INTERNATIONAL CIVIL ORGANISATION DE L'AVIATION
AVIATION ORGANIZATION
INTERNATIONAL CIVIL CIVILE INTERNATIONALE
ORGANISATION DE L'AVIATION
European
AVIATIONandORGANIZATION
North Atlantic Office Bureau
CIVILEEurope et Atlantique Nord
INTERNATIONALE
European and North Atlantic Office Bureau Europe et Atlantique Nord
ORGANIZACIÓN DE AVIACIÓN МЕЖДУНАРОДНАЯ ОРГАНИЗАЦИЯ
CIVIL INTERNACIONAL
ORGANIZACIÓN DE AVIACIÓN ГРАЖДАНСКОЙОРГАНИЗАЦИЯ
МЕЖДУНАРОДНАЯ АВИАЦИИ
Oficina
CIVILEuropa y Atlántico Norte
INTERNACIONAL Европейское/Североатлантическое
ГРАЖДАНСКОЙ АВИАЦИИ бюро
Oficina Europa y Atlántico Norte Европейское/Североатлантическое бюро
3 bis villa Emile Bergerat, 92522 Neuilly-sur-Seine Cedex, France
When replying please quote
Reference : EUR/NAT 15-0631.TEC (HAS/LEJ) 31 December 2015
Subject : European Region (EUR) Operations Bulletin with guidelines to airspace users in order to
raise their awareness on State aircraft operations especially in the High Seas airspace over
the Baltic Sea - (EUR OPS Bulletin 2015_002)
Dear Madam, Sir,
1. I wish to refer to outcome of the 57th Meeting of the European Air Navigation Planning Group
in November 2015, which endorsed the promulgation of this EUR OPS Bulletin that addresses several
coordination issues and operational aspects identified in the Baltic Sea area.
2. The purpose of the European Operations Bulletin 2015_002, effective 15 December 2015 is to
promulgate guidelines to airspace users in order to raise their awareness on State aircraft operations under due
regard, or when State aircraft operations are conducted only partially in accordance with ICAO provisions,
especially in the High Seas airspace over the Baltic Sea. The Bulletin is available for download on the
EUR/NAT section of ICAO Public website (www.icao.int/EURNAT/), following the “EUR & NAT
Documents” link, then “EUR Documents” and “EUR OPS Bulletins” folder.
3. In view of the above, I wish to invite you to disseminate the document to all concerned aviation
stakeholders which operate in the airspace over the Baltic Sea. You are also invited to use the relevant
operational information/recommendations for re-publication in other individual formats, or in any other
information bulletin. The European Operations Bulletin 2015_002 will be reviewed and updated, when
necessary.
Yours sincerely,
Luis Fonseca de
Almeida
2016.01.05
16:15:56 +01'00'
Luis Fonseca de Almeida
ICAO Regional Director
Europe and North Atlantic
Enclosure : Attachment A – ICAO EUR OPS Bulletin 2015_002
Distribution: EUR/NAT States of accreditation and international organisations (including EASA)
National 01 46 41 85 85 National 01 46 41 85 00 E-mail:
[email protected]
Tel.: Fax:
International +33 1 46 41 85 85 International +33 1 46 41 85 00 Web: http://www.paris.icao.int
Serial Number: 2015_002 Effective: 15 December 2015
Subject: Guidelines to airspace users in order to raise their awareness on State aircraft
operations especially in the High Seas airspace over the Baltic Sea
The practical meaning for airspace users that are operating over the High Seas
• Within a Flight Information Region (FIR),
classes of airspace established for volumes of
airspace extending over the High Seas and
their associated rules apply only to civil
aviation. However, the safety of air navigation
is paramount for all airspace users.
• All airspace users must be aware that State
aircraft have the possibility to operate under
“due regard” over the High Seas as the access
of State aircraft to High Seas airspace cannot
be restricted.
• State aircraft will operate in compliance with
ICAO SARPS to the maximum extent
practicable, but can, due to mission
requirements, also operate under "due regard"
for the safety of navigation of civil aircraft.
When operating under "due regard", the State
aircraft is not subject to ATC, irrespective of
the declared airspace-class over the High Seas.
• A State aircraft operating under “due regard” might not have
filed a flightplan, might not necessarily establish radio
communications or enable its identification through means of
cooperative surveillance. State aircraft operating under “due
regard” are required to maintain safe separation from civil
aircraft flying in their proximity
• Civil Air Traffic Control (ATC) units have normally no
responsibilities for the separation of State aircraft when they
are operating under "due regard", and can only, when know to
them, provide traffic information to all other aircraft which
are in the vicinity of the particular State aircraft.
• All civil airspace users must adhere to ICAO SARPS, in
particular to the Rules of the Air in ICAO Annex 2, when
operating over the High Seas. They must be aware that State
aircraft are authorised to operate under "due regard" at any
time in the airspace over the High Seas.
Additional information can be found in:
- ICAO Circular 330, Civil/Military Cooperation in Air Traffic Management
- ICAO EUR Doc 032, Interim Guidance Material on Civil/Military Cooperation in ATM
EUR OPS BULLETIN 2015_002 2
The legal background
UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) with Relevance for Aviation
Article 2, Legal status of the territorial sea, of the air space over the territorial sea and of its bed and subsoil
1. The sovereignty of a coastal State extends, beyond its land territory and internal waters and, in the case of an
archipelagic State, its archipelagic waters, to an adjacent belt of sea, described as the territorial sea.
2. This sovereignty extends to the air space over the territorial sea as well as to its bed and subsoil.
3. The sovereignty over the territorial sea is exercised subject to this Convention and to other rules of international law.
Article 3, Breadth of the territorial sea
Every State has the right to establish the breadth of its territorial sea up to a limit not exceeding 12 nautical miles,
measured from baselines determined in accordance with this Convention.
Article 58, Rights and duties of other States in the exclusive economic zone
In the exclusive economic zone, all States, whether coastal or land-locked, enjoy, subject to the relevant provisions of
this Convention, the freedoms referred to in article 87 of navigation and over-flight and of the laying of submarine
cables and pipelines, and other internationally lawful uses of the sea related to these freedoms, such as those associated
with the operation of ships, aircraft and submarine cables and pipelines, and compatible with the other provisions of
this Convention.
Article 86
The provisions apply to all parts of the sea that are not included in the exclusive economic zone, in the territorial
sea or in the internal waters of a State, or in the archipelagic waters of an archipelagic State. This article does not
entail any abridgement of the freedoms enjoyed by all States in the exclusive economic zone in accordance with
article 58.
Article 87, Freedom of the high seas
The high seas are open to all States, whether coastal or land-locked.
1. Freedom of the high seas is exercised under the conditions laid down by this Convention and by other rules of
international law. It comprises, inter alia, both for coastal and land-locked States:
(a) Freedom of navigation
(b) Freedom of over-flight ……………………
Note : Turkey is not a signatory to the UNCLOS III from 1982 and their position is well known and remains unchanged
EUR OPS BULLETIN 2015_002 3
ICAO Provisions
The ICAO Chicago Convention in Article 3 (a) expressly excludes State aircraft from its
scope of applicability. Articles 3 (b), (c) and (d) further clarify the definition and scope of
application of the Articles of the Convention. As a consequence of Article 3, in particular
subparagraph 3 (d), States are required to safeguard navigation of civil aircraft when
setting rules for their State aircraft. This leaves it up to the individual State to regulate
these operations and services, generating a wide diversity of military regulations. However,
especially in congested airspace, harmonized regulation is a precondition for a safe, efficient
and ecologically sustainable aviation system.
At the same time, States are aware of the limitations of ICAO Standards and Recommended
Practices (SARPs) and designated Annexes to the Convention, including PANS and regional
supplementary procedures (SUPPs), as they relate to State/military aircraft and their services.
Indeed, as seen above, Article 3 of the Convention specifically exempts State aircraft from
compliance with articles of the Convention. More and more multinational military operations
that cross international boundaries require complex coordination and planning processes to
avoid unnecessary segregation or restrictions and to achieve the required level of safety.
In accordance with the Chicago Convention, Article 3 (b), “Aircraft used in military, customs and police services
shall be deemed to be State aircraft”. In broad terms, the right to access all airspace, within the limits of the
operational needs, is a crucial requirement to enable the military, customs and police to perform the security, defence
and law enforcement missions mandated by their States and by international agreements. It is, therefore, a fundamental
requirement that each State be able to train and operate its State aircraft effectively. In this manner, it is vital for State
aircraft to be provided access to sufficient space, enabling adequate opportunities for the training and execution of
security, defence and law enforcement elements.
In pursuit of their tasks, operators of State aircraft should, where practicable, respect
international, regional and State civil aviation legislation and aim for compliancy.
However, it is recognized that the nature of the defence and security tasks can create
unique situations that need special handling and considerations. In this regard, ICAO
Circular 330 chapter 5 explains in detail what roles are performed by military and
non-military flights under the title of “State aircraft”. It also highlights circumstances
when State aircraft can be fully compliant or partially compliant with international
civil aviation rules and procedures, as provided for in ICAO SARPs, and it lists the
general expectations for handling such aircraft by an air navigation service provider
(ANSP). A number of States and international organisations have regulated the
operation of State aircraft and made this information publicly available.
ICAO Annex 11 specifies a number of provisions that address the aspects of air traffic services over the High Seas,
including the division of airspace in Flight Information Regions (each under the responsibility of ICAO Member
States). The State that has accepted the provision of ATS over the High Seas must provide air traffic services in
accordance with Annex 11, but “may apply the SARPs in a manner consistent with that adopted for airspace under its
jurisdiction” and the obligation on States that their ATS authorities closely coordinate with military authorities on
activities that may affect flights of civil aircraft (e.g. provide flight plans and other relevant data)
In Summary
Over the High Sea only the relevant international law applies
All States enjoy the freedom to overfly the high seas and so
called “passages” (i.e. international straits)
High seas start outside the territorial sea and the territorial sea
extends up to a maximum of 12 NM from the national coastline
High Seas airspace is not territorial airspace, hence national
and/or other legislation DO NOT apply
ICAO SARPs apply to civil aircraft over the High Seas, but not
to State aircraft in military services (‘military aircraft’) or other
State aircraft
States must have due regard for the safety of civil aircraft and
must have established respective regulations for national State
aircraft
EUR OPS BULLETIN 2015_002 4
Notice
The purpose of European Operations Bulletin 2015_002 is to promulgate guidelines to airspace users in
order to raise their awareness on State aircraft operations under due regard, or when State aircraft operations
are conducted only partially in accordance with ICAO provisions, especially in the High Seas airspace over
the Baltic Sea.
This Bulletin was prepared in response to one of the recommendations from the ICAO Civil/Military
Cooperation Symposium (ICAO EUR/NAT Office, April 2015) and is also reflecting the outcome of the
Baltic Sea Project Team, which was established by the EANPG COG/62 Meeting (May 2015) to address
several coordination issues and operational aspects identified in the Baltic Sea area. It was endorsed by the
57th Meeting of the European Air Navigation Planning Group in November 2015.
EUR Ops Bulletins are used to distribute information on behalf of the European Air Navigation Planning
Group (EANPG). The material contained therein may be developed within the working structure of the
EANPG or be third party documents posted at the request of an EANPG Member State. A printed or
electronic copy of this Bulletin, plus any associated documentation, is provided to the recipient as is and
without any warranties as to its description, condition, quality, fitness for purpose or functionality and for
use by the recipient solely for guidance only. The information published by ICAO in this document is made
available without warranty of any kind; the Organization accepts no responsibility or liability whether direct
or indirect, as to the currency, accuracy or quality of the information, nor for any consequence of its use.
The designations and the presentation of material in this publication do not imply the expression of any
opinion whatsoever on the part of ICAO concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area of
its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
The EUR OPS Bulletin Checklist available on www.icao.int/EURNAT/ (EUR & NAT Documents, EUR
Documents), contains an up to date list of all current EUR Ops Bulletins.
There is no objection to the reproduction of extracts of information contained in this Bulletin if the source is
acknowledged.
Questions or comments regarding this OPS Bulletin may be directed to the ICAO European and
North Atlantic Office at
[email protected]
– END –
----------------------------------------------------------------
Official correspondence from ICAO EUR/NAT Office
----------------------------------------------------------------
Dear Sir/Madam,
Please find herewith attached my letter reference EUR/NAT 15-0631.TEC (HAS/LEJ) of 31 December
2015 regarding the European Operations Bulletin 2015_002, effective 15 December 2015.
This State letter is also available for download from the ICAO Secure Portal http://portal.icao.int/ , Group
EURNATSTATELETTERS.
Please consider the attached electronic letter as the official version. Printed copy will not be sent by
postal mail.
Note: Please do not reply to this email address. Your message should be sent to:
[email protected].
Yours sincerely,