied that the
aircraft conforms to an approved design and is in a condition for safe operation. This
may include inspections by the competent authority of the Member State of registry.
3.1.3. Changes to Annex I (Part-M) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014
M.A.707 is amended as follows:
(a) (…)
3. For used aircraft to be imported into the EU, this staff shall, in addition to the requirements
laid down in M.A.707(a)1 or (a)2 as appropriate, have acquired the technical competence
and experience necessary to determine that the aircraft meets the requirements of M.A.904
at the time of import.
(b) Airworthiness review staff nominated by the approved continuing airworthiness organisation can
only be issued an authorisation by the approved continuing airworthiness organisation when
formally accepted by the competent authority after satisfactory completion of an airworthiness
review under the supervision of the competent authority or under the supervision of the
organisation's airworthiness review staff in accordance with a procedure approved by the
competent authority. The organisation shall also specifically authorise the airworthiness review
staff referred to in M.A.707(a)(3).
(…)
M.A.710 is amended as follows:
(a) To satisfy the requirement for the airworthiness review of an aircraft referred to in point
M.A.901, a full documented review of the aircraft records shall be carried out by the approved
continuing airworthiness management organisation in order to be satisfied that:
(…)
8. from the time when the aircraft is covered by the scope of this regulation, all maintenance
performed has been released in accordance with Annex I (Part-M); and
(…)
M.A.904 is amended as follows:
(a) When importing an aircraft onto a Member State register from a third country or an aircraft
referred to in Article 1 (2)(a) of Regulation (EC) No 216/2008, the applicant shall:
(…)
2. for aircraft other than new, have an airworthiness review carried out satisfactorily in
accordance with point M.A.901, including the assessment of the aircraft configuration; and
3. have all maintenance carried out to comply with the approved applicable maintenance
programme in accordance with point M.A.302.
(…)
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 15 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
(e) The Member State shall also issue the airworthiness review certificate valid normally for one
year unless the Member State has safety reason to limit the validity.
(f) In the case that an evaluation programme is required in accordance with 21.A.174, the
evaluation report shall be taken into consideration by the continuing airworthiness
management organisation performing the airworthiness review required by M.A.904(a)2. It
shall be submitted to the competent authority together with the documented recommendation
required by M.A.904(b).
3.2. Draft acceptable means of compliance and guidance material (draft EASA decision)
3.2.1. Changes to AMC/GM to Annex I (Part-21) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012
New AMC 21.A.174 and GM 21.A.174 are added:
GM 21.A.174, 21.B.326 and 21.B.327 ‘Member State of registry’ and ‘State aircraft’.
The ‘competent authority of the Member State of registry' referred in these paragraphs is the
competent authority that will be responsible for the oversight of the aircraft once the application
process is successfully completed. The ‘Member State of registry’ is also referred as the ‘importing
Member State’.
A ‘State aircraft’ referred in these paragraphs is an aircraft referred to in paragraph 2(a) of Article 1 of
Regulation (EC) No 216/2008, which carries out military, customs, police, search and rescue,
firefighting, coastguard, or similar activities or services for a Member State.
GM 21.A.174(b)(3)(ii) and (d) Airworthiness Statement
The intention of the airworthiness statement of the previous ICAO contracting State of registry, i.e.
exporting State, is to reflect the airworthiness status of the aircraft at the time of import. This means
as close as practicable to the point in time when the oversight responsibility of the exporting State
ends. Normally, this is documented by the date of de-registration.
An airworthiness statement issued by the exporting State should:
— either declare compliance with the Agency´s approved type design (built standard,
modifications, repairs) at the time of import, or state any deviations thereof if this has been
previously agreed and accepted in writing by the competent authority of the importing Member
State, and
— confirm that the aircraft is airworthy in accordance with continuing airworthiness requirements
of the exporting State at the time of import.
The importing Member State should insist on a statement reflecting the airworthiness status of the
aircraft at the time of import. In the absence of such statement, the airworthiness status of an aircraft
in the previous regulatory system cannot be determined by an importing Member State or by the
applicant requesting the issuance of an airworthiness certificate unless they possess a thorough
knowledge of the aviation legislation and the acceptable procedures of the exporting State.
Certain exceptional circumstances may warrant acceptance of an application without a current
airworthiness statement from the former State of registration. These exceptional circumstances do
not include lack of procedural knowledge and/or commercial or time considerations but may be
circumstances such as:
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 16 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
— civil disturbances or war in the territory of the former State of registry; or
— discontinuation of the former State of registry´s civil aviation authority; or
— significant and continued non-compliances with ICAO minimum airworthiness standards by the
former State of registry; or
— unwillingness of the former State of registry to cooperate as foreseen by ICAO.
AMC 21.A.174(b)(4)(v)(B) and (d)(2) Acceptable evidences of the initial built standard
Evidence as to what approved design the aircraft was initially built to may be constituted by:
— a conformity statement issued by the production organisation that manufactured and delivered
the aircraft, clearly identifying the aircraft and its type design, at the time of initial delivery; or
— a certificate of airworthiness for export issued by the State of manufacture, clearly identifying
the aircraft and its type design, at the time of initial delivery; or
— any other conformity statement issued by the State of manufacture or the production
organisation that manufactured and delivered the aircraft, clearly identifying the aircraft and its
type design, at the time of initial delivery.
AMC 21.A.174(b)(4)(v)(C) and (d)(3) Evaluation programme
The evaluation programme is not intended to replace the standard airworthiness review activities
required by Part-M but to complement them.
1) Preconditions to establish an evaluation programme
a) Previous maintenance programme and sufficient historical records generated under the
foreign regulatory system are available to either completely satisfy the continuing
airworthiness record requirements to a level equivalent to M.A.305 of Commission
Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014, Annex I (Part-M), or to allow reconstruction of missing
records
b) Journey logs and/or technical logs are available to establish previous aircraft operation,
aircraft utilisation and aircraft operating environment.
2) Considerations to be included in the development of the evaluation programme
The following factors should be assessed and considered in the development of the evaluation
programme:
a) Conclusions drawn from a complete aircraft record review;
b) Aircraft age and ownership history (i.e. registrations, owners/operators);
c) Visual aircraft condition;
d) Aircraft storage condition;
e) Previous aircraft operating environment, previous aircraft operating profiles;
f) Any past experience relating to the import of aircraft that the CAMO developing the
evaluation programme had with the previous owner/operator;
g) Any past experience relating to the import of aircraft that the CAMO developing the
evaluation programme had with the previous State of registry.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 17 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
3) Content of the evaluation programme
The following content should be included in an evaluation programme to be proposed to the
competent authority:
a) Result of the record review performed, describing completeness, accuracy and quality of the
records received and description of any records which were reconstructed in accordance
with AMC M.A.305(h);
b) Identification of particular events that took place during the aircraft life and that could have
required unscheduled maintenance, such as: lightning strikes, hard landings, long term
storage, propeller or rotor over-speed, over-torque, impact on a main rotor blade, etc..
Assessment of aircraft airworthiness condition considering the records of the remedial
action taken to restore airworthiness after these events, if needed;
c) Conclusions which were drawn from factors listed in paragraph 2) above;
d) Proposed physical inspection and investigation activities suitable to:
i) identify the current aircraft configuration and deviations from the design approved by
the Agency;
ii) identify repairs, unrepaired damage and modifications performed on the aircraft in the
past, including inspections due to particular events described in b); and
iii) identify unclear or unacceptable design standards;
e) Proposed physical inspection and investigation activities suitable to:
i) identify maintenance standards that the aircraft was subjected in the past, and
ii) identify unclear or unacceptable maintenance standards;
f) Organisations required to determine the current aircraft configuration and to determine
deviations from an EASA approved design (e.g. POA, DOA, manufacturer, TC/STC holder,
CAMO, etc.);
g) Organisations required to support the inspection and investigation activities (e.g. CAMO,
AMO);
h) Documents used for determination of conformity with a design approved in accordance with
Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012;
i) Date and location of proposed inspections and investigations.
4) Acceptance of the evaluation programme by the new Member State of registry
If the competent authority finds that the proposed evaluation programme is suitable to properly
evaluate the aircraft configuration and maintenance status as delivered from the previous
register, it should accept the proposal and notify the applicant of its involvement in the proposed
inspection and investigation activities.
If the competent authority finds that the proposed evaluation programme is insufficient to
properly evaluate the aircraft configuration and maintenance status, as delivered from the
previous register, it should reject the evaluation proposal.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 18 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
AMC 21.A.174(b)(4)(v)(C) Evaluation programme for ‘State aircraft’
For the preparation of the evaluation programme in accordance with point 21.A.174(b)(4)(v)(C), the
following aspects regarding assessment and analysis of historical aircraft records should also be
considered:
— Previous Flight operations;
Assessment of the effects of the previous operating profile. Flights outside of the civil flight
manual limitations might require support from the TCH to address the impact on continued
airworthiness and life limitations;
Note: Any change of airworthiness limitations will have to be approved in accordance with
Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012.
— Modifications
Modifications and equipment previously fitted to the aircraft, which were intended to satisfy
the aircraft State role, need to be identified and must eventually be approved in accordance
with Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012 to remain on the aircraft or be removed from
the aircraft to restore or achieve an approved configuration.
Removing a modification may result in redundant requirements (e.g. mounting holes) which are
a deviation from the type design and should be approved. Also, if the steps are complex (such as
removal of wiring) then reversal of the modification may require detailed maintenance
instructions. In these cases, where a service bulletin from the aircraft manufacturer is not
available to remove the modification, a Part-21 organisation should generate suitable EASA
approved data to remove the modification.
— Maintenance and certification of maintenance
As the aircraft was excluded from the requirements of Commission Regulation (EC)
No 216/2008, the release certificates of maintenance should be reviewed to establish that the
maintenance performed and certified in accordance with equivalent standards to Annex I (Part-
M), was carried out by appropriately qualified personnel, being authorised by appropriately
approved organisations, and using approved data.
— Life Limitations
Assessments should be made to assure that aircraft systems and parts do, neither exceed the
airworthiness limitations approved in accordance with Commission Regulation (EU)
No 748/2012, nor the limitations established by the ‘State aircraft’ aviation authority, whichever
limit is less.
GM 21.A.174(b)(4) and (d) Process for application and issuance of a CofA or RCofA
The flow diagram illustrates the certificate of airworthiness (CofA) and restricted certificate of
airworthiness (RCofA) application process in the case of introduction of a ‘State aircraft’
(21.A.174(b)(4)) and import of a used aircraft originating from a non-Member State without a valid
airworthiness statement (21.A.174(d)).
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 19 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
The evaluation programme is intended to address the absence of an airworthiness statement issued
by the exporting authority and to supplement the airworthiness review process.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 20 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
21.A.174 Part-21
Application for CofA/RCofA
pre-application phase
no
Is it a used
aircraft?
yes
Is it a no Is a current yes
previous airworthiness
‘State statement
aircraft’ available?
yes no
early in the application phase
Submit docs iaw Submit docs iaw
21.A.174(b)(3) 21.A.174(b)(2)
Submit Submit application iaw
applicant application iaw 21.A.174(b)(3)(ii) and
21.A.174(b)(4) 21.A.174(d)
prepare evaluation
CAMO responsible programme iaw
for the evaluation 21.A.174(b)(4)(v)(C) or
21.A.174(d)(3)
Part-M
programme
CAMO responsible obtain competent
for the programme authority acceptance for
together with
competent authority the programme,
competent authority
defines its involvement evaluation iaw
CAMO responsible 21.A.174(b)(4)(v) or
for the evaluation 21.A.174(d), compile
programme (*) report and submit
report to CAMO
performing the
airworthiness review
CAMO performing
the AR and issuing the
recommendation for ARC(*) perform AR and issue
recommendation for
ARC
(*) Can either be two different CAMOs appropriately
late in the application phase approved iaw M.A.711(b) or can also be the same
CAMO performing both tasks
assess evaluation
competent authority report and ARC
recommendation &
issue CofA/RCofA iaw
21.B.326/327 and ARC
i.a.w. Part-M
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 21 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
GM 21.B.325 (a) is renamed amended as follows:
GM 21.B.325(a) & (b) Airworthiness certificates
1. Completion of the certificate of airworthiness by a Member State
Block 5: Insert restrictions developed in accordance with Part 21, including any reference to
limitations as indicated in GM 21.B21.B.320(b)(6).
2. Completion of the certificate of airworthiness (EASA Form 25) or of the restricted certificate of
airworthiness (EASA Form 24) by a Member State
Block 4: Use one or more of the following categories identified in the second column of this table:
Airworthiness code used for certification CofA category (Block 4)
CS-LSA Light sport aeroplane
CS-VLA Very light aeroplane
CS-VLR Very light rotorcraft
CS-22 Sailplane or powered sailplane-utility and/or aerobatic
category
CS-23 Normal, utility, aerobatic or commuter category aeroplane
CS-25 Large aeroplane
CS-27 Small rotorcraft
CS-29 Large rotorcraft
CS-31HB Hot-air balloon
CS-31GB Free gas balloon
CS-31TGB Tethered gas balloon
When an aircraft has been certificated in more than one category, all categories should be referenced.
For those aircraft certified in accordance with a national code which does not reference a category
equivalent to those specified in the above table, the type certificate data sheet (TCDS) reference
determined in accordance with Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012 Article 3(1)(a) should be
specified in Block 4.
Block 5: Insert restrictions developed in accordance with Part-21, including any reference to
limitations as indicated in GM 21.B.320(b)(6).
GM 21.B.325 (b) is renamed amended as follows:
GM 21.B.325(b)(c) Completion of the Aairworthiness Rreview Ccertificate by a Member State
1 Purpose: In accordance with the applicable continuing airworthiness requirements a certificate of
airworthiness is valid only if a valid airworthiness review certificate issued in accordance with Part-M
is attached to it. For new aircraft, the competent authority will issue the airworthiness review
certificate when issuing the certificate of airworthiness.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 22 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
3.2.2. Changes to AMC/GM to Annex I (Part-M) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014
New GM M.A.304 is added:
GM M.A.304 Data for modifications and repairs
The aircraft configuration is the consistent set of its functional and physical characteristics, as defined
in the applicable aircraft documentation.
The understanding of the aircraft configuration is essential to ensure the aircraft continuing
airworthiness. For each individual aircraft, this is defined by means of a complete description of the
aircraft type design, plus all embodied modifications and repairs.
The configuration of an individual aircraft is the baseline for determining the aircraft physical
conformity with the approved design. Also, some elements of the configuration of the individual
aircraft influence the contents of the aircraft maintenance programme, the aircraft flight manual, etc.
While the embodiment of a single modification or repair on an aircraft compliant with M.A.304 cannot
affect the safety of an individual aircraft, the joint impact of several independently approved
modifications or repairs is not assessed during their approval process and, if embodied on the same
individual aircraft may affect its airworthiness. The management of the aircraft configuration is the
responsibility of the person responsible for its continuing airworthiness. This person has to assess,
prior to the embodiment of a new modification or repair, that:
(i) the modifications and/or repairs are in compliance with M.A.304, and;
(ii) the new modification and/or repair will not conflict with the modifications and repairs already
embodied, affecting thus the aircraft airworthiness.
New AMC M.A.707(a)(3) is added:
AMC M.A.707(a)(3) Airworthiness review staff
The demonstration that an aircraft conforms to a design approved under Commission Regulation (EU)
No 748/2012 at the time of its import into the EU regulatory system requires confirmation that the
approval process applied to modifications to the type design and repairs embodied is in accordance
with European rules, taking also into account bilateral agreements signed by the EU.
Airworthiness review staff should have acquired the technical competence and experience necessary
to conduct an airworthiness review for importing an aircraft as described in M.A.904, and also
knowledge of the applicable bilateral agreements, before carrying out airworthiness reviews for used
aircraft to be imported into the EU. In particular, this airworthiness review staff should possess:
1. Technical competence that allows for determining the required steps to achieve that the
configuration of the imported aircraft is compliant with applicable European rules. This
knowledge may be gained through a training course that focuses on the design approval process
of Part-21 and the alleviations for import established in EU bilateral agreements.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 23 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
2. Experience acquired after satisfactory completion of an airworthiness review for importing a used
aircraft under supervision by their organisation, which should record the performance of this
airworthiness review and the assessment of the staff.
AMC M.A.904 (a)(2) is amended as follows:
AMC M.A.904 (a)(2) Airworthiness reviews of aircraft imported into the EU
1. When performing an airworthiness review of aircraft imported into the EU the aircraft and the
relevant records should be reviewed to determine the work to be undertaken to establish the
airworthiness of the aircraft, in accordance with Part-21 of Commission Regulation EU
No 748/2012 and Part-M.
Records should be available in English or any other language acceptable to the competent
authority.
2. In determining the work to be undertaken during the airworthiness review on the aircraft, the
following should be taken into consideration:
(a) the information from third country authorities such as export certificates, primary authority
information;
(b) the information on aircraft maintenance history to meet continuing airworthiness record
system’s requirements equivalent to those specified in M.A.305, and M.A.306 if applicable.
such as continuing airworthiness records, aircraft, engine, propeller, rotor and life limited part
log books or cards as appropriate, tech log/flight log/cabin log, list of deferred defects, total
flight times and cycles, times and cycles since last maintenance, accident history, former
maintenance schedule, former AD compliance status;
When assessing the aircraft continuing airworthiness records, the following should be
considered:
— Missing records may be reconstructed in accordance with AMC M.A.305(h);
— Previous maintenance, performed on the aircraft and its components and released to
service under third country´s airworthiness requirements, is deemed acceptable as long
as the aircraft was on the third country´s register and the maintenance was performed
in accordance with standards at least equivalent to Part-M. This requires that the
maintenance performed and certified in accordance with equivalent standards to
Annex I (Part-M), was carried out by appropriately qualified personnel, being authorised
by appropriately approved organisations, and using approved data;
— Repaired parts subject to schedule maintenance (e.g. inspections or overhaul) or
airworthiness limitations should be accompanied by authorised release certificates,
EASA Forms 1 or certificates considered equivalent to Part-M;
— Maintenance not performed to this required level, or in case of doubt, needs to be
included into the bridging programme of subparagraph (e);
— If components subject to an airworthiness limitation have been replaced since new, the
records of such components should show them as being produced by the respective
original equipment manufacturer (OEM) and the part numbers verified to be eligible for
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 24 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
installation according to a design approved under Commission Regulation (EU)
No 748/2012. If the components do not satisfy these criteria then their eligibility for
installation should be separately verified by reference to acceptable Part-21 design
approval and to a Form 1, or equivalent in accordance to applicable rules, with regard to
the manufacturing of new parts.
(c) the information on aircraft such as aircraft, engine and propeller type certificate datasheets ,
noise and emission certificate data sheets, flight manual and supplements;
(d) the aircraft continuing airworthiness status such as the aircraft and component AD status, the
SB status, the maintenance status, the status of all service life limited components, weight and
centre of gravity schedule including equipment list;
(e)(d) the modification and repair status of the aircraft detailing elements such as
owner/operator designed modifications and repairs, unintended deviations/concessions
originating from production, STCs, and parts needing European parts approval (EPA);
(f) the aircraft cabin configuration such as emergency equipment fitted, cockpit configuration,
placards, instrument limitations, cabin layout;
(g)(e) the maintenance needed for import, such as embodiment of modifications needed to
comply with the EASA type certificate and the, bridging check to comply with the new
maintenance programme;
(h) the avionics such as, but not limited to, radio and navigation equipment, instrument flight
rules (IFR) equipment, digital flight data recorder (DFDR)/cockpit voice recorder (CVR) test,
emergency locator transmitter (ELT) 406 MHz code and identification;
(i) the compass compensation;
(j) special operating rules such as extended twin-engine operations (ETOPS)/long range
operations (LROPS), reduced vertical separation minima (RVSM), minimum navigation
performance specifications (MNPS), all weather operations (AWOPS), area navigation (RNAV);
(k)(f)the aircraft survey including verification of conformity with the flight manual and the
datasheet, presence of fire proof identification plates, conformity of markings including
registration presence and serviceability of emergency equipment, internal and external
lighting systems, and
(l)(g)check flight including check of control system/cockpit ground check/engine run up.operational
checks to verify proper functioning of aircraft systems and controls; this might include engine
run-ups or check flights if verification of required functions cannot be checked on ground.
(h) in case the airworthiness statement referred to in 21.A.174 is missing, the evaluation report
required by M.A.904(f).
AMC M.A.904 (b) is amended as follows:
AMC M.A.904 (b) Airworthiness reviews of aircraft imported into the EU
(…)
(b) Aircraft information
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 25 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
(…)
- export certificate number, or identification of the evaluation report required by M.A.904(f);
(c) Documents accompanying the recommendation
(…)
- original export certificate or the evaluation report required by M.A.904(f);
(…)
(e) Aircraft check flight
- a copy of the check flight report, if applicable.
New GM M.A.904 (a)(2) is added:
GM M.A.904(a)(2) Airworthiness review of aircraft imported into the EU
When importing an aircraft, the demonstration that an aircraft conforms to an approved design
depends on the quality of the aircraft physical survey and of the records arising from the management
of the aircraft configuration.
At the time of import of a used aircraft, when assessing its configuration, it is necessary to address the
potential interrelation between multiple modifications and/or repairs particularly when such
modifications and/or repairs are designed by different persons or organisations. To this extent, the
organisation conducting the airworthiness review for import should:
(i) collect the necessary aircraft design-related documents or data, and
(ii) determine that the design of modifications or repairs embodied meet the applicable
airworthiness requirements and assess if their combined effect may have a safety impact. Due
consideration shall be given to the bilateral agreements in force at the time of import and to
declarations issued by the former State of registry.
When assessing if aircraft modifications interrelate, the organisation conducting the airworthiness
review should determine the need for assistance by the aircraft type certificate holder or other
relevant organisation holding embodied design approvals.
New GM M.A.904(f) is added:
GM M.A.904(f) Evaluation report for imports without an airworthiness statement
The evaluation report required in M.A.904(f) should contain at least the following information:
— A reference to the accepted evaluation programme;
— A description of the inspection and investigation activities performed;
— A description of the inspection and investigation results;
— A listing and justification of deviations from the accepted programme. Significant deviations
from the accepted programme need to be agreed with the competent authority in advance.
Appendix V to AMC M.A.704 is amended as follows:
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 26 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
3. Proposed amendments
Appendix V to AMC M.A.704
[…]
4.4 Additional procedures for recommendations to competent authorities for the import of aircraft
(This paragraph should describe the additional tasks regarding the recommendation for the issuance of
an airworthiness review certificate in the case of import of aircraft. This should include:
— communication with the competent authority of registry;,
— additional items to be reviewed during the airworthiness review of the aircraft to be imported
such as the management of aircraft design approvals, for example:
several approvals that could potentially interrelate and the need to seek support from the
(supplemental) type certificate holder,
changes/repairs classification,
consideration of PMA parts and TSO articles, and,
owner/operator produced articles in the light of applicable bilateral agreements;
— specification of maintenance required to be carried out;,
— etc.).
[…]
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 27 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
4.1. Issues to be addressed
Under European airworthiness rules, the airworthy aircraft are issued with a certificate of
airworthiness (CofA) and with an airworthiness review certificate (ARC):
— The CofA is issued for new aircraft when it is shown that the aircraft has been produced
conforming to an approved design. Also for used aircraft, a CofA is issued when the
aircraft is imported from another State, once it is shown at the time of import that the
aircraft correspond to an approved design, meets its production standard and the
continuing airworthiness requirements. For both new or used aircraft, the process to
issue a CofA is regulated in Part-21 and the airworthiness certificate has unlimited
validity. The process of transferring aircraft between Member States is also addressed in
Part-21.
— During the life of the aircraft an ARC is issued periodically after satisfactorily undergoing
an airworthiness review conducted in accordance with Part-M. The ARC is valid for a
definite time period, up to 36 months.
The CofA is only valid in combination with a valid ARC and both valid certificates are required to
fly the aircraft10.
The processes to obtain both certificates are typically linked and, depending on the country,
they are also related to the process of registering the aircraft. Aircraft registration is subject to
national rules, outside the Agency’s scope.
The Agency acknowledges that in the current requirements in Part-21 and Part-M, in relation to
the import of an aircraft, there is some room for improvement of the way the requirements are
articulated, as regularly competent authorities and stakeholders raise questions in this area.
In particular, the Agency, based on stakeholders feedback, identified the following reasons for
initiating this rulemaking activity (already listed in the ToR of the rulemaking task):
(1) For an aircraft imported into the EU, the issuance of a CofA is currently regulated under
Part-21, Subpart H — ‘Certificates of Airworthiness and Restricted Certificates of
Airworthiness’, in particular by paragraphs 21.A.174 and 21.B.325. Paragraph 21.A.174
refers to Part-M with regard to the recommendation for the issuance of an Airworthiness
Review Certificate (ARC), and Part-M presents in M.A.710 the requirement for conducting
an airworthiness review in order to issue a recommendation for the issuance of an ARC
by the competent authority. The main objectives of the airworthiness review are to
establish the airworthiness status of the imported aircraft with regard to the European
rules, and to identify additional approvals, inspections, or maintenance tasks required to
ensure compliance with the European rules. Leased aircraft are subject to such review
when they change to ‘European registration’. Stakeholders expressed the need for
further clarification on certificates, documents, and records from the third country that
would be acceptable when performing the airworthiness review for these aircraft.
10
Under certain conditions, an aircraft can also fly with an RCofA or a Permit to Fly, as regulated under Part-21.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 28 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
(2) In the particular case of aircraft registered in a EU Member State, which are used by
third-country operators (and where the responsibilities of the State of registry have not
been transferred), the possibilities available in the Basic Regulation in order to amend
Part-M to give credit for the management of the airworthiness and the maintenance
performed by the foreign operator/maintenance organisation, should be evaluated
(instead of requiring a contract with a CAMO and the maintenance being performed by a
Part-145 organisation). This should eliminate the need for the leasing companies to move
those aircraft outside the EU regulatory system.
(3) 21.A.174, in the case of import of a used aircraft, requires an airworthiness statement
from the exporting authority has led to different interpretations and discussions about
the consideration that should be given to this statement, particularly in cases where
there is no bilateral aviation agreement with the exporting State. Also, the case where
such export statement, or other documents required by 21.A.174 are not available,
should be addressed.
(4) The following case is not clearly addressed in the current requirements: when a national
aviation authority (NAA) receives an application for the issuance of a CofA for a used
aircraft that has not been flown for a certain period of time and its airworthiness
certificate or airworthiness review certificate is overdue, no person has been in charge of
its continuing airworthiness for a certain period of time and/or they have been
deregistered or transferred between Member States. In some cases the aircraft
concerned never had a CofA issued under European regulation, but instead under
previous Member State national regulations.
(5) There are also cases of applications for a CofA for aircraft which were previously outside
the scope of EASA, such as: military, police, or custom aircraft. This situation is not
specifically addressed in the existing Part-21 and Part-M requirements.
(6) It has been observed that Member States have different interpretations of the rules for
issuing the first CofA for a new aircraft produced in Europe. Examples are the need for
inspection, the required documentation, and incorporation of airworthiness directives.
There is a need to clarify those issues.
(7) Today, there is also room for different interpretation regarding the applicable
requirements in case a used aircraft is transferred from one Member State to another.
Improvement of the rules is needed to achieve consistent implementation and equal
treatment11.
(8) Finally, a need for guidance on the proper use of Box 4 in the EASA Forms 24 and 25 is
proposed to align with the ICAO provisions mandating identification of the aircraft
category in the airworthiness certificate.
11
It was never the intention within this rulemaking activity to address the validity of an ARC issued previously by an NAA or
CAMO in accordance with Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014 for a used aircraft which is changing registration.
This process was considered for discussion under rulemaking task RMT.0521, which led to NPA 2015-17 ‘Airworthiness
review (AR) process’. Therefore, this NPA does not cover the AR process or the ARC validity during aircraft transfers .
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 29 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
4.1.1. Safety risk assessment
When importing an aircraft it is important that its airworthiness status is thoroughly assessed.
Considering that the current rules are not suitable for all the cases that arise during the
importing process, it is possible that the lack of adequate regulation may lead to cases where
the aircraft being imported has some airworthiness flaws. This could be the case, for instance,
when an used aircraft is being imported into a Member State but there is no airworthiness
statement issued from the exporting authority.
The safety risks are identified as extremely improbable but with catastrophic potential
consequences. However, there are no safety occurrences and safety recommendations linked
to this RMT.
4.1.2. Who is affected?
The issue is of interest for owners/operators intending to operate aircraft once registered in the
EU, for CAMOs issuing recommendations for such aircraft and for competent authorities issuing
the airworthiness review certificates and the airworthiness certificates.
4.1.3. How could the issue/problem evolve?
If the regulations would not be amended as proposed, the inconsistencies for the process of
importing an aircraft between Part-M and Part-21 would remain and there would not be a
common approach within the Member States. The safety risk would remain unaddressed.
The identified non-compliance with ICAO with regard to the format of the CofA would remain.
4.2. Objectives
The objectives of the EU in the field of civil aviation are defined in Article 2 of the Basic
Regulation. This proposal will contribute to the achievement of these objectives by addressing
the issues outlined in Chapter 2.1 above.
The specific objectives of this proposal are:
— to mitigate potential safety risks linked to the fact that the aircraft did not comply with
the EU rules prior to being registered/imported, and to facilitate a common
understanding of the approach to be followed, in terms of recognition of other
certificates and/or records issued by other stakeholders to the aircraft involved; and
— to clarify current ambiguities in the rules related to issuance of CofA in order to achieve
standardised implementation and equal treatment in all Member States.
4.3. Policy options
The next paragraphs discusses the different options considered for the issues identified in
paragraph 4.1.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 30 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
List of options and initial content
Short title Description (linked to the points in paragraph 4.1)
Option 0 Do From a regulatory perspective
nothing
Option 1 Draft (1) Tailoring the airworthiness review and the recognition of relevant documents
rules for the cases where aircraft are being imported.
Amend the rule/AMC/GM to define the acceptance of documents/records/ certificates
issued with regard to the continuing airworthiness of an aircraft subject to foreign rules,
during the import process.
(2) Development of implementing rules for the continuing airworthiness of
European registered aircraft which are leased out to foreign countries.
Amend the continuing airworthines rules to permit that European-registered aircraft which
are being operated by third country operators (leased-out aircraft) follow less prescriptive
implementing rules to be created in Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014 that would allow the
aircraft owner to also fulfil the continuing airworthiness requirements imposed by the
foreign State of the operator.
(3) The missing airworthiness statement that is to be issued by the exporting
authority.
It is not that uncommon that, for different reasons, the airworthiness statement that has
to be issued by the authority where the aircraft was registered, which is required in
21.A.174(3)(ii), is missing at the time of import.
(4) (5) Two cases not explicitly addressed by the current provisions: aircraft with
invalid certificates and aircraft considered ‘State aircraft’.
Develop rule proposals to cover the following cases:
- The owner of an aircraft with an invalid airworthiness certificate, decides to restore
the airworthines of the aircraft so it can be granted with a new CofA and ARC.
- An aircraft which has been used for a purpose (e.g. military, custom or police) that
excluded it to be subject to civil European rules (i.e. the Basic Regulation and
implementing rules) and it is planned to be used for civil operations.
(6) Issuance of the first CofA to a new aircraft produced in Europe
Amend the rule paragraph 21.A.174 (or 21.A.163(b)) and/or develop guidance material
describing the process to be followed for the issuance of a CofA for a new aircraft.
(7) Clarify the process for transferring an aircraft between European Member
States.
Amend Part-21 paragraph 21.B.320 in order to permit that the transfer of an aircraft
between Member States is not hindered.
(8) Clarify on the use of Box 4 of EASA Forms 24 and 25, CofA form and RCofA
form.
Amend the rule/AMC/GM to provide instructions on how to use Box 4 of Forms 24 and 25.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 31 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
Discarded items in Option 1
(2) Development of implementing rules for the continuing airworthiness of European
registered aircraft which are leased out to foreign countries.
At the time of publication of the ToR, it was the Agency’s understanding that leased-out aircraft
were requested by the State of the operator to follow the foreign continuing airworthiness rules
and, therefore, the aircraft airworthiness could not be managed by a CAMO i.a.w. Part-M, nor
could the aircraft be maintained in an organisation i.a.w. Part-145. On the contrary, during the
time taken for the rulemaking discussions, the lessors consulted by the Agency have stated that
in most of the countries to where they lease-out European aircraft, the foreign aviation
authority recognises European CAMO and Part-145 approved organisations as
suitable/approved to conduct these activities. It is also the lessor’s preference to retain the
aircraft under European registration, which retains the value of the asset and facilitates the
process of returning the aircraft when the lease contract ends.
Therefore ‘do nothing’ is the preferred option and the lessors will retain, where allowed by the
foreign State of operator, these aircraft under European registration (and subject to Part-M)
when leased-out outside Europe.
(6) Issuance of the first CofA to a new aircraft produced in Europe
The rulemaking group reviewed the existing requirements and specifically the cases that lead to
include this case in the ToR of the rulemaking task. The group concluded that the rule is clear
and does not need to be amended. Option 0 is the preferred option. The reported cases where
difficulties arose for the issuance of a CofA for a new aircraft were due to inadequate
implementation of the existing requirements and, if persistent, should be addressed by a
standardisation activity conducted by the Agency.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 32 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
List of options and final content
Short title Description (linked to the points in paragraph 4.1)
Option 0 Do nothing From a regulatory perspective
Option 1 Draft rules (1) Tailoring the airworthiness review and the recognition of relevant
documents for the cases where aircraft are being imported.
Amend the rule/AMC/GM to define the acceptance of documents / records /
certificates issued with regard to the continuing airworthiness of an aircraft subject
to foreign rules, during the import process.
(3) The missing airworthiness statement that is to be issued by the
exporting authority.
It is not that uncommon that, for different reasons, the airworthiness statement that
has to be issued by the authority where the aircraft was registered, which is required
in 21.A.174(3)(ii), is missing at the time of import.
(4) (5) Two cases not explicitly addressed by the current provisions: aircraft
with invalid certificates and aircraft considered ‘State aircraft’.
Develop rule proposals to cover the following cases:
- The owner of an aircraft with an invalid airworthiness certificate, decides to
restore the airworthines of the aircraft so it can be granted with a new CofA
and ARC.
- An aircraft which has been used for a purpose (e.g. military, custom or police)
that excluded it to be subject to civil European rules (i.e. the Basic Regulation
and implementing rules) and it is planned to be used for civil operations.
(7) Clarify the process for transferring an aircraft between European
Member States.
Amend Part-21 paragraph 21.B.320 in order to permit that the transfer of an aircraft
between Member States is not hindered.
(8) Clarify on the use of Box 4 of EASA Forms 24 and 25, CofA form and
RCofA form.
Amend the rule/AMC/GM to provide instructions on how to use Box 4 of Forms 24
and 25.
4.4. Analysis of impacts per criteria
The Agency believes that there are no significant social or economic impacts regarding the issues,
identified in Option 1. The potential impacts are with regard to harmonisation and safety benefits due
to the development of more clear requirements to be applied for specific cases which were not
regulated before.
4.4.1. Safety impact
Option 0 – Do nothing
The safety risks remains as identified in Section 4.1.1.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 33 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
Option 1 – Draft rules
The proposed changes to the IR and AMC/GM have been analysed from a safety impact
perspective. It is considered that the proposed text, once introduced as a regulation and
AMC/GM, will have a positive safety impact since it covers cases of import of aircraft which are
not widely considered in the current rules, therefore leaving certain aspects unaddressed or up
to the discretion of the involved parties. For instance, the proposed process to be followed
when an export airworthiness statement is missing, which it is not addressed in the current
rules, will provide a foundation for the safe importing process.
4.4.2. Environmental impact
No environmental impact is anticipated.
4.4.3. Social impact
No social impact is anticipated.
4.4.4. Economic impact
Option 0 – Do nothing
The issues identified in paragraph 4.1 will remain, leading to regulatory burdens and cost
inefficiency.
Option 1 – Draft rules
By providing better and coherent rules for the process of importing an aircraft,
operators/owners will have more certainty about the acceptance of the aircraft by the
corresponding NAAs. This can increase the mobility of the aircraft in and out the EASA remit and
provide adequate flexibility to the operators/owners. This can be of particular interest for
aircraft being leased from outside the EU for a long period of time.
The proposed amendments to the regulation would allow for some European aircraft excluded
from the Basic Regulation in accordance with Article 1.2, i.e. ‘State aircraft’, to be issued with a
CofA and an ARC and be used for civil operation.
The rule also clarifies how to proceed for aircraft with an invalid airworthiness certificate to be
prepared again for operation.
Allowing these aircraft to be again civil-operated under the framework established by the Basic
Regulation may be an economic solution for some operators seeking an aircraft.
Cases described in issues (4) and (5), are likely to affect GA aircraft. If these cases were
regulated, it would provide aircraft owners certainty on the applicable process and, therefore,
facilitate a wider market of these aircraft, having a positive economic impact for their
community.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 34 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
Question to stakeholders – Economic impacts
1. What will be the costs, related with the implementation of Option 1?
a. costs for preparing, issuing documents / records / certificates in the import process
issued with regard to the continuing airworthiness of an aircraft subject to foreign
rules?
b. costs, related with the procedures for re-entering of an aircraft in the system with an
invalid CoA;
c. costs, related to the procedure for re-entering of an aircraft which has been used for
another purpose (e.g. military, custom or police) and it is planned to be used for civil
operations.
2. Stakeholders are invited to provide any other quantified justification elements on the
possible economic impacts (including benefits) of the options proposed, or alternatively to
propose another justified solution to the issue.
4.4.5. General Aviation (GA) and proportionality issues
Option 0 – Do nothing
The issues identified in paragraph 4.1 will remain, leading to regulatory burdens and cost
inefficiency.
Option 1 – Draft rules
This proposal is consistent with other rulemaking tasks that have introduced alleviations related
to GA. At least two of the cases identified in the ToR and addressed in the NPA are of interest of
the GA community: firstly, European-registered aircraft which were not in the scope of the Basic
Regulation (see point (5) of paragraph 4.1) that could be imported to operate as GA aircraft and
secondly, aircraft for which their airworthiness certificate has become invalid and are to be
flown again (see point (4) of paragraph 4.1). These two cases not solely affect GA, but the
majority of cases reported affect these aircraft/operations.
4.4.6. Impact on ‘better regulation’ and harmonisation
Option 0 – Do nothing
The issues identified in paragraph 4.1 will remain, leading to regulatory burdens and cost
inefficiency.
Option 1 – Draft rules
The amendments proposed in this NPA are expected to provide more certainty to stakeholders
importing aircraft since cases not being addressed by the existing rules are being dealt with. This
will achieve a more harmonised process for importing aircraft into Europe.
4.5. General justifications to select the preferred option for each item from the issue
analysis
(a) Tailoring the airworthiness review and the recognition of relevant documents for the
cases where aircraft are being imported.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 35 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
Table 1: Addressing point (1) of paragraph 4.1
Option No Description
0 Do nothing (from a regulatory perspective)
1 Amend the rule/AMC/GM to define the acceptance of
documents/records/certificates issued with regard to the continuing airworthiness
of an aircraft subject to foreign rules, during the import process.
Option 1 is the preferred option, because it addresses the problems identified in the
issue analysis (paragraph 4.1) and provides a safe and cost-effective framework. More
concretely, it addresses the issue of the existing rules that, in order to assess the
airworthiness status of the aircraft being imported, the rules foresee that an
airworthiness review is conducted in accordance with Part-M. This process requires
verification of specific records which are mandatory for European aircraft, but the same
records are not available for an aircraft that has been managed under a foreign system.
Therefore, this NPA proposes to amend paragraph M.A.710. With this amendment, it is
made explicit that the airworthiness records of the aircraft being imported, are not
supposed to comply with Part-M.
(b) The missing airworthiness statement that is to be issued by the exporting authority.
Table 2: Addressing point (3) of paragraph 4.1
Option No Description
0 Do nothing (from a regulatory perspective)
1 It is not that uncommon that, for different reasons, the airworthiness statement
that has to be issued by the authority where the aircraft was registered, which is
required in 21.A.174(3)(ii), is missing at the time of import.
The preferred option is No 1 because it addresses the problems identified in the issue
analysis (paragraph 4.1) and provides a safe regulatory framework. The rulemaking group
has considered different cases why this statement might be missing and the text of the
NPA proposes new requirements for alternative solutions to achieve the same objective
as with the missing airworthiness statement.
(c) Two cases are not explicitly addressed by the current requirements: aircraft with invalid
certificates and aircraft considered ‘State aircraft’.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 36 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
Table 3: Addressing point (4) and (5) of paragraph 4.1
Option No Description
0 Do nothing (from a regulatory perspective)
1 Develop rule proposals to cover the following cases:
- The owner of an aircraft with an invalid airworthiness certificate, decides to
restore the airworthines of the aircraft so it can be granted with a new CofA
and ARC.
- An aircraft which has been used for a purpose (e.g. military, custom or
police) that excluded it to be subject to civil European rules (i.e. the Basic
Regulation and implementing rules) and it is planned to be used for civil
operations.
In the past the NAAs queried the Agency on the process to be followed when aircraft
were re-entering the system after their airworthiness certificates (CofA and ARC) had
become invalid or when an ‘State aircraft’ was planned for future civil use and, therefore,
require a CofA and an ARC issued i.a.w. the implementing rules (Part-21 and Part-M). The
Agency believes that these cases need dedicated requirements in the rules.
Therefore, the preferred option is No 1 and the Chapter 3 of this NPA proposes the
related text.
(d) Clarify the process for transferring an aircraft between European Member States.
Table 4: Addressing point (7) of paragraph 4.1
Option No Description
0 Do nothing (from a regulatory perspective)
1 Amend Part-21 paragraph 21.B.320 in order to permit that the transfer of an
aircraft between Member States is not hindered.
The preferred option is No 1: By impeding that the competent authorities can conduct
investigations on aircraft being transferred from another Member State, having already a
CofA and an ARC issued in accordance with European rules, the change of registration of
airworthy aircraft within Europe would be made easier. Required amendments to the ARC
process are subject to NPA 2015-17.
(e) Clarify on the use of Box 4 of EASA Forms 24 and 25, CofA form and RCofA form.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 37 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
Table 5: Addressing point (8) of paragraph 4.1
Option No Description
0 Do nothing (from a regulatory perspective)
1 Amend the rule/AMC/GM to provide instructions on how to use Box 4 of Forms 24
and 25.
The preferred option is No 1: This provides clarity on the expected information on the
forms and it will allow to estate the aircraft category in the CofA in line with ICAO
provisions.
4.6. Conclusions
Option 1 is the preferred option for the following items:
(1) Tailoring the airworthiness review and the recognition of relevant documents for the cases where
aircraft are being imported.
(3) The missing airworthiness statement that is to be issued by the exporting authority.
(4)(5) Two cases which are not explicitly addressed by the current provisions, namely aircraft with
invalid certificates and aircraft considered ‘State aircraft’.
(7) Clarify the process for transferring an aircraft between European Member States.
(8) Clarify on the use of ‘Box 4’ of the EASA Forms 24 and 25, the CofA form and the RCofA form.
Option 0 (Do nothing) is the preferred option for the following items:
(2) Development of implementing rules for the continuing airworthiness of European registered
aircraft which are leased out to foreign countries.
(6) Issuance of the first CofA for a new aircraft produced in Europe.
Question to stakeholders
Stakeholders are also invited to provide any other quantitative information they may find necessary to
bring to the attention of the Agency.
As a result, the relevant parts of the RIA might be adjusted on a case-by-case basis.
4.7. Monitoring and evaluation
Monitoring is a continuous and systematic process of data collection and analysis for the
implementation/application of a rule/activity. It generates factual information for possible
future evaluation and impact assessments and helps to identify actual implementation
problems. The monitoring will occur in terms collecting and analysing data from different
available source through several tools e.g. feedback loops, standardisation activities, EASA
continuous monitoring, etc. The responsible actors for collecting and providing the data (e.g.
Member States, national authorities, operators, etc) will be further specified in the
implementation phase.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 38 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
The proposal might be subject to interim/on-going/ex-post evaluation which will judge how well
the adopted rules have performed (or are working), taking account of earlier predictions made
in this impact assessment. The evaluation will provide an evidence-based judgement of the
extent to which the proposal has been; relevant, given the needs and its objectives; effective
and efficient; coherent; and has achieved added-value at EU level.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 39 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
5. References
5. References
5.1. Affected regulations
— Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014 of 26 November 2014 on the continuing
airworthiness of aircraft and aeronautical products, parts and appliances, and on the
approval of organisations and personnel involved in these tasks (OJ L 362, 17.12.2014,
p. 1).
— Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012 of 3 August 2012 laying down implementing
rules for the airworthiness and environmental certification of aircraft and related
products, parts and appliances, as well as for the certification of design and production
organisations (OJ L 224, 21.8.2012, p. 1).
5.2. Affected CS, AMC and GM
— ED Decision 2015/029/R of 17 December 2015 issuing acceptable means of compliance
and guidance material to Part-M, Part-145, Part-66, and Part-147 of Regulation (EU)
No 1321/2014 and repealing Decision 2003/19/RM of the Executive Director of the
Agency of 28 November 2003.
— ED Decision 2012/020/R of the Executive Director of the Agency of 30 October 2012 on
acceptable means of compliance and guidance material for the airworthiness and
environmental certification of aircraft and related products, parts and appliances, as
well as for the certification of design and production organisations (‘AMC and GM to
Part-21’).
5.3. Reference documents
ICAO Doc 9760 was considered during the working group discussions in order to ensure
alignment of European rules with ICAO.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 40 of 41
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-08
6. Appendices
6. Appendices
N/A
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 41 of 41
An agency of the European Union
Saatja: Silja Vöörmann-Miloševic </O=MAJANDUS-TEEDE-SIDEMINISTEERIUM/OU=FIRST ADMINISTRATIVE GROUP/CN=RECIPIENTS/CN=SILJA.VOORMANN>
Saaja: Lennuameti Grupp, Gerli Rebane, Kertu Martšenkov, Priit Rifk, Andres Peterson
Teema: EASA NPA 2016-08 Import of aircraft from other regulatory system, and Part-21 Subpart H review
Hea lennundushuviline!
Euroopa Lennundusohutusamet (EASA) on avaldanud NPA 2016-08 seoses
õhusõiduki impordi ja Osa-21 alajao H ülevaatusega:
'Import of aircraft from other regulatory system, and Part-21 Subpart H
review’
<http://www.easa.europa.eu/document-library/notices-of-proposed-amendmen
t/npa-2016-08>
Kui soovite ülalviidatud ettepaneku sisu kommenteerida, siis palume
edastada kommentaarid EASA-le elektrooniliselt:
http://hub.easa.europa.eu/crt/ <http://hub.easa.europa.eu/crt/> .
Kommentaaride esitamise tähtaeg on 7. detsember 2016.
Heade soovidega
Silja Vöörmann-Milošević
Õigusnõunik
+372 610 3560
www.ecaa.ee <http://www.ecaa.ee/> | Lõõtsa 5, Tallinn 11415
Lennuamet