Ref. Ares(2018)1133442 - 28/02/2018
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Innovation and Networks Executive Agency
Connecting Europe Facility (CEF) Department
Unit C4 – CEF Energy & ICT
Brussels, 28/02/2018
INEA/C4/AM/if
Ares(2018)
BY EMAIL ONLY
Ms Katrin Reinhold
Director General of the Health
and Welfare Information
Systems Centre (HWISC)
Uus-Tatari 25/Veerenni 13
10134 Tallinn
ESTONIA
Email:
[email protected]
Subject: Transmission of the signed Grant Agreement - Action n° 2017-EE-IA-
0009
Dear Ms Reinhold,
Please find herewith an electronically signed copy of the Grant Agreement n°
INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560. A copy of this Grant Agreement has been transmitted
for information to Ms Marika Priske, Secretary General at the Ministry of Social Affairs.
Furthermore I am pleased to inform you that, in line with article 4.1.2 of the above-
mentioned Grant Agreement, a pre-financing payment of 574,543 EUR has been made as
follows:
Account holder: Ministry of Finance
Account n°: EE221010220027690221; reference on payment: 2800048574
Should you have any questions relating to the implementation of the Grant Agreement,
you may contact Ms Aleksandra Małecka at (
[email protected]) who is the
Project Officer in charge at INEA.
Agence exécutive pour l'innovation et les réseaux /Uitvoerend Agentschap innovatie en netwerken, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel,
BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
Office: W910 - 01/107 - Tel. direct line +32 229-56391
[email protected]
I take this opportunity to wish you successful implementation and look forward to
continuing the good cooperation with you and your services for the successful outcome
of the Action.
Yours sincerely,
[e-Signed]
Susan Tournis
Deputy Head of Unit
Encl.: Grant Agreement No INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Copy: Mr Lehor Meius, HWISC (
[email protected])
2
Electronically signed on 12/02/2018 17:16 (UTC+01) in accordance with article 4.2 (Validity of electronic documents) of Commission Decision 2004/563
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
CEF general model agreement: 31 July 2014
Innovation and Networks Executive Agency
Department C - Connecting Europe Facility (CEF)
GRANT AGREEMENT
UNDER THE CONNECTING EUROPE FACILITY (CEF) -
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SECTOR
AGREEMENT No INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
The Innovation and Networks Executive Agency (INEA) ("the Agency"), under the
powers delegated by the European Commission ("the Commission"), represented for the
purposes of signature of this Agreement by the Head of Department C of the Agency,
Andreas Boschen,
on the one part,
and
1. Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre (HWISC)
Public law body
Registration No 70009770
Uus-Tatari 25 / Veerenni 13
10134 Tallinn
Estonia
VAT No EE101941259,
hereinafter referred to as “the coordinator”, represented for the purposes of signature of this
Agreement by Director General of the Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre,
Katrin Reinhold
and the following other beneficiaries:
2. Estonian Health Insurance Fund (EHIF) - established in Estonia
3. Estonian Social Insurance Board (ESIB) - established in Estonia
4. Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs (EMSA) - established in Estonia
duly represented by the coordinator by virtue of the mandates included in Annex IV for the
signature of this Agreement,
hereinafter referred to collectively as “the beneficiaries”, and individually as “beneficiary”
for the purposes of this Agreement where a provision applies without distinction between the
coordinator or another beneficiary,
1
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
on the other part,
HAVE AGREED
to the Special Conditions (hereinafter referred to as “the Special Conditions”) and the
following Annexes:
Annex I Description of the action
Annex II General Conditions (hereinafter referred to as “the General Conditions”)
Annex III Estimated budget of the action
Annex IV Mandates provided to the coordinator by the other beneficiaries
Annex V Model technical report(s)
Annex VI Model financial statement(s)
Annex VII Model terms of reference for the certificate on the financial statements
which form an integral part of this Agreement, hereinafter referred to as "the Agreement".
The terms set out in the Special Conditions shall take precedence over those set out in the
Annexes.
The terms of Annex II "General Conditions" shall take precedence over the other Annexes.
2
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
SPECIAL CONDITIONS
TABLE OF CONTENT
ARTICLE 1 – SUBJECT MATTER OF THE AGREEMENT
ARTICLE 2 – ENTRY INTO FORCE OF THE AGREEMENT AND DURATION OF
THE ACTION
ARTICLE 3 – MAXIMUM AMOUNT AND FORM OF THE GRANT
ARTICLE 4 – ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS ON REPORTING, PAYMENTS AND
PAYMENT ARRANGEMENTS
ARTICLE 5 – BANK ACCOUNT FOR PAYMENTS
ARTICLE 6 – DATA CONTROLLER AND COMMUNICATION DETAILS OF THE
PARTIES
ARTICLE 7 – ENTITIES AFFILIATED TO THE BENEFICIARIES
ARTICLE 8 – IMPLEMENTING BODIES DESIGNATED BY THE BENEFICIARIES
ARTICLE 9 – MONO-BENEFICIARY GRANT
ARTICLE 10 – ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS ON REIMBURSEMENT OF COSTS
DECLARED ON THE BASIS OF THE BENEFICIARY'S USUAL COST
ACCOUNTING PRACTICES
ARTICLE 11 – ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS ON USE OF THE RESULTS
(INCLUDING INTELLECTUAL AND INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY
RIGHTS)
ARTICLE 12 – OBLIGATION TO CONCLUDE AN INTERNAL CO-OPERATION
AGREEMENT
ARTICLE 13 – INAPPLICABILITY OF THE NO-PROFIT PRINCIPLE
ARTICLE 14 – INELIGIBILITY OF VALUE ADDED TAX
ARTICLE 15 – SPECIAL PROVISIONS ON ELIGIBLE COSTS
ARTICLE 16 – WAIVING OF THE OBLIGATION TO PROVIDE CERTIFICATES ON
THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
ARTICLE 17 – FINANCIAL SUPPORT TO THIRD PARTIES
ARTICLE 18 – IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTION TASKS BY BENEFICIARIES NOT
RECEIVING EU FUNDING
ARTICLE 19 – SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES WITH NON EU BENEFICIARIES
ARTICLE 20 – BENEFICIARIES WHICH ARE INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATIONS
ARTICLE 21 – JOINT AND SEVERAL FINANCIAL LIABILITY FOR RECOVERIES
ARTICLE 22 – IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTIVITIES NOT FINANCIALLY
SUPPORTED UNDER THE AGREEMENT
3
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ARTICLE 1 – SUBJECT MATTER OF THE AGREEMENT
The Commission has decided to award a grant, under the terms and conditions set out in the
Special Conditions, the General Conditions and the other Annexes to the Agreement, for the
action entitled "Estonian integration with the EESSI system" ("the action"), action number
2017-EE-IA-0009 as described in Annex I.
With the signature of the Agreement, the beneficiaries accept the grant and agree to
implement the action, acting on their own responsibility.
ARTICLE 2 – ENTRY INTO FORCE OF THE AGREEMENT AND DURATION OF
THE ACTION
2.1 The Agreement shall enter into force on the date on which the last party signs.
2.2 The action shall run from 05/06/2017 (“the starting date”) until 31/05/2019 (“the
completion date”).
ARTICLE 3 - MAXIMUM AMOUNT AND FORM OF THE GRANT
The grant for the action shall be of a maximum amount of EUR 1,149,086.
The grant shall take the form of:
(a) the reimbursement of 75.00% of the eligible costs of the action ("reimbursement of
eligible costs"), which are estimated at EUR 1,532,114 and which are:
(i) actually incurred (“reimbursement of actual costs”)
(ii) reimbursement of unit costs: not applicable
(iii) reimbursement of lump sum costs: not applicable
(iv) for indirect costs declared on the basis of a flat-rate of 7% of the total eligible direct
costs minus subcontracting costs within the meaning of Article II.10 and costs of
financial support to third parties within the meaning of Article II.11
(“reimbursement of flat-rate costs”);
(v) declared on the basis of an amount per unit calculated in accordance with the
beneficiary’s usual cost accounting practices (“reimbursement of costs declared on
the basis of the beneficiary's usual cost accounting practices”) for personnel costs
(b) unit contribution: not applicable
(c) lump sum contribution: not applicable
(d) flat-rate contribution: not applicable
ARTICLE 4 – ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS ON REPORTING, PAYMENTS AND
PAYMENT ARRANGEMENTS
4.1 Reporting periods and payments
4
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
In addition to the provisions set out in Articles II.23 and II.24, the following reporting and
payment arrangements shall apply:
4.1.1 Reporting periods
The action is divided into the following reporting periods:
One single reporting period from the starting date to the completion date of the action.
4.1.2 Payments
Upon entry into force of the Agreement, the Agency shall make the pre-financing payment of
EUR 574,543 (five hundred seventy-four thousand five hundred forty-three euros) to the
coordinator in accordance with Article II.24.1.
At the end of each reporting period, except the last reporting period, the Agency shall make
an interim payment to the coordinator in accordance with Article II.24.2.
At the end of the last reporting period, the Agency shall make the payment of the balance to
the coordinator in accordance with Article II.24.3.
4.2 Time limit for payments
The time limit for the Agency to make the payment of the balance is 90 days.
4.3 Language and submission means of requests for payment, reports and financial
statements
All requests for payments, reports and financial statements shall be submitted in English.
Those documents or, if applicable, scanned copies of the original signed paper versions and
electronic files, shall be sent via e-mail to the e-mail address specified in Article 6.2.
ARTICLE 5 – BANK ACCOUNT FOR PAYMENTS
All payments shall be made to the coordinator's bank account as indicated below:
Name of bank: AS SEB Pank
Address of branch: Tornimae 2, 15010 Tallinn, Estonia
Precise denomination of the account holder: Ministry of Finance
Full account number (including bank codes): EE221010220027690221; reference on
payment: 2800048574
BIC code: EEUHEE2X
ARTICLE 6 - DATA CONTROLLER AND COMMUNICATION DETAILS OF THE
PARTIES
6.1 Data controller
The entity acting as a data controller according to Article II.6 shall be the Director of the
5
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
Agency.
6.2 Communication details of the Agency
Any communication addressed to the Agency by post or e-mail shall be sent to the following
address:
Innovation and Networks Executive Agency (INEA)
Department C - Connecting Europe Facility (CEF)
Unit C4 Energy & ICT
B-1049 Brussels
Fax: +32(0)2 297 37 27
E-Mail addresses:
For general communication:
[email protected]
For the submission of requests for payment, reports and financial statements: INEA-
[email protected]
Any communication addressed to the Agency by registered mail, courier service or hand-
delivery shall be sent to the following address:
Innovation and Networks Executive Agency (INEA)
Avenue du Bourget, 1
B-1140 Brussels (Evere)
6.3 Communication details of the beneficiaries
Any communication from the Agency to the beneficiaries shall be sent to the following
addresses:
For Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre:
Lehor Meius
Project Manager
Uus-Tatari 25 / Veerenni 13 , 10134 Tallinn, Estonia
E-mail address:
[email protected]
ARTICLE 7 – ENTITIES AFFILIATED TO THE BENEFICIARIES
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 8 - IMPLEMENTING BODIES DESIGNATED BY THE BENEFICIARIES
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 9 - MONO-BENEFICIARY GRANT
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 10 – ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS ON REIMBURSEMENT OF COSTS
DECLARED ON THE BASIS OF THE BENEFICIARY'S USUAL COST
6
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ACCOUNTING PRACTICES
In addition to the conditions set out in Article II.20.5, where, in accordance with point (v) of
Article 3(a) the grant takes the form of the reimbursement of unit costs, lump sum costs or
flat-rate costs declared by the beneficiary on the basis of its usual cost accounting practices,
the beneficiary shall ensure that the cost accounting practices used are also in compliance
with the conditions laid down in Commission Decision C(2016)478 of 3 February 2016.
ARTICLE 11 – ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS ON USE OF THE RESULTS
(INCLUDING INTELLECTUAL AND INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY RIGHTS)
In addition to the provisions of Article II.8.3, the beneficiaries shall warrant that the Agency
has the rights to:
– summarise the results of the action and distribute the summary;
– extract a part (e.g. audio or video files) of, divide into parts or compile the results of
the action.
ARTICLE 12 – OBLIGATION TO CONCLUDE AN INTERNAL CO-OPERATION
AGREEMENT
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 13 - INAPPLICABILITY OF THE NO-PROFIT PRINCIPLE
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 14 - INELIGIBILITY OF VALUE ADDED TAX
By way of derogation from point (h) of Article II.19.2, amounts of value added tax (VAT)
paid are not eligible for the following beneficiaries: Estonian Health Insurance Fund, Health
and Welfare Information Systems Centre, Estonian Social Insurance Board and Estonian
Ministry of Social Affairs.
ARTICLE 15 - SPECIAL PROVISIONS ON ELIGIBLE COSTS
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 16 – WAIVING OF THE OBLIGATION TO PROVIDE CERTIFICATES
ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 17 - FINANCIAL SUPPORT TO THIRD PARTIES
Article II.11 is not applicable.
ARTICLE 18 — IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTION TASKS BY BENEFICIARIES
NOT RECEIVING EU FUNDING
7
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 19 – SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES WITH NON EU BENEFICIARIES
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 20 – BENEFICIARIES WHICH ARE INTERNATIONAL
ORGANISATIONS
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 21 – JOINT AND SEVERAL FINANCIAL LIABILITY FOR
RECOVERIES
Not applicable.
ARTICLE 22 – IMPLEMENTATION OF ACTIVITIES NOT FINANCIALLY
SUPPORTED UNDER THE AGREEMENT
Not applicable.
SIGNATURES
For the coordinator For the Agency
Katrin Reinhold Andreas Boschen
Done at Tallinn, on Done at Brussels, on
In duplicate in English
8
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ANNEX I
DESCRIPTION OF THE ACTION
ARTICLE I.1 – SCOPE AND OBJECTIVES OF THE ACTION
The action aims at integrating the national Estonian infrastructure with the EESSI electronic
communication (Core) platform and at improving cross-border communication between
Estonian and other EU social security institutions. The Health and Welfare Information
Systems Centre (HWISC) mandated by the Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs and in co-
operation with this Ministry and local competent institutions, such as Estonian Health
Insurance Fund (EHIF) and Estonian Social Insurance Board (ESIB), will prepare, test and
deploy all resources, software components and related business artefacts necessary for the
cross-border exchange of social security information according to EESSI rules and
regulations, best practices and experiences. While doing so, HWISC will take into account
the specificities of the already available infrastructures, services and electronic registries in
Estonia. The action will result in complete EESSI-readiness of each competent institution, as
well as in integration of high-priority Business Use Cases (BUCs) into their information
systems and business processes.
The scope of the action includes:
1. Consultancy and training for deployment and maintenance of EESSI related software
components;
2. Acquisition of additional software licenses for the installation, connection and operation of
Estonian EESSI Access Point (AP);
3. Installation and configuration of Estonian EESSI AP in Production and Acceptance
environments;
4. Set up and training of first and second level IT support teams of Estonian AP and RINAs;
5. Training of end users in several Estonian competent institutions in the use of EESSI cross-
border business processes;
6. Distribution, installation and configuration, development and deployment of national
applications to allow competent institutions to connect to the EESSI Core platform and their
compliance with cross-border business processes. This will include:
- installations of full Reference Implementation of National Application (RINA) instances for
several competent institutions,
- back-end systems integration reusing RINA components in two different Estonian
competent institutions.
7. Development and configuration of adapter software to enable communication of RINAs
and Estonian AP through national data exchange layer X-road;
8. Development and configuration of a "pilot" solution for using RINA as a component in
automatic data exchange between institutions;
9. Local adaptations of EESSI operational documentation, including technical guidelines,
local business procedures, analysis of data model and procedures implementation,
translations and development of user manuals and training materials.
This action will be carried out as part of the national EESSI project in Estonia covering other
relevant institutions and activities in the EESSI domain.
9
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ARTICLE I.2 – LOCATION OF THE ACTION
I.2.1 Member State(s): Estonia
I.2.2 EEA country(ies): not applicable
I.2.3 Third country(ies): not applicable
ARTICLE I.3 – ACTIVITIES
I.3.1 Activities timetable
Activity Activity title Indicative Indicative Milestone
number start date end date number
1 Preparing and implementing EESSI 05/06/2017 26/04/2019 1, 2
exchange service in Estonia
2 Preparing and implementing EESSI 05/06/2017 03/05/2019 3, 4, 5, 6
integration in the Estonian Social
Insurance Board (ESIB) and in the
Estonian Health Insurance Fund (EHIF)
3 EESSI service and integration testing 01/12/2017 31/05/2019 7, 8, 9, 10,
and approval 15
4 Setup and launch of EESSI service 07/08/2017 31/05/2019 11, 12
support in Estonia and ESIB
5 Training and consultancy for EESSI 05/06/2017 31/05/2019 13, 14
stakeholder groups
6 Governance and management of EESSI 05/06/2017 31/05/2019 16
integration
I.3.2 Activities description
Activity 1: Preparing and implementing EESSI exchange service in Estonia
This activity aims at establishing the necessary prerequisites for EESSI exchanges of
information for all Estonian competent institutions. It includes the following tasks:
- T1.1 Plan activities towards national implementation
Within this task a national preparation and implementation plan will be created.
- T1.2 Design national domain architecture
This task is dedicated to analysing and designing national EESSI architecture in Estonia
taking into account Estonian requirement for using X-road layer for any official electronic
communication between public institutions. National Access Services will be selected and
confirmed with all stakeholder institutions. Also, a national Domain Architecture document
will be prepared.
- T1.3 Design sample institutional domain architecture for the Estonian Social Insurance
Board (ESIB) - RINA integration
Within this task sample institution architecture for Estonian Social Insurance Board (ESIB)
will be prepared using the common programming interface (CPI) and the National
10
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
Information Exchange (NIE) interface of RINA to establish connection with ESIB's main
information system.
- T1.4 Establish common organizational requirements and procedures for all Estonian
stakeholder institutions
This task ensures that identified and agreed requirements and procedures are in place,
described in an appropriate document, and signed by each stakeholder institution.
- T1.5 Establish legal, security and privacy requirements and procedures for all Estonian
stakeholder institutions
Within this task a document governing the legal and security aspects of EESSI operation in
each Estonian competent institution will be prepared.
- T1.6 Acquire and deploy necessary additions to supporting national domain software
Within this task all supporting software for EESSI Acceptance and Production environments
required by National Architecture will be acquired and deployed by the dates set in the
EESSI implementation plan.
The type of software to be acquired includes additional BizTalk licenses, Microsoft and SQL
licenses as well as subcontracted customization of Estonian State Information System
Authority’s X-road adapter software.
- T1.7 Establish common project management repositories for EESSI integration activities
This task is dedicated to establishing a common national EESSI software and documentation
repositories which will be made accessible for specified roles in all Estonian stakeholder
institutions.
- T1.8 Assure semantic interoperability.
This task assures that semantics is aligned between structured electronic document (SED)
datasets and EESSI-related data in each Estonian institution's data model as well as between
Estonian institutions.
Estonian competent institutions and Information System Authority (RIA) will be consulted
and cooperated with as necessary in this task.
- T1.9 Ensure deployment and configuration of AP software, X-road adapters, National
Access Services and RINA's into pre-production (Test and Acceptance) environments
Within this task HWISC will deploy and configure software for EESSI service operation over
the integration period as necessary, proceeding from national EESSI implementation plan.
It will ensure that pre-production environments are established and accessible in each
Estonian stakeholder institution.
- T1.10 Make preparations for national testing
This task is dedicated to preparation of base documentation (national testing strategy and test
plan), as well as resources (test cases, test data, contacts in relevant partner Member States)
for testing.
Activity 2: Preparing and implementing EESSI integration in the Estonian Social
Insurance Board (ESIB) and in the Estonian Health Insurance Fund (EHIF)
The aim of this activity is to establish prerequisites for EESSI exchanges in:
11
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
- Estonian Social Insurance Board (ESIB), responsible for the sectors Applicable Legislation,
Family Benefits, Pensions, Miscellaneous, Horizontal and Recovery;
- Estonian Health Insurance Fund (EHIF), responsible for the sectors Sickness and Accidents
at Work and Occupational Diseases.
Activity 2 includes the following tasks:
- T2.1 Plan activities
Within this task Institutional preparation and implementation plans for both institutions will
be prepared.
- T2.2 Design Institutional Domain Architecture
Within this task EHIF will analyse EESSI software and business needs for EESSI BUC
integration, as well as national architecture (T1.2) and sample architecture of ESIB (T1.3)
and design appropriate and cost-effective integration solution. A document on EHIF-specific
interface architecture will be prepared.
- T2.3 Review EESSI organizational requirements and procedures taking into account the
capabilities and requirements of ESIB and EHIF
Within this task both ESIB and EHIF will review and give feedback to the summary of
organizational requirements, roles and procedures for EESSI service operation prepared by
HWISC under activity 1. Furthermore, both institutions will submit to HWISC a signed
document describing organizational EESSI roles and actors.
- T2.4 Establish legal, security and privacy requirements and procedures for ESIB and EHIF
proceeding from general EESSI requirements delivered by HWISC
Within this task both ESIB and EHIF will collaborate with HWISC to establish legal, security
and privacy requirements appropriate for EESSI Business Use Cases processed.
They will review and give feedback to a document summarising legal and security aspects of
EESSI operation in Estonia prepared by prepared by HWISC under activity 1.
- T2.5 Launch of the business use case from the Applicable Legislation sector
ESIB will launch the first use case of cross-border EESSI exchanges, using a simple and
common BUC from the Applicable Legislation sector (LA_BUC_04). Results of the pilot
launch will be shared after three months period with other competent institutions in Estonia
as well as interested organizations in other countries.
The task will result in a report on the launch of LA_BUC_04 in production environment.
- T2.6 Prepare and implement EESSI integration solutions for EHIF
Within this task EHIF will subcontract the work to analyse, develop and test software
solutions for fully integrating high priority BUCs into its business processes and information
system using interfaces between its backend systems and RINA. The software specifications
of the integration solution will be reviewed and accepted by EHIF and shared with HWISC.
As a result of this task, EESSI integration solutions of EHIF will be operating in acceptance
environment.
- T2.7 Prepare and implement EESSI integration solutions for ESIB
Within this task ESIB will subcontract the work to analyse, develop and test software
solutions for fully integrating high priority BUCs into its business processes and information
systems using RINA building blocks wherever realistic to do so. As a result of this task
12
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
EESSI integration solutions of ESIB will be deployed and operating in acceptance
environment.
- T2.8 Local deployment of all required EESSI software components to institutional pre-
production (test and acceptance) environments
Under this task EHIF will deploy RINA and related software into EHIF's institutional part of
national pre-production environment.
- T2.9 Make preparations for testing according to national and institutional plan
Within this task both ESIB and EHIF will cooperate with HWISC and other competent
institutions in writing test cases and creating test data, as well as will prepare to participate in
testing of Business Use Cases which have been attributed to their organisations.
ESIB and EHIF will provide input to base documentation and testing resources.
Activity 3: EESSI service and integration testing and approval
This activity has the following two aims:
1) to test, audit and provide evidence about technical and organizational EESSI readiness of
Estonian stakeholder institutions on the one hand and about EESSI software components,
Common Data Model and Institution Repository on the other;
2) to ensure business readiness of EESSI platform and nationally developed software from
the perspective of ESIB and EHIF.
Activity 3 includes the following tasks:
- T3.1 Coordinate pre-production testing to assure quality of EESSI service in Estonia
Within this task HWISC will first deploy all new EESSI releases into pre-production
environments to enable the compatibility testing of national components of Estonian EESSI
architecture. HWISC will keep schedules of all testing efforts and share test cases and test
data as necessary. Subsequently, acceptance and other pre-production test reports will be
finalised by dates specified in the test plan.
- T3.2 Perform national EESSI audit
Within this task HWISC will organize an internal audit for each Estonian competent
institution. This audit will focus on legal, organizational and security aspects to provide
evidence of fulfilment of the requirements set by guidelines of both national authorities and
European Commission.
This audit will cover components of national EESSI solution: national competent institutions,
their infrastructure and EESSI-related organisational practices as well as X-road adapters and
National Application – RINA integration solutions. Components provided by the European
Commission, DG Employment (Access Point and RINA software code) will not be part of
the audit, except when important security issues with these have become apparent by the time
of the audit. In this case audit will check whether measures against these issues have been
implemented.
HWISC will also ensure that the audit is repeated by external accredited contractors no less
than three months before the end of EESSI integration period.
The task will result in reports on the internal and external EESSI audits of Estonian
stakeholder institutions.
- T3.3 Preparation of country readiness approval
13
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
Within this task HWISC will provide objective evidence of technical and business readiness
of the own and each Estonian competent institution. Since the involved institutions will not
begin cross-border exchanges at the same time, a separate readiness statement summarizing
results of acceptance tests and at least the internal audit performed by HWISC will be written
each time a new institution goes into production.
- T3.4 EESSI service deployment
After task T3.3 is successfully completed, HWISC will deploy all required EESSI software
into national EESSI production environment. Other institutions will deploy their own
required components according to the service procedures agreed within the context of task
T1.4.
- T3.5 Perform acceptance and other required pre-production testing to assure quality of
EESSI service provision by ESIB
Within this task HWISC and the developer of ESIB's institutional systems will first deploy all
new releases of RINA and integrated software into pre-production environments, to make
sure that the national and international compatibility is maintained. ESIB will be responsible
for organising and subcontracting institution level testing as agreed with HWISC and its
partners outside Estonia. Acceptance and other pre-production test reports will be submitted
to HWISC.
- T3.6 Assure the institutional readiness of ESIB
Based on results of acceptance tests and internal EESSI audit organized by HWISC, HWISC
will present ESIB with EESSI Readiness Statement, which outlines the status of ESIB's
organizational EESSI readiness, as well as possible adjustments to its organizational and
business processes and deadlines for their completion. ESIB will confirm the necessary
adjustments introduced to become authorization to start cross-border exchanges with live
data.
- T3.7 Pass the conformance testing provided by EESSI Core Service Platform
By the end of the current action, national EESSI system established as a result of this action
will need to have passed the conformance testing provided by the EESSI Core Service
Platform. Changes to the source code to address possible non-conformance issues will be
made. This task may require participation of all partner institutions and will be coordinated
by HWISC.
Activity 4: Setup and launch of EESSI service support in Estonia and ESIB
This activity has the following two aims:
1) launch of organizational procedures necessary for setup and operation of national EESSI
helpdesk and EESSI service, as well as change management and bug fixing processes for
national EESSI-related software development;
2) launch of organizational procedures necessary for setup and operation of EESSI helpdesk
in ESIB, as well as procedures related to development of EESSI-related software in that
institution. Since ESIB will launch its Business Use Cases (BUCs) in several stages, EESSI
service support processes for ESIB will be gradually extended by adding new features and
resources as necessary.
Activity 4 includes the following tasks:
14
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
- T4.1 Setup of service provision and monitoring processes
HWISC will coordinate the technical aspects of EESSI service in Estonia and will take direct
responsibility for maintaining and monitoring the AP (APEE01) and related software for all
institutions; moreover, HWISC will provide RINA-related services for ESIB and for the Tax
and Customs Board (EMTA).
As a result of this task, EESSI service will be up and running for all Estonian competent
institutions in a sustainable manner and in line with the agreed specifications. Furthermore,
service and performance monitoring tools and procedures will be adopted, enabling support
to intervene in case of performance degradation or service interruption.
- T4.2 Setup of national helpdesk service
This task is dedicated to establishing a national problem ticketing process to manage
incidents, issues and change requests. HWISC will also collect and process end user input on
behalf of the Tax and Customs Board (EMTA). For other Estonian competent institutions
first level helpdesk operators will be granted access to HWISC's common ticketing system.
- T4.3 Setup of change management and bug fixing processes
As part of this task EESSI Change Management process and bug fixing procedures will be
applied in all Estonian competent institutions. HWISC will gather information through
different means and use it to produce issue, improvement and new feature tickets either in
EESSI Central Service Desk or, in case of nationally developed EESSI system components,
in appropriate national ticketing systems.
- T4.4 Setup of first level EESSI helpdesk in ESIB
Within this task ESIB will adopt national helpdesk platform of HWISC, filtering
institutionally raised issues to single out and resolve problems related to EESSI business in
the institutional domain of ESIB.
- T4.5 Setup of change management and bug fixing processes at ESIB
This task is dedicated to enabling ESIB's input into HWISC's change management system.
ESIB users will have only the responsibility to submit business level change requests into the
national EESSI ticketing system provided by HWISC. HWISC's helpdesk will decide
whether they should be solved in institutional, national or international domain and will
forward them into appropriate channels.
Activity 5: Training and consultancy for EESSI stakeholder groups
The aim of this activity is to orchestrate educational, informative, training and consultative
initiatives to empower and support EESSI technical personnel, clerks, system developers and
mobile citizens, as well as to ensure sustainability of EESSI service in Estonia.
Activity 5 includes the following tasks:
- T5.1 Overall communication strategy
This task is dedicated to elaborating an overall communication strategy to ensure
dissemination of EESSI knowledge. This will include a prior analysis of affected EESSI
stakeholder groups, such as administrative personnel and clerks in other public sector
institutions, technical personnel, software development companies and in certain cases
mobile Estonian citizens and health care providers.
15
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
- T5.2 Education and training of personnel
Taking into account the needs of each Estonian stakeholder institution, the Ministry of Social
Affairs after consultation with HWISC and the Estonian competent institutions will specify a
training plan and organize specific training sessions for selected groups of Estonian
specialists in all institutions at least on the following topics:
- EESSI base technologies (BizTalk, Bonita), 1-2 sessions, for 5-10 persons per session;
- Installing, configuring and administrating national component applications (AP, National
Access Services, X-road adapters), 10-12 sessions, for 2-5 persons per session;
- Institution Repository Management, 2 sessions, for 2-3 persons per session;
- RINA installation and configuration, 3 sessions, for 2-5 persons per session;
- RINA administration, 3 sessions, for 2-5 persons per session;
- EESSI operational procedures, including change management and central support, 3
sessions, for 2-5 persons per session;
- EESSI security procedures, 5 sessions, for 10-20 persons per session;
- RINA user portal, 5 sessions, for 5-20 persons per session;
- BUC/SED overview (EESSI case management for clerks, 10 sessions, for 5-20 persons per
session;
- EESSI and integration solutions (institution-specific sessions), 2-5 sessions, for 5-10
persons per session;
- Use of EESSI Service Desk, 3 sessions, for 5-20 persons per session;
- EESSI testing procedures, 3-10 sessions, for 2-10 persons per session.
The number of sessions and participants will be defined once the number and content of
trainings provided by DG Employment will be communicated.
With regard to the training sessions which cannot be organised in Estonia (for example
BizTalk course and trainings provided by the European Commission, DG Employment to
Member State EESSI specialists and trainers), participation of relevant personnel will be
ensured, if required. Moreover, should the participation of EESSI specialists from Estonian
competent institutions not part of this action be required and justified, the Ministry of Social
Affairs may involve them in those training sessions..
Since Ministry does not possess necessary technical and business level knowledge, external
consultants will be hired for each topic if necessary and various trainings provided by DG
Employment EESSI Transition Team will be used to maximum extent whenever they are
appropriate for national training needs (for example, to train national level trainers).
Furthermore, HWISC and Estonian competent institutions will assist in preparation,
translation and extension of required technical, operational and business level documentation
and/or training materials as well as conducting national training sessions for key actors in
national EESSI organisation as necessary.
Trainings will be scheduled over the entire integration period as necessary to coincide with
the launches of BUC's in different institutions.
As a result of this task, a national training plan and schedule will be elaborated, and both
technical and business level training sessions conducted.
- T5.3 Promoting regional EESSI development community
Within this task Ministry of Social Affairs will organize two events (RINA integration boot
camp/hackathon for 30 participants and RINA security hackathon for 20 participants) to
familiarize local software developers with RINA building blocks and to include them
16
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
possibly in future international RINA community. A particular attention will be given to the
security and reliability of RINA solution as well as to solutions for using RINA as a
component in automatic data exchanges. These activities concern the RINA-related
development, technological consultation and training efforts in a different format.
As a result of this task, a local RINA community development road-map will be elaborated.
RINA community events will address local software developers, universities, experts from
national competent institutions and interested partners in neighbouring EU Member States.
Organisation of RINA boot camp/integration hackathon will be subcontracted, while security
hackathon will be held by the Ministry.
- T5.4 Communication and dissemination of information
This task is dedicated to contacting each target group with necessary information through
selected channels, as outlined in the overall communication strategy.
Public advertisement campaign will be held to inform healthcare service providers in private
sector of the EESSI integration and of the possibility to use the system in the process of
confirming the entitlement for insurance.
Moreover, one external EESSI communication event for 40 delegates from 17 countries will
be held with the aim of finding immediate testing partners in other early adopting competent
institutions in other EU Member States.
Finally, within this task an informative video will be produced by an external contractor to
present EESSI nationally (both to other government institutions and to the management of
competent institutions themselves) as viable and necessary data exchange channel about to be
launched.
As a result of this task, EESSI will be introduced in Estonia on business level as a necessary
and reliable tool for data exchanges.
Activity 6: Governance and management of EESSI integration
This activity aims at establishing appropriate national project governance structure to assure
sustainable EESSI integration of Estonian competent institutions and to keep EU level
stakeholders and other Member States up-to-date about status of Estonian EESSI integration.
Furthermore, should any business travel be necessary to successfully accomplish the tasks
described in previous activities (for example consulting with EESSI specialists in other EU
Member States, participating in common testing or installation events), these travels will be
arranged as part of EESSI governance and management by HWISC. An exception to this is
participation in any training events, which will be handled by the Ministry of Social Affairs
under activity 5.
Activity 6 includes the following tasks:
- T6.1 Establish Project Governance model and Rules of Procedure.
This task is dedicated to establishing a national EESSI integration project governance model,
taking into the account relationships between local stakeholder institutions, as well as
instructions and recommendations from EESSI governance bodies and major partners in
other Member States. Furthermore, common Rules of Procedure for the project will be
established.
- T6.2 Accomplish, manage and report national activities
This task is dedicated to ensuring execution of tasks in the proposed national integration plan,
managing issues and maintaining required assets to do so, keeping national and international
17
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
stakeholders up-to-date about the proceedings. Furthermore, the beneficiaries will ensure that
the EESSI Transition Monitoring Dashboard provided by the European Commission, DG
Employment is regularly updated to confirm progress of national implementation activities
defined as part of the "EESSI Transition Keys to Production" approach and that the validation
points have been successfully accomplished.
ARTICLE I.4 – MILESTONES AND MEANS OF VERIFICATION
Milestone Milestone description Indicative Means of
number completion verification
date
1 Hardware and supporting software 31/08/2018 Test report / digitally
components in the respective domains of signed statements by
competent institutions have been deployed appropriate domain
managers
2 National pre-production environments have 28/02/2018 Test report / digitally
been established and are accessible signed confirmation
by Access Point
Manager
3 LA_BUC_04 has been launched in Estonia 04/06/2018 Report (document)
4 RINA has been deployed in pre-production 29/06/2018 Test report / signed
environments of EHIF statement by EHIF
domain manager and
Estonian Access
Point Manager
5 EESSI integration solutions are deployed 03/05/2019 Test report / signed
and operating in pre-production statement by EHIF
environments of EHIF domain manager and
Access Point
Manager. Copies of
software code and
release notes
6 All EESSI integration solutions are 03/05/2019 Test report / signed
deployed and operating in pre-production statement by ESIB
environments of ESIB domain manager and
Access Point
Manager. Copies of
software code and
release notes
7 Report of the internal EESSI audit of 29/06/2018 Audit report
Estonian stakeholder institutions (document)
8 All national domain EESSI software (AP, 31/08/2018 Test report / signed
RINAs, X-road adapters) has been statement by
deployed to production environment HWISC's IT
infrastructure
manager
9 Report of the external EESSI audit of 28/02/2019 Report (document)
Estonian stakeholder institutions
10 Acceptance and other pre-production test 29/03/2019 Acceptance and
18
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
reports other pre-production
test reports
(documents)
11 EESSI Help Desk service and support is up 31/08/2018 Description of Help
and running in HWISC and accessible in Desk System in
Estonian competent institutions. EESSI HWISC and of Help
Help Desk service and support is up and Desk role in ESIB
running in ESIB (document). List of
support tickets
produced over a
period of 1 month
12 EESSI change management and bug fixing 31/12/2018 Analysis of EESSI
procedures are in place and operating tickets submitted in
2018 - report
(document)
13 A number of RINA community events, as 30/03/2018 Invitations, agendas
specified in road map, has been organised of events,
presentations, signed
lists of participants
14 Technical and business level training 31/05/2019 Agendas, signed lists
sessions, as specified in national training of participants at
plan training sessions
15 EESSI system in Estonia has passed the 31/05/2019 Conformance test
conformance test provided by the EESSI report
Core Service Platform
16 Validation points confirming progress of 31/05/2019 Report generated
national implementation activities defined from the EESSI
as part of the "EESSI Transition Keys to Transition
Production" approach have been Monitoring
successfully accomplished. EESSI Dashboard every six
Transition Monitoring Dashboard has been months from the
updated start of the action
19
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ANNEX II
GENERAL CONDITIONS
TABLE OF CONTENT
PART A – LEGAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS
II.1 – GENERAL OBLIGATIONS AND ROLES OF THE BENEFICIARIES
II.2 – COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN THE PARTIES
II.3 – LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES
II.4 – CONFLICT OF INTERESTS
II.5 – CONFIDENTIALITY
II.6 – PROCESSING OF PERSONAL DATA
II.7 – VISIBILITY OF UNION FUNDING
II.8 – PRE-EXISTING RIGHTS AND OWNERSHIP AND USE OF THE RESULTS
(INCLUDING INTELLECTUAL AND INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY RIGHTS)
II.9 – AWARD OF CONTRACTS NECESSARY FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE
ACTION
II.10 – SUBCONTRACTING OF TASKS FORMING PART OF THE ACTION
II.11 – FINANCIAL SUPPORT TO THIRD PARTIES
II.12 – AMENDMENTS TO THE AGREEMENT
II.13 – ASSIGNMENT OF CLAIMS FOR PAYMENTS TO THIRD PARTIES
II.14 – FORCE MAJEURE
II.15 – SUSPENSION OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ACTION
II.16 – TERMINATION OF THE AGREEMENT
II.17 – NOT APPLICABLE
II.18 – APPLICABLE LAW, SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES AND ENFORCEABLE
DECISION
PART B – FINANCIAL PROVISIONS
II.19 – ELIGIBLE COSTS
II.20 – IDENTIFIABILITY AND VERIFIABILITY OF THE AMOUNTS DECLARED
II.21 – ELIGIBILITY OF COSTS OF ENTITIES AFFILIATED TO THE BENEFICIARIES
AND OF IMPLEMENTING BODIES DESIGNATED BY THE BENEFICIARIES
II.22 – BUDGET TRANSFERS
II.23 – TECHNICAL AND FINANCIAL REPORTING – REQUESTS FOR PAYMENT
AND SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS
II.24 – PAYMENTS AND PAYMENT ARRANGEMENTS
II.25 – DETERMINING THE FINAL AMOUNT OF THE GRANT
II.26 – RECOVERY
II.27 – CHECKS, AUDITS AND EVALUATION
20
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
PART A – LEGAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS
ARTICLE II.1 – GENERAL OBLIGATIONS AND ROLES OF THE
BENEFICIARIES
II.1.1 General obligations and role of the beneficiaries
The beneficiaries shall:
(a) be jointly and severally responsible for carrying out the action in accordance with the
terms and conditions of the Agreement;
(b) be responsible for complying with any legal obligations incumbent on them jointly or
individually under applicable EU, international and national law;
(c) make appropriate internal arrangements for the proper implementation of the action,
consistent with the provisions of this Agreement; where provided for in the Special
Conditions, those arrangements shall take the form of an internal co-operation
agreement between the beneficiaries.
II.1.2 General obligations and role of each beneficiary
Each beneficiary shall:
(a) inform the coordinator immediately of any change likely to affect or delay the
implementation of the action of which the beneficiary is aware;
(b) inform the coordinator immediately of any change in its legal, financial, technical,
organisational or ownership situation or of its affiliated entities and of any change in its
name, address or legal representative or of its affiliated entities;
(c) submit in due time to the coordinator:
(i) the data needed to draw up the reports, financial statements and other documents
provided for in the Agreement;
(ii) all the necessary documents in the event of audits, checks or evaluation in
accordance with Article II.27;
(iii) any other information to be provided to the Agency according to the Agreement,
except where the Agreement requires that such information is submitted directly by
the beneficiary to the Agency.
II.1.3 General obligations and role of the coordinator
The coordinator shall:
(a) monitor that the action is implemented in accordance with the Agreement;
21
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
(b) be the intermediary for all communications between the beneficiaries and the Agency,
except where provided otherwise in the Agreement, and, in particular, the coordinator
shall:
(i) immediately provide the Agency with the information related to any change in the
name, address, legal representative as well as in the legal, financial, technical,
organisational or ownership situation of any of the beneficiaries or of its affiliated
entities, or to any event likely to affect or delay the implementation of the action,
of which the coordinator is aware;
(ii) bear responsibility for supplying all documents and information to the Agency
which may be required under the Agreement, except where provided otherwise in
the Agreement; this includes responsibility for submitting the deliverables
identified in Annex I, in accordance with the timing and conditions set out in it;
where information is required from the other beneficiaries, the coordinator shall
bear responsibility for obtaining and verifying this information before passing it on
to the Agency;
(c) make the appropriate arrangements for providing any financial guarantees required
under the Agreement;
(d) establish the requests for payment in accordance with the Agreement;
(e) ensure that all the appropriate payments are made to the other beneficiaries without
unjustified delay;
(f) bear responsibility for providing all the necessary documents in the event of checks and
audits initiated before the payment of the balance, and in the event of evaluation in
accordance with Article II.27.
The coordinator shall not subcontract any part of its tasks to the other beneficiaries or to any
other party.
ARTICLE II.2 – COMMUNICATIONS BETWEEN THE PARTIES
II.2.1 Form and means of communications
Any communication relating to the Agreement or to its implementation shall be made in
writing (in paper or electronic form), shall bear the number of the Agreement and shall be
made using the communication details identified in Article 6.
Electronic communications shall be confirmed by an original signed paper version of that
communication if requested by any of the parties provided that this request is submitted
without unjustified delay. The sender shall send the original signed paper version without
unjustified delay.
Formal notifications shall be made by registered mail with return receipt or equivalent, or by
equivalent electronic means.
22
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
II.2.2 Date of communications
Any communication is deemed to have been made when it is received by the receiving party,
unless the agreement refers to the date when the communication was sent.
Electronic communication is deemed to have been received by the receiving party on the day
of successful dispatch of that communication, provided that it is sent to the addressees listed
in Article 6. Dispatch shall be deemed unsuccessful if the sending party receives a message of
non-delivery. In this case, the sending party shall immediately send again such
communication to any of the other addresses listed in Article 6. In case of unsuccessful
dispatch, the sending party shall not be held in breach of its obligation to send such
communication within a specified deadline.
Mail sent to the Agency using the postal services is considered to have been received by the
Agency on the date on which it is registered by the department identified in Article 6.2.
Formal notifications made by registered mail with return receipt or equivalent, or by
equivalent electronic means, shall be considered to have been received by the receiving party
on the date of receipt indicated on the return receipt or equivalent.
ARTICLE II.3 – LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES
II.3.1 The Agency shall not be held liable for any damage caused or sustained by any of the
beneficiaries, including any damage caused to third parties as a consequence of or
during the implementation of the action.
II.3.2 Except in cases of force majeure, the beneficiaries shall compensate the Agency for
any damage sustained by it as a result of the implementation of the action or because
the action was not implemented or implemented poorly, partially or late.
ARTICLE II.4 - CONFLICT OF INTERESTS
II.4.1 The beneficiaries shall take all necessary measures to prevent any situation where the
impartial and objective implementation of the Agreement is compromised for reasons
involving economic interest, political or national affinity, family or emotional ties or
any other shared interest (“conflict of interests”).
II.4.2 Any situation constituting or likely to lead to a conflict of interests during the
implementation of the Agreement shall be notified to the Agency, in writing, without
delay. The beneficiaries shall immediately take all the necessary steps to rectify this
situation. The Agency reserves the right to verify that the measures taken are
appropriate and may require additional measures to be taken within a specified
deadline.
ARTICLE II.5 – CONFIDENTIALITY
II.5.1 The Agency and the beneficiaries shall preserve the confidentiality of any information
and documents, in any form, which are disclosed in writing or orally in relation to the
implementation of the Agreement and which are explicitly indicated in writing as
23
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
confidential.
II.5.2 The beneficiaries shall not use confidential information and documents for any reason
other than fulfilling their obligations under the Agreement, unless otherwise agreed
with the Agency in writing.
II.5.3 The Agency and the beneficiaries shall be bound by the obligations referred to in
Articles II.5.1 and II.5.2 during the implementation of the Agreement and for a period
of five years starting from the payment of the balance, unless:
(a) the party concerned agrees to release the other party from the confidentiality
obligations earlier;
(b) the confidential information becomes public through other means than in breach
of the confidentiality obligation through disclosure by the party bound by that
obligation;
(c) the disclosure of the confidential information is required by law.
ARTICLE II.6 – PROCESSING OF PERSONAL DATA
II.6.1 Processing of personal data by the Agency
Any personal data included in the Agreement shall be processed by the Agency pursuant to
Regulation (EC) No 45/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 December
2000 on the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data by the
Community institutions and bodies and on the free movement of such data.
Such data shall be processed by the data controller identified in Article 6.1 solely for the
purposes of the implementation, management and monitoring of the Agreement, without
prejudice to possible transmission to the bodies charged with the monitoring or inspection
tasks n application of Union law.
The beneficiaries shall have the right of access to their personal data and the right to rectify
any such data. Should the beneficiaries have any queries concerning the processing of their
personal data, they shall address them to the data controller, identified in Article 6.1.
The beneficiaries shall have the right of recourse at any time to the European Data Protection
Supervisor.
II.6.2 Processing of personal data by the beneficiaries
Where the Agreement requires the processing of personal data by the beneficiaries, the
beneficiaries may act only under the supervision of the data controller identified in Article
6.1, in particular with regard to the purpose of the processing, the categories of data which
may be processed, the recipients of the data and the means by which the data subject may
exercise his or her rights.
The access to data that the beneficiaries grant to their personnel shall be limited to the extent
24
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
strictly necessary for the implementation, management and monitoring of the Agreement.
The beneficiaries undertake to adopt appropriate technical and organisational security
measures having regard to the risks inherent in the processing and to the nature of the
personal data concerned, in order to:
(a) prevent any unauthorised person from gaining access to computer systems processing
personal data, and especially:
(i) unauthorised reading, copying, alteration or removal of storage media;
(ii) unauthorised data input as well as any unauthorised disclosure, alteration or
erasure of stored personal data;
(iii) unauthorised persons from using data-processing systems by means of data
transmission facilities;
(b) ensure that authorised users of a data-processing system can access only the personal
data to which their access right refers;
(c) record which personal data have been communicated, when and to whom;
(d) ensure that personal data being processed on behalf of third parties can be processed
only in the manner prescribed by the Agency;
(e) ensure that, during communication of personal data and transport of storage media, the
data cannot be read, copied or erased without authorisation;
(f) design their organisational structure in such a way that it meets data protection
requirements.
ARTICLE II.7 – VISIBILITY OF UNION FUNDING
II.7.1 Information on Union funding and use of European Union emblem
Unless the Agency requests or agrees otherwise, any communication or publication related to
the action, made by the beneficiaries jointly or individually, including at conferences,
seminars or in any information or promotional materials (such as brochures, leaflets, posters,
presentations, etc.), shall indicate that the action has received funding from the Union and
shall display the European Union emblem.
When displayed in association with another logo, the European Union emblem must have
appropriate prominence.
The obligation to display the European Union emblem does not confer to the beneficiaries a
right of exclusive use. The beneficiaries shall not appropriate the European Union emblem or
any similar trademark or logo, either by registration or by any other means.
For the purposes of the first, second and third subparagraphs and under the conditions
25
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
specified therein, the beneficiaries are exempted from the obligation to obtain prior
permission from the Agency to use the European Union emblem.
II.7.2 Disclaimers excluding Agency responsibility
Any communication or publication related to the action, made by the beneficiaries jointly or
individually in any form and using any means, shall indicate that it reflects only the author's
view and that the Agency is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information
it contains.
ARTICLE II.8 – PRE-EXISTING RIGHTS AND OWNERSHIP AND USE OF THE
RESULTS (INCLUDING INTELLECTUAL AND INDUSTRIAL PROPERTY
RIGHTS)
II.8.1 Ownership of the results by the beneficiaries
Unless stipulated otherwise in the Agreement, ownership of the results of the action,
including industrial and intellectual property rights, and of the reports and other documents
relating to it, shall be vested in the beneficiaries.
II.8.2 Pre-existing industrial and intellectual property rights
Where industrial and intellectual property rights, including rights of third parties, exist prior
to the conclusion of the Agreement, the beneficiaries shall establish a list which shall specify
all rights of ownership and use of the pre-existing industrial and intellectual property rights
and disclose it to the Agency at the latest before the commencement of implementation.
The beneficiaries shall ensure that they or their affiliated entities have all the rights to use any
pre-existing industrial and intellectual property rights during the implementation of the
Agreement.
II.8.3 Rights of use of the results and of pre-existing rights by the Agency
Without prejudice to Articles II.1.1, II.3 and II.8.1, the beneficiaries grant the Agency the
right to use the results of the action for the following purposes:
(a) use for its own purposes, and in particular, making available to persons working for the
Agency, Union institutions, other Union agencies and bodies and to Member States'
institutions, as well as copying and reproducing in whole or in part and in unlimited
number of copies;
(b) distribution to the public, and in particular, publication in hard copies and in electronic
or digital format, publication on the internet, including on the Europa website, as a
downloadable or non-downloadable file, broadcasting by any kind of technique of
transmission, public display or presentation, communication through press information
services, inclusion in widely accessible databases or indexes;
(c) translation;
26
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
(d) giving access upon individual requests without the right to reproduce or exploit, as
provided for by Regulation (EC) No 1049/2001 of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 30 May 2001 regarding public access to European Parliament, Council and
Commission documents;
(e) storage in paper, electronic or other format;
(f) archiving in line with the document management rules applicable to the Agency;
(g) rights to authorise or sub-licence the modes of exploitation set out in points (b) and (c)
to third parties.
Additional rights of use for the Agency may be provided for in the Special Conditions.
The beneficiaries shall warrant that the Agency has the right to use any pre-existing industrial
and intellectual property rights, which have been included in the results of the action. Unless
specified otherwise in the Special Conditions, those pre-existing rights shall be used for the
same purposes and under the same conditions applicable to the rights of use of the results of
the action.
Information about the copyright owner shall be inserted when the result is divulged by the
Agency. The copyright information shall read: "© – [year] – [name of the copyright owner].
All rights reserved. Licenced to the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency under
conditions.".
ARTICLE II.9 – AWARD OF CONTRACTS NECESSARY FOR THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ACTION
II.9.1 Where the implementation of the action requires the procurement of goods, works or
services, the beneficiaries shall award the contract to the tender offering best value for
money or, as appropriate, to the tender offering the lowest price. In doing so, they
shall avoid any conflict of interests.
The beneficiaries shall ensure that the Agency, the Commission, the European Anti-
Fraud Office (OLAF) and the European Court of Auditors may exercise their rights
under Article II.27 also towards the contractor.
II.9.2 Beneficiaries acting in their capacity of contracting authorities within the meaning of
Directive 2004/18/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 31 March
2004 on the coordination of procedures for the award of public work contracts, public
supply contracts and public service contracts or contracting entities within the
meaning of Directive 2004/17/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of
31 March 2004 coordinating the procurement procedures of entities operating in the
water, energy, transport and postal services sectors shall abide by the applicable
national public procurement rules.
II.9.3 The beneficiaries shall retain sole responsibility for carrying out the action and for
compliance with the provisions of the Agreement. The beneficiaries shall ensure that
any procurement contract contains provisions stipulating that the contractor has no
27
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
rights vis-à-vis the Agency under the Agreement.
II.9.4 The beneficiaries shall ensure that the conditions applicable to them under Articles
II.3, II.4, II.5 and II.8 are also applicable to the contractor.
II.9.5 Where, in accordance with Article 3(a), the grant takes the form of the reimbursement
of eligible costs:
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article II.9.1, the costs related
to the contract concerned shall be ineligible;
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article II.9.2, II.9.3 or II.9.4,
the grant may be reduced in proportion to the seriousness of the breach of
obligations.
Where, in accordance with Article 3(b), (c) or (d) the grant takes the form of a unit,
lump sum or flat-rate contribution, if a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations
under Article II.9.1, II.9.2, II.9.3 or II.9.4, the grant may be reduced in proportion to
the seriousness of the breach of obligations.
ARTICLE II.10 – SUBCONTRACTING OF TASKS FORMING PART OF THE
ACTION
II.10.1 A "subcontract" is a procurement contract within the meaning of Article II.9, which
covers the implementation by a third party of tasks forming part of the action as
described in Annex I.
II.10.2 Beneficiaries may subcontract tasks forming part of the action, provided that, in
addition to the conditions specified in Article II.9.1, the following conditions are
complied with:
(a) subcontracting only covers the implementation of a limited part of the action;
(b) recourse to subcontracting is justified having regard to the nature of the action
and what is necessary for its implementation;
(c) the estimated costs of the subcontracting are clearly identifiable in the estimated
budget set out in Annex III;
(d) any recourse to subcontracting, if not provided for in Annex I, is communicated
by the coordinator and approved by the Agency without prejudice to Article
II.12.2.
II.10.3 Beneficiaries acting in their capacity of contracting authorities within the meaning of
Directive 2004/18/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 31 March
2004 on the coordination of procedures for the award of public work contracts, public
supply contracts and public service contracts or contracting entities within the
meaning of Directive 2004/17/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of
31 March 2004 coordinating the procurement procedures of entities operating in the
28
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
water, energy, transport and postal services sectors shall abide by the applicable
national public procurement rules.
II.10.4 The beneficiaries shall retain sole responsibility for carrying out the action and for
compliance with the provisions of the Agreement. The beneficiaries shall ensure that
any subcontract contains provisions stipulating that the subcontractor has no rights
vis-à-vis the Agency under the Agreement.
II.10.5 The beneficiaries shall ensure that the conditions applicable to them under Articles
II.3, II.4, II.5, II.7 and II.8 are also applicable to the subcontractor.
II.10.6 Where, in accordance with Article 3(a), the grant takes the form of the reimbursement
of eligible costs:
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article II.10.2, the costs
related to the subcontract concerned shall be ineligible;
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article II.10.3, II.10.4 or
II.10.5, the grant may be reduced in proportion to the seriousness of the breach of
obligations.
Where, in accordance with Article 3(b), (c) or (d) the grant takes the form of a unit,
lump sum or flat-rate contribution if a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations
under Article II.10.2, II.10.3, II.10.4 or II.10.5, the grant may be reduced in
proportion to the seriousness of the breach of obligations.
ARTICLE II.11 - FINANCIAL SUPPORT TO THIRD PARTIES
II.11.1 Where the implementation of the action requires giving financial support to third
parties, the beneficiaries shall give such financial support in accordance with the
conditions specified in Annex I, which shall at least contain:
(a) the maximum amount of financial support, which shall not exceed EUR 60 000
for each third party except where the financial support is the primary aim of the
action as specified in Annex I;
(b) the criteria for determining the exact amount of the financial support;
(c) the different types of activity that may receive financial support, on the basis of
a fixed list;
(d) the definition of the persons or categories of persons which may receive
financial support;
(e) the criteria for giving the financial support.
The beneficiaries shall ensure that the Agency, the Commission, the European Anti-
Fraud Office (OLAF) and the European Court of Auditors may exercise their rights
under Article II.27 also towards the third parties receiving financial support.
29
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
II.11.2 By way of derogation from Article II.11.1, in case the financial support takes the
form of a prize, the beneficiaries shall give such financial support in accordance with
the conditions specified in Annex I, which shall at least contain:
(a) the conditions for participation;
(b) the award criteria;
(c) the amount of the prize;
(d) the payment arrangements.
The beneficiaries shall ensure that the Agency, the Commission, the European Anti-
Fraud Office (OLAF) and the European Court of Auditors may exercise their rights
under Article II.27 also towards the third parties receiving a prize.
II.11.3 The beneficiaries shall ensure that the conditions applicable to them under Articles
II.3, II.4, II.5, II.7 and II.8 are also applicable to the third parties receiving financial
support.
II.11.4 Where, in accordance with Article 3(a), the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of eligible costs:
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article II.11.1 or II.11.2, the
costs related to the financial support shall be ineligible;
If a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations under Article II.11.3, the grant
may be reduced in proportion to the seriousness of the breach of obligations.
Where, in accordance with Article 3(b), (c) or (d) the grant takes the form of a unit,
lump sum or flat-rate contribution if a beneficiary breaches any of its obligations
under Article II.11.1 II.11.2 or II.11.3, the grant may be reduced in proportion to the
seriousness of the breach of obligations.
ARTICLE II.12 – AMENDMENTS TO THE AGREEMENT
II.12.1 Any amendment to the Agreement shall be made in writing.
II.12.2 An amendment may not have the purpose or the effect of making changes to the
Agreement which would call into question the decision awarding the grant or be
contrary to the equal treatment of applicants.
II.12.3 Any request for amendment shall be duly justified and shall be sent to the other
party in due time before it is due to take effect, and in any case three months before
the end of the period set out in Article 2.2, except in cases duly substantiated by the
party requesting the amendment and accepted by the other party.
II.12.4 A request for amendment on behalf of the beneficiaries shall be submitted by the
30
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
coordinator. If a change of coordinator is requested without its agreement, the
request shall be jointly submitted by all other beneficiaries or shall be submitted by a
beneficiary acting on behalf of all beneficiaries.
II.12.5 Amendments shall enter into force on the date on which the last party signs or on the
date of approval of the request for amendment.
Amendments shall take effect on a date agreed by the parties or, in the absence of
such an agreed date, on the date on which the amendment enters into force.
ARTICLE II.13 – ASSIGNMENT OF CLAIMS FOR PAYMENTS TO THIRD
PARTIES
II.13.1 Claims for payments of the beneficiaries against the Agency may not be assigned to
third parties, except in duly justified cases where the situation warrants it.
The assignment shall only be enforceable against the Agency if it has accepted the
assignment on the basis of a written and reasoned request to that effect made by the
coordinator on behalf of the beneficiaries.
In the absence of such an acceptance, or in the event of failure to observe the terms
thereof, the assignment shall have no effect on the Agency.
II.13.2 In no circumstances shall such an assignment release the beneficiaries from their
obligations towards the Agency.
ARTICLE II.14 – FORCE MAJEURE
II.14.1 "Force majeure" shall mean any unforeseeable exceptional situation or event beyond
the parties' control, which prevents either of them from fulfilling any of their
obligations under the Agreement, which was not attributable to error or negligence
on their part or on the part of subcontractors, affiliated entities, implementing bodies
or third parties involved in the implementation and which proves to be inevitable in
spite of exercising all due diligence. Any default of a service, defect in equipment or
material or delays in making them available, unless they stem directly from a
relevant case of force majeure, as well as labour disputes, strikes or financial
difficulties cannot be invoked as force majeure.
II.14.2 A party faced with force majeure shall formally notify the other party without delay,
stating the nature, likely duration and foreseeable effects.
II.14.3 The parties shall take the necessary measures to limit any damage due to force
majeure. They shall do their best to resume the implementation of the action as soon
as possible.
II.14.4 The party faced with force majeure shall not be held to be in breach of its
obligations under the Agreement if it has been prevented from fulfilling them by
force majeure.
31
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ARTICLE II.15 – SUSPENSION OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ACTION
II.15.1 Suspension of the implementation by the beneficiaries
The coordinator, on behalf of the beneficiaries, may suspend the implementation of the action
or any part thereof, if exceptional circumstances make such implementation impossible or
excessively difficult, in particular in the event of force majeure. The coordinator shall inform
the Agency without delay, giving all the necessary reasons and details and the foreseeable
date of resumption.
Unless the Agreement or the participation of a beneficiary is terminated in accordance with
Articles II.16.1, II.16.2 or points (c) or (d) of Article II.16.3.1, the coordinator shall, once
the circumstances allow resuming the implementation of the action, inform the Agency
immediately and present a request for amendment of the Agreement as provided for in
Article II.15.3.
II.15.2 Suspension of the implementation by the Agency
II.15.2.1 The Agency may suspend the implementation of the action or any part thereof:
(a) if the Agency has evidence that a beneficiary has committed substantial
errors, irregularities or fraud in the award procedure or in the
implementation of the Agreement or if a beneficiary fails to comply with its
obligations under the Agreement;
(b) if the Agency has evidence that a beneficiary has committed systemic or
recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of obligations under other
grants funded by the Union or the European Atomic Energy Community
which were awarded to that beneficiary under similar conditions, provided
that those errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of obligations have a
material impact on this grant;
(c) if the Agency suspects substantial errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of
obligations committed by a beneficiary in the award procedure or in the
implementation of the Agreement and needs to verify whether they have
actually occurred; or
(d) following an evaluation of the progress of the project, in particular in the
event of major delays in the implementation of the action.
II.15.2.2 Before suspending the implementation the Agency shall formally notify the
coordinator of its intention to suspend, specifying the reasons thereof, and, in the
cases referred to in points (a), (b) and (d) of Article II.15.2.1, the necessary
conditions for resuming the implementation. The coordinator shall be invited to
submit observations on behalf of all beneficiaries within 30 calendar days from
receipt of this notification.
If, after examination of the observations submitted by the coordinator, the
Agency decides to stop the suspension procedure, it shall formally notify the
32
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
coordinator thereof.
If no observations have been submitted or if, despite the observations submitted
by the coordinator, the Agency decides to pursue the suspension procedure, it
may suspend the implementation by formally notifying the coordinator thereof,
specifying the reasons for the suspension and, in the cases referred to in points
(a), (b) and (d) of Article II.15.2.1, the definitive conditions for resuming the
implementation or, in the case referred to in point (c) of Article II.15.2.1, the
indicative date of completion of the necessary verification.
The coordinator shall inform the other beneficiaries immediately. The suspension
shall take effect five calendar days after the receipt of the notification by the
coordinator or on a later date, where the notification so provides.
In order to resume the implementation, the beneficiaries shall endeavour to meet
the notified conditions as soon as possible and shall inform the Agency of any
progress made in this respect.
Unless the Agreement or the participation of a beneficiary is terminated in
accordance with Articles II.16.1, II.16.2 or points (c), (i), (j) or (k) of Article
II.16.3.1, the Agency shall, as soon as it considers that the conditions for
resuming the implementation have been met or the necessary verification,
including on-the-spot checks, has been carried out, formally notify the
coordinator thereof and invite the coordinator to present a request for amendment
of the Agreement as provided for in Article II.15.3.
II.15.3 Effects of the suspension
If the implementation of the action can be resumed and the Agreement is not terminated, an
amendment to the Agreement shall be made in accordance with Article II.12 in order to
establish the date on which the action shall be resumed, to extend the duration of the action
and to make any other modifications that may be necessary to adapt the action to the new
implementing conditions.
The suspension is deemed lifted as from the date of resumption of the action agreed by the
parties in accordance with the first subparagraph. Such a date may be before the date on
which the amendment enters into force.
Any costs incurred by the beneficiaries, during the period of suspension, for the
implementation of the suspended action or the suspended part thereof, shall not be
reimbursed or covered by the grant.
The right of the Agency to suspend the implementation is without prejudice to its right to
terminate the Agreement or the participation of a beneficiary in accordance with
Article II.16.3 and its right to reduce the grant or recover amounts unduly paid in accordance
with Articles II.25.4 and II.26.
Neither party shall be entitled to claim compensation on account of a suspension by the other
party.
33
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ARTICLE II.16 – TERMINATION OF THE AGREEMENT
II.16.1 Termination of the Agreement by the coordinator
In duly justified cases, the coordinator, on behalf of all beneficiaries, may terminate the
Agreement by formally notifying the Agency thereof, stating clearly the reasons and
specifying the date on which the termination shall take effect. The notification shall be sent
before the termination is due to take effect.
If no reasons are given or if the Agency considers that the reasons exposed cannot justify the
termination, it shall formally notify the coordinator, specifying the grounds thereof, and the
Agreement shall be deemed to have been terminated improperly, with the consequences set
out in the fourth subparagraph of Article II.16.4.1.
II.16.2 Termination of the participation of one or more beneficiaries by the coordinator
In duly justified cases, the participation of any one or several beneficiaries in the Agreement
may be terminated by the coordinator, acting on request of that beneficiary or those
beneficiaries, or on behalf of all the other beneficiaries. When notifying such termination to
the Agency, the coordinator shall include the reasons for the termination of the participation,
the opinion of the beneficiary or beneficiaries the participation of which is terminated, the
date on which the termination shall take effect and the proposal of the remaining beneficiaries
relating to the reallocation of the tasks of that beneficiary or those beneficiaries or, where
relevant, to the nomination of one or more replacements which shall succeed that beneficiary
or those beneficiaries in all their rights and obligations under the Agreement. The notification
shall be sent before the termination is due to take effect.
If the coordinator’s participation is terminated without its agreement, the formal notification
must be done by another beneficiary (acting on behalf of the other beneficiaries).
If no reasons are given or if the Agency considers that the reasons exposed cannot justify the
termination, it shall formally notify the coordinator, specifying the grounds thereof, and the
participation shall be deemed to have been terminated improperly, with the consequences set
out in the fourth subparagraph of Article II.16.4.1.
Without prejudice to Article II.12.2, an amendment to the Agreement shall be made, in order
to introduce the necessary modifications.
II.16.3 Termination of the Agreement or the participation of one or more beneficiaries
by the Agency
II.16.3.1 The Agency may decide to terminate the Agreement or the participation of any
one or several beneficiaries participating in the action, in the following
circumstances:
(a) if a change to the beneficiary’s legal, financial, technical, organisational or
ownership situation is likely to affect the implementation of the Agreement
substantially or calls into question the decision to award the grant;
34
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
(b) if, following the termination of the participation of any one or several
beneficiaries, the necessary modifications to the Agreement would call into
question the decision awarding the grant or would result in unequal
treatment of applicants;
(c) if the beneficiaries do not implement the action as specified in Annex I or if
a beneficiary fails to comply with another substantial obligation incumbent
on it under the terms of the Agreement;
(d) in the event of force majeure, notified in accordance with Article II.14, or
in the event of suspension by the coordinator as a result of exceptional
circumstances, notified in accordance with Article II.15, where resuming
the implementation is impossible or where the necessary modifications to
the Agreement would call into question the decision awarding the grant or
would result in unequal treatment of applicants;
(e) if a beneficiary is declared bankrupt, is being wound up, is having its affairs
administered by the courts, has entered into an arrangement with creditors,
has suspended business activities, is the subject of any other similar
proceedings concerning those matters, or is in an analogous situation arising
from a similar procedure provided for in national legislation or regulations;
(f) if a beneficiary or any related person, as defined in the second
subparagraph, have been found guilty of professional misconduct proven by
any means;
(g) if a beneficiary is not in compliance with its obligations relating to the
payment of social security contributions or the payment of taxes in
accordance with the legal provisions of the country in which it is
established or in which the action is implemented;
(h) if the Agency has evidence that a beneficiary or any related person, as
defined in the second subparagraph, have committed fraud, corruption, or
are involved in a criminal organisation, money laundering or any other
illegal activity detrimental to the Union's financial interests;
(i) if the Agency has evidence that a beneficiary or any related person, as
defined in the second subparagraph, have committed substantial errors,
irregularities or fraud in the award procedure or in the implementation of
the Agreement, including in the event of submission of false information or
failure to submit required information in order to obtain the grant provided
for in the Agreement;
(j) if the Agency has evidence that a beneficiary has committed systemic or
recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of obligations under other
grants funded by the Union or the European Atomic Energy Community
which were awarded to that beneficiary under similar conditions, provided
that those errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of obligations have a
35
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
material impact on this grant;
(k) following an evaluation of the progress of the project, in particular in the
event of major delays in the implementation of the action;
(l) if the action has not started within two years of the starting date set out in
Article 2.2 or, for grants for studies, if the action has not started within one
year of the starting date set out in Article 2.2.
For the purposes of points (f), (h) and (i), "any related person" shall mean any
natural person who has the power to represent the beneficiary or to take decisions
on its behalf.
II.16.3.2 Before terminating the Agreement or the participation of any one or several
beneficiaries, the Agency shall formally notify the coordinator of its intention to
terminate, specifying the reasons thereof and inviting the coordinator, within 45
calendar days from receipt of the notification, to submit observations on behalf of
all beneficiaries and, in the case of point (c) of Article II.16.3.1, to inform the
Agency about the measures taken to ensure that the beneficiaries continue to fulfil
their obligations under the Agreement.
If, after examination of the observations submitted by the coordinator, the
Agency decides to stop the termination procedure, it shall formally notify the
coordinator thereof.
If no observations have been submitted or if, despite the observations submitted
by the coordinator, the Agency decides to pursue the termination procedure, it
may terminate the Agreement or the participation of any one or several
beneficiaries by formally notifying the coordinator thereof, specifying the reasons
for the termination.
In the cases referred to in points (a), (b), (c), (e), (g) and (k) of Article II.16.3.1,
the formal notification shall specify the date on which the termination takes
effect. In the cases referred to in points (d), (f), (i), (j), (l) of Article II.16.3.1, the
termination shall take effect on the day following the date on which the formal
notification was received by the coordinator.
II.16.4 Effects of termination
II.16.4.1 Where the Agreement is terminated, payments by the Agency shall be limited to
the amount determined in accordance with Article II.25 on the basis of the eligible
costs incurred by the beneficiaries and the actual level of implementation of the
action on the date when the termination takes effect. Costs relating to current
commitments, which are not due for execution until after the termination, shall not
be taken into account. The coordinator shall have 60 days from the date when the
termination of the Agreement takes effect, as provided for in Articles II.16.1 and
II.16.3.2, to produce a request for payment of the balance in accordance with
Article II.23.2. If no request for payment of the balance is received within this
36
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
time limit, the Agency shall not reimburse or cover any costs which are not
included in a financial statement approved by it or which are not justified in a
technical report approved by it. In accordance with Article II.26, the Agency shall
recover any amount already paid, if its use is not substantiated by the technical
reports and, where applicable, by the financial statements approved by the
Agency.
Where the participation of a beneficiary is terminated, the beneficiary concerned
shall submit to the coordinator a technical report and, where applicable, a financial
statement covering the period from the end of the last reporting period according
to Article 4.1.1 for which a report has been submitted to the Agency to the date on
which the termination takes effect. The technical report and the financial
statement shall be submitted in due time to allow the coordinator to draw up the
corresponding payment request. Only those costs incurred by the beneficiary
concerned up to the date when termination of its participation takes effect shall be
reimbursed or covered by the grant. Costs relating to current commitments, which
were not due for execution until after the termination, shall not be taken into
account. The request for payment for the beneficiary concerned shall be included
in the next payment request submitted by the coordinator in accordance with the
schedule laid down in Article 4.
Where the Agency, in accordance with point (c) of Article II.16.3.1, is
terminating the Agreement on the grounds that the coordinator has failed to
produce the request for payment and, after a reminder, has still not complied with
this obligation within the deadline set out in Article II.23.3, the first subparagraph
shall apply, subject to the following:
(a) there shall be no additional time period from the date when the termination of
the Agreement takes effect for the coordinator to produce a request for
payment of the balance in accordance with Article II.23.2; and
(b) the Agency shall not reimburse or cover any costs incurred by the
beneficiaries up to the date of termination or up to the end of the period set
out in Article 2.2, whichever is the earlier, which are not included in a
financial statement approved by it or which are not justified in a technical
report approved by it.
In addition to the first, second and third subparagraphs, where the Agreement or
the participation of a beneficiary is terminated improperly by the coordinator
within the meaning of Articles II.16.1 and II.16.2, or where the Agreement or the
participation of a beneficiary is terminated by the Agency on the grounds set out
in points (c), (f), (h), (i), (j) and (k) of Article II.16.3.1, the Agency may also
reduce the grant or recover amounts unduly paid in accordance with Articles
II.25.4 and II.26, in proportion to the gravity of the failings in question and after
allowing the coordinator, and, where relevant, the beneficiaries concerned, to
submit their observations.
II.16.4.2 Where the Agency, in accordance with point (l) of Article II.16.3.1, is terminating
the Agreement on the ground that the action has not started by the set deadline, the
37
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
following shall apply:
(a) the coordinator shall not produce a request for payment of the balance; and
(b) the final amount of the grant shall be EUR 0 (zero euro). The Agency shall
recover any amounts unduly paid in accordance with Article II.26.
II.16.4.3 Neither party shall be entitled to claim compensation on account of a termination
by the other party.
ARTICLE II.17 – NOT APPLICABLE
ARTICLE II.18 – APPLICABLE LAW, SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES AND
ENFORCEABLE DECISION
II.18.1 The Agreement is governed by the applicable Union law complemented, where
necessary, by the law of Belgium.
II.18.2 Pursuant to Article 272 TFEU, the General Court or, on appeal, the Court of Justice
of the European Union, shall have sole jurisdiction to hear any dispute between the
Union and any beneficiary concerning the interpretation, application or validity of
this Agreement, if such dispute cannot be settled amicably.
II.18.3 By virtue of Article 299 TFEU, for the purposes of recoveries within the meaning of
Article II.26 or financial penalties, the Commission may adopt an enforceable
decision to impose pecuniary obligations on persons other than States. An action
may be brought against such decision before the General Court of the European
Union pursuant to Article 263 TFEU.
38
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
PART B – FINANCIAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE II.19 – ELIGIBLE COSTS
II.19.1 Conditions for the eligibility of costs
"Eligible costs" of the action are costs actually incurred by the beneficiary which meet the
following criteria:
(a) they are incurred in the period set out in Article 2.2, with the exception of costs relating
to the request for payment of the balance and the corresponding supporting documents
referred to in Article II.23.2.
Costs of contracts for goods, works or services or of subcontracts are considered to be
incurred when the contract or subcontract (or a part of it) is executed, i.e. when the
goods, works or services (including studies) are supplied, delivered or provided;
(b) they are indicated in the estimated budget of the action set out in Annex III;
(c) they are incurred in connection with the action as described in Annex I and are
necessary for its implementation; in particular, for the costs of contracts for goods, the
goods are supplied in a Member State or in any other countries where the action is
implemented as described in Annex I; for the costs of contracts for works, the works
are delivered in a Member State or in any other countries where the action is
implemented as described in Annex I; for the costs of contracts for services (including
studies), the services provided concern a Member State or any other countries where
the action is implemented as described in Annex I;
(d) they are identifiable and verifiable, in particular being recorded in the accounting
records of the beneficiary and determined according to the applicable accounting
standards of the country where the beneficiary is established and with the usual cost
accounting practices of the beneficiary;
(e) they comply with the requirements of applicable tax and social legislation; and
(f) they are reasonable, justified, and comply with the principle of sound financial
management, in particular regarding economy and efficiency.
II.19.2 Eligible direct costs
"Direct costs" of the action are those specific costs which are directly linked to the
implementation of the action and can therefore be attributed directly to it. They may not
include any indirect costs.
To be eligible, direct costs shall comply with the conditions of eligibility set out in
Article II.19.1.
In particular, the following categories of costs are eligible direct costs, provided that they
satisfy the conditions of eligibility set out in Article II.19.1 as well as the following
39
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
conditions:
(a) the costs of personnel working under an employment contract with the beneficiary or an
equivalent appointing act and assigned to the action, comprising actual salaries plus
social security contributions and other statutory costs included in the remuneration,
provided that these costs are in line with the beneficiary's usual policy on remuneration;
those costs may also include additional remunerations, including payments on the basis
of supplementary contracts regardless of the nature of those contracts, provided that
they are paid in a consistent manner whenever the same kind of work or expertise is
required, independently from the source of funding used;
The costs of natural persons working under a contract with the beneficiary other than an
employment contract may be assimilated to such costs of personnel, provided that the
following conditions are fulfilled:
(i) the natural person works under the instructions of the beneficiary and, unless
otherwise agreed with the beneficiary, in the premises of the beneficiary;
(ii) the result of the work belongs to the beneficiary; and
(iii) the costs are not significantly different from the costs of staff performing similar
tasks under an employment contract with the beneficiary;
(b) costs of travel and related subsistence allowances, provided that these costs are in line
with the beneficiary's usual practices on travel;
(c) the full costs of purchase of equipment and other assets shall be eligible, provided that
they are treated as capital expenditure in accordance with the tax and accounting rules
applicable to the beneficiary and are recorded in the fixed assets account of its balance
sheet and if the asset has been purchased in accordance with Article II.9.1.
The costs of rental or lease of equipment or other assets are also eligible, provided that
these costs do not exceed the depreciation costs of similar equipment or assets and are
exclusive of any finance fee;
(d) costs of consumables and supplies, provided that they are purchased in accordance with
the first subparagraph of Article II.9.1 and are directly assigned to the action;
(e) costs arising directly from requirements imposed by the Agreement (dissemination of
information, specific evaluation of the action, audits, translations, reproduction),
including the costs of requested financial guarantees, provided that the corresponding
services are purchased in accordance with the first subparagraph of Article II.9.1;
(f) costs entailed by service contracts, including costs of environmental studies on the
protection of the environment and on compliance with the relevant Union law, provided
that the corresponding services are purchased in accordance with the first subparagraph
of Article II.9.1 and costs entailed by subcontracts within the meaning of Article II.10,
provided that the conditions laid down in Article II.10.2 are met;
40
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
(g) costs of financial support to third parties within the meaning of Article II.11, provided
that the conditions laid down in Article II.11.1 or II.11.2 are met;
(h) duties, taxes and charges paid by the beneficiary, notably non-deductible value added
tax (VAT), provided that they are included in eligible direct costs, and unless specified
otherwise in the Agreement.
II.19.3 Indirect costs
"Indirect costs" of the action are those costs which are not specific costs directly linked to the
implementation of the action and can therefore not be attributed directly to it. They may not
include any costs identifiable or declared as eligible direct costs.
Eligible indirect costs shall be declared on the basis of a flat rate of 7% of the total eligible
direct costs minus subcontracting costs within the meaning of Article II.10 and costs of
financial support to third parties within the meaning of Article II.11.
II.19.4 Ineligible costs
In addition to any other costs which do not fulfill the conditions set out in Article II.19.1, the
following costs shall not be considered eligible:
(a) return on capital;
(b) debt and debt service charges;
(c) provisions for losses or debts;
(d) interest owed;
(e) doubtful debts;
(f) exchange losses;
(g) costs of transfers from the Agency charged by the bank of a beneficiary;
(h) costs declared by the beneficiary in the framework of another action receiving a grant
financed from the Union budget (including grants awarded by a Member State and
financed from the Union budget and grants awarded by other bodies than the
Commission for the purpose of implementing the Union budget);in particular, indirect
costs shall not be eligible under a grant for an action awarded to a beneficiary which
already receives an operating grant financed from the Union budget during the period in
question;
(i) contributions in kind from third parties;
(j) excessive or reckless expenditure;
(k) deductible VAT;
41
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
(l) costs of land and building acquisition (including expropriation costs).
ARTICLE II.20 – IDENTIFIABILITY AND VERIFIABILITY OF THE AMOUNTS
DECLARED
II.20.1 Reimbursement of actual costs
Where, in accordance with Article 3(a)(i), the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of actual costs, the beneficiary must declare as eligible costs the
costs it actually incurred for the action.
If requested to do so in the context of the checks or audits described in Article II.27,
the beneficiary must be able to provide adequate supporting documents to prove the
costs declared, such as contracts, invoices and accounting records. In addition, the
beneficiary's usual accounting and internal control procedures must permit direct
reconciliation of the amounts declared with the amounts recorded in its accounting
statements as well as with the amounts indicated in the supporting documents.
II.20.2 Reimbursement of pre-determined unit costs or pre-determined unit
contribution
Where, in accordance with Article 3(a)(ii) or (b), the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of unit costs or of a unit contribution, the beneficiary must declare as
eligible costs or as requested contribution the amount obtained by multiplying the
amount per unit specified in Article 3(a)(ii) or (b) by the actual number of units used
or produced.
If requested to do so in the context of the checks or audits described in Article II.27,
the beneficiary must be able to provide adequate supporting documents to prove the
number of units declared. However, the beneficiary does not need to identify the
actual eligible costs covered or to provide supporting documents, notably accounting
statements, to prove the amount declared per unit.
II.20.3 Reimbursement of pre-determined lump sum costs or pre-determined lump
sum contribution
Where, in accordance with Article 3(a)(iii) or (c), the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of lump sum costs or of a lump sum contribution, the beneficiary
must declare as eligible costs or as requested contribution the global amount
specified in Article 3(a)(iii) or (c), subject to the proper implementation of the
corresponding tasks or part of the action as described in Annex I.
If requested to do so in the context of the checks or audits described in Article II.27,
the beneficiary must be able to provide adequate supporting documents to prove the
proper implementation. However, the beneficiary does not need to identify the actual
eligible costs covered or to provide supporting documents, notably accounting
statements, to prove the amount declared as lump sum.
42
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
II.20.4 Reimbursement of pre-determined flat-rate costs or pre-determined flat-rate
contribution
Where, in accordance with Article 3(a)(iv) or (d), the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of flat-rate costs or of a flat-rate contribution, the beneficiary must
declare as eligible costs or as requested contribution the amount obtained by
applying the flat rate specified in Article 3(a)(iv) or (d).
If requested to do so in the context of the checks or audits described in Article II.27,
the beneficiary must be able to provide adequate supporting documents to prove the
eligible costs or requested contribution to which the flat rate applies. However, the
beneficiary does not need to identify the actual eligible costs covered or to provide
supporting documents, notably accounting statements, for the flat rate applied.
II.20.5 Reimbursement of costs declared on the basis of the beneficiary's usual cost
accounting practices
Where, in accordance with Article 3(a)(v), the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of unit costs declared on the basis of the beneficiary's usual cost
accounting practices, the beneficiary must declare as eligible costs the amount
obtained by multiplying the amount per unit calculated in accordance with its usual
cost accounting practices by the actual number of units used or produced. If
requested to do so in the context of the checks or audits described in Article II.27,
the beneficiary must be able to provide adequate supporting documents to prove the
number of units declared.
Where, in accordance with Article 3(a)(v), the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of lump sum costs declared on the basis of the beneficiary's usual
cost accounting practices, the beneficiary must declare as eligible costs the global
amount calculated in accordance with its usual cost accounting practices, subject to
the proper implementation of the corresponding tasks or part of the action. If
requested to do so in the context of the checks or audits described in Article II.27,
the beneficiary must be able to provide adequate supporting documents to prove the
proper implementation.
Where, in accordance with Article 3(a)(v), the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of flat-rate costs declared on the basis of the beneficiary's usual cost
accounting practices, the beneficiary must declare as eligible costs the amount
obtained by applying the flat rate calculated in accordance with its usual cost
accounting practices. If requested to do so in the context of the checks or audits
described in Article II.27, the beneficiary must be able to provide adequate
supporting documents to prove the eligible costs to which the flat rate applies.
In all three cases provided for in the first, second and third subparagraphs, the
beneficiary does not need to identify the actual eligible costs covered, but it must
ensure that the cost accounting practices used for the purpose of declaring eligible
costs are in compliance with the following conditions:
(a) the cost accounting practices used constitute its usual cost accounting practices
43
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
and are applied in a consistent manner, based on objective criteria independent
from the source of funding;
(b) the costs declared can be directly reconciled with the amounts recorded in its
general accounts; and
(c) the categories of costs used for the purpose of determining the costs declared
are exclusive of any ineligible cost or costs covered by other forms of grant in
accordance with Article 3.
ARTICLE II.21 – ELIGIBILITY OF COSTS OF ENTITIES AFFILIATED TO THE
BENEFICIARIES AND OF IMPLEMENTING BODIES DESIGNATED BY THE
BENEFICIARIES
II.21.1 Where the Special Conditions contain a provision on entities affiliated to the
beneficiaries or a provision on implementing bodies, costs incurred by such an entity
or body are eligible, provided that they satisfy the same conditions under Articles
II.19 and II.20 as apply to the beneficiary, and that the beneficiary to which the
entity is affiliated or by which the implementing body is designated ensures that the
Agency, the Commission, the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) and the
European Court of Auditors may exercise their rights under Article II.27 also
towards the entity or body.
II.21.2 The beneficiary to which the entity is affiliated or by which the implementing body
is designated shall ensure that the conditions applicable to it under Articles II.3, II.4,
II.5, II.7, II.9 and II.10 are also applicable to the entity or body.
II.21.3 The beneficiaries shall retain sole responsibility for carrying out the action and for
compliance with the provisions of the Agreement. The beneficiaries shall ensure that
any agreement or contract with an affiliated entity or implementing body contains
provisions stipulating that the affiliated entity or implementing body has no right vis-
à-vis the Agency under the Agreement.
ARTICLE II.22 – BUDGET TRANSFERS
The estimated budget set out in Annex III may be adjusted by transfers of amounts between
beneficiaries and between budget categories, without this adjustment being considered as an
amendment of the Agreement within the meaning of Article II.12, provided that the action is
implemented as described in Annex I.
The beneficiaries may not however:
- adjust amounts which, in accordance with Article 3(a)(iii) or (c), take the form of lump
sums;
- add costs relating to subcontracts not provided for in Annex I, unless such additional
subcontracts are approved in accordance with Article II.10.
By way of derogation from the first subparagraph, should beneficiaries want to modify the
44
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
value of the estimated CEF contribution that each of them is entitled to as referred to in point
(b) of Article II.17.1 and point (c) of II.26.3, the coordinator shall request an amendment in
accordance to Article II.12.
ARTICLE II.23 – TECHNICAL AND FINANCIAL REPORTING – REQUESTS FOR
PAYMENT AND SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS
II.23.1 Action Status Reports - Requests for further pre-financing payments and
supporting documents
Not applicable.
II.23.2 Interim and final reports - Requests for interim payments or for payment of the
balance and supporting documents
The coordinator shall submit a request for an interim payment or for payment of the balance
within 60 days following the end of each reporting period for which, in accordance with
Article 4.1, an interim payment or the payment of the balance is due.
This request shall be accompanied by the following documents:
(a) an interim report (“interim technical report”) or, for the payment of the balance, a final
report on implementation of the action (“final technical report”), drawn up in
accordance with Annex V; the interim or final technical report must contain the
information needed to justify the eligible costs declared or the contribution requested
on the basis of unit costs and lump sums where the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of unit or lump sum costs or of a unit or lump sum contribution in
accordance with Article 3(a)(ii), (iii), (b) or (c), as well as information on
subcontracting as referred to in Article II.10.2(d);
(b) an interim financial statement (“interim financial statement”) or, for the payment of the
balance, a final financial statement (“final financial statement”); the interim or final
financial statements must include a consolidated statement as well as a breakdown of
the amounts claimed by each beneficiary, its affiliated entities and implementing
bodies; they must be drawn up in accordance with the structure of the estimated budget
set out in Annex III and with Annex VI and detail the amounts for each of the forms of
grant set out in Article 3 for the reporting period concerned;
(c) only for the payment of the balance, a summary financial statement (“summary
financial statement”); this statement must include a consolidated financial statement
and a breakdown of the amounts declared or requested by each beneficiary, its affiliated
entities and its implementing bodies, aggregating the financial statements already
submitted previously and indicating the receipts referred to in Article II.25.3.2 for each
beneficiary, its affiliated entities and its implementing bodies; it must be drawn up in
accordance with Annex VI;
(d) only for the payment of the balance and for beneficiaries established in the European
Union, the certification by the Member State in which the beneficiary is established that
(i) the information provided is full, reliable and true and (ii) the costs declared in the
45
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
final financial statement are real and eligible in accordance with this Agreement; in
exceptional cases, at the request of the beneficiary, the certification may be provided by
the Member State in which the action is implemented;
(e) unless the Special Conditions provide otherwise, for each beneficiary for which the
total contribution in the form of reimbursement of actual costs as referred to in Article
3(a)(i) is at least EUR 750 000 and which requests a reimbursement in that form of at
least EUR 325 000 (when adding all previous reimbursements in that form for which a
certificate on the financial statements has not been submitted), a certificate on the
financial statements and underlying accounts (“certificate on the financial statements”);
This certificate shall be produced by an approved auditor or, in case of public bodies,
by a competent and independent public officer and drawn up in accordance with
Annex VII. It shall certify that the costs declared in the interim or final financial
statement by the beneficiary concerned, its affiliated entities or and its implementing
bodies for the categories of costs reimbursed in accordance with Article 3(a)(i) are real,
accurately recorded and eligible in accordance with the Agreement. In addition, for the
payment of the balance, it shall certify that all the receipts referred to in
Article II.25.3.2 have been declared.
The coordinator shall certify that the information provided in the request for interim payment
or for payment of the balance is full, reliable and true. It shall also certify that the costs
incurred can be considered eligible in accordance with the Agreement and that the request for
payment is substantiated by adequate supporting documents that can be produced in the
context of the checks or audits described in Article II.27. In addition, for the payment of the
balance, it shall certify that all the receipts referred to in Article II.25.3.2 have been declared.
II.23.3 Non-submission of documents
Where the coordinator has failed to submit a request for interim payment or payment of the
balance accompanied by the documents referred to above by the deadline set out in
Article II.23.2 and where the coordinator still fails to submit such a request within 60 days
following a written reminder sent by the Agency, the Agency reserves the right to terminate
the Agreement in accordance with Article II.16.3.1(c), with the effects described in the third
and the fourth subparagraphs of Article II.16.4.1.
II.23.4 Currency for requests for payment and financial statements and conversion
into euro
Requests for payment and financial statements shall be drafted in euro.
Beneficiaries with general accounts in a currency other than the euro shall convert costs
incurred in another currency into euro at the average of the daily exchange rates published in
the C series of Official Journal of the European Union, determined over the corresponding
reporting period. Where no daily euro exchange rate is published in the Official Journal of
the European Union for the currency in question, conversion shall be made at the average of
the monthly accounting rates established by the Commission and published on its website
(http://ec.europa.eu/budget/contracts_grants/info_contracts/inforeuro/inforeuro_en.cfm),
determined over the corresponding reporting period.
46
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
Beneficiaries with general accounts in euro shall convert costs incurred in another currency
into euro according to their usual accounting practices.
ARTICLE II.24 – PAYMENTS AND PAYMENT ARRANGEMENTS
II.24.1 Pre-financing
II.24.1.1 The pre-financing is intended to provide the beneficiaries with a float. It remains
the property of the Union until it is cleared against the payment of the balance to
the coordinator.
Where payment of pre-financing is conditional on receipt of a financial guarantee,
the financial guarantee shall fulfill the following conditions:
(a) it is provided by an approved bank or an approved financial institution. The
guarantee shall be denominated in euros. Where a beneficiary is established in
a third country, the Agency may agree that a bank or a financial institution
established in that third country may provide the guarantee if it considered that
the bank or financial institution offers equivalent security and characteristics
as those offered by a bank or financial institution established in a Member
State. At the request of the coordinator and acceptance by the Agency, the
financial guarantee may be replaced by a joint and several guarantee by a third
party;
(b) the guarantor stands as first-call guarantor and does not require the Agency to
have recourse against the principal debtor (i.e. the beneficiary concerned); and
(c) it provides that it remains in force until the pre-financing is cleared against the
payment of the balance by the Agency and, in case the payment of the balance
is made in the form of a debit note, three months after the debit note is notified
to the coordinator. The Agency shall release the guarantee within the
following month.
II.24.1.2 Without prejudice to Article II.24.5, where Article 4.1 provides for a pre-financing
payment upon entry into force of the Agreement or following a later date, the
Agency shall pay to the coordinator within 30 days following that date or, where
required by Article 4.1, following receipt of the financial guarantee.
II.24.2 Interim payments
Interim payments are intended to reimburse or cover the eligible costs incurred for the
implementation of the action during the corresponding reporting periods.
Without prejudice to Articles II.24.4 and II.24.5, on receipt of the documents referred to in
Article II.23.2, the Agency shall pay to the coordinator the amount due as interim payment
within the time limit specified in Article 4.2.
This amount shall be determined following approval of the request for interim payment and
47
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
of the accompanying documents and in accordance with the fourth subparagraph. Approval
of the request for interim payment and of the accompanying documents shall not imply
recognition of the regularity or of the authenticity, completeness and correctness of the
declarations and information they contain.
The amount due as interim payment shall be determined as follows:
(a) the following amounts, which depend on the form of the grant, shall be added:
(i) where, in accordance with Article 3(a), the grant takes the form of the
reimbursement of eligible costs, the amount obtained by application of the
reimbursement rate specified in that Article to the eligible costs of the action
approved by the Agency for the concerned reporting period and the
corresponding categories of costs, beneficiaries, affiliated entities and
implementing bodies;
(ii) where, in accordance with Article 3(b), the grant takes the form of a unit
contribution, the amount obtained by multiplying the unit contribution specified
in that Article by the actual number of units approved by the Agency for the
concerned reporting period and for the corresponding beneficiaries, affiliated
entities and implementing bodies;
(iii) where, in accordance with Article 3(c), the grant takes the form of a lump sum
contribution, the lump sum specified in that Article for the corresponding
beneficiaries, affiliated entities and implementing bodies, subject to approval by
the Agency of the proper implementation during the concerned reporting period
of the corresponding tasks or part of the action in accordance with Annex I;
(iv) where, in accordance with Article 3(d), the grant takes the form of a flat-rate
contribution, the amount obtained by applying the flat rate referred to in that
Article to the eligible costs or to the contribution accepted by the Agency for the
concerned reporting period and the corresponding beneficiaries, affiliated entities
and implementing bodies.
(b) the amount obtained in accordance with point (a) shall be limited to the difference
between the ceiling for pre-financing and interim payments set out in Article 4.1.3 and
the total amount of the pre-financing and interim payments already made.
II.24.3 Payment of the balance
The payment of the balance, which may not be repeated, is intended to reimburse or cover
after the end of the period set out in Article 2.2 the remaining part of the eligible costs
incurred by the beneficiaries for its implementation. Where the total amount of earlier
payments is greater than the final amount of the grant determined in accordance with
Article II.25, the payment of the balance may take the form of a recovery as provided for by
Article II.26.
Without prejudice to Articles II.24.4 and II.24.5, on receipt of the documents referred to in
Article II.23.2, the Agency shall pay the amount due as the balance within the time limit
specified in Article 4.2.
48
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
This amount shall be determined following approval of the request for payment of the
balance and of the accompanying documents and in accordance with the fourth subparagraph.
Approval of the request for payment of the balance and of the accompanying documents shall
not imply recognition of the regularity or of the authenticity, completeness and correctness of
the declarations and information they contain.
The amount due as the balance shall be determined by deducting, from the final amount of
the grant determined in accordance with Article II.25, the total amount of pre-financing and
interim payments already made.
II.24.4 Suspension of the time limit for payment
The Agency may suspend the time limit for payment specified in Article 4.2, at any time by
formally notifying the coordinator that its request for payment cannot be met, either because
it does not comply with the provisions of the Agreement, or because the appropriate
supporting documents have not been produced, or because there is doubt about the eligibility
of the costs declared in the financial statement.
The coordinator shall be notified as soon as possible of any such suspension, together with
the reasons thereof.
Suspension shall take effect on the date when notification is sent by the Agency. The
remaining payment period shall start to run again from the date on which the requested
information or revised documents are received or the necessary further verification, including
on-the-spot checks, is carried out. Where the suspension exceeds two months, the coordinator
may request a decision by the Agency on whether the suspension is to be continued.
Where the time limit for payment has been suspended following the rejection of one of the
technical reports or financial statements provided for by Article II.23 and the new report or
statement submitted is also rejected, the Agency reserves the right to terminate the
Agreement in accordance with Article II.16.3.1(c), with the effects described in Article
II.16.4.
II.24.5 Suspension of payments
II.24.5.1 The Agency may, at any time during the implementation of the Agreement,
suspend the pre-financing payments, interim payments or payment of the balance
for all beneficiaries, or suspend the pre-financing payments or interim payments for
any one or several beneficiaries:
(a) if the Agency has evidence that a beneficiary has committed substantial errors,
irregularities or fraud in the award procedure or in the implementation of the
grant, or if a beneficiary fails to comply with its obligations under the
Agreement;
(b) if the Agency has evidence that a beneficiary has committed systemic or
recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of obligations under other
grants funded by the Union or by the European Atomic Energy Community
49
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
which were awarded to that beneficiary under similar conditions, provided that
those errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of obligations have a material
impact on this grant;
(c) if the Agency suspects substantial errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of
obligations committed by a beneficiary in the award procedure or in the
implementation of the Agreement and needs to verify whether they have
actually occurred; or
(d) following an evaluation of the progress of the project, in particular in the event
of major delays in the implementation of the action.
II.24.5.2 Before suspending payments, the Agency shall formally notify the coordinator of
its intention to suspend payments, specifying the reasons thereof and, in the cases
referred to in points (a), (b) and (d) of Article II.24.5.1, the necessary conditions
for resuming payments. The coordinator shall be invited to make any observations
on behalf of all beneficiaries within 30 calendar days from receipt of this
notification.
If, after examination of the observations submitted by the coordinator, the Agency
decides to stop the procedure of payment suspension, the Agency shall formally
notify the coordinator thereof.
If no observations have been submitted or if, despite the observations submitted by
the coordinator, the Agency decides to pursue the procedure of payment
suspension, it may suspend payments by formally notifying the coordinator,
specifying the reasons for the suspension and, in the cases referred to in points (a),
(b) and (d) of Article II.24.5.1, the definitive conditions for resuming payments or,
in the case referred to in point (c) of Article II.24.5.1, the indicative date of
completion of the necessary verification.
The coordinator shall inform the other beneficiaries immediately. The suspension
of payments shall take effect on the date when the notification is sent by the
Agency.
In order to resume payments, the beneficiaries shall endeavour to meet the notified
conditions as soon as possible and shall inform the Agency of any progress made in
this respect.
The Agency shall, as soon as it considers that the conditions for resuming payments
have been met or the necessary verification, including on-the-spot checks, has been
carried out, formally notify the coordinator thereof.
During the period of suspension of payments and without prejudice to the right to
suspend the implementation of the action in accordance with Article II.15.1 or to
terminate the Agreement or the participation of a beneficiary in accordance with
Article II.16.1 and Article II.16.2, the coordinator is not entitled to submit any
requests for payments or, where the suspension concerns the pre-financing
50
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
payments or interim payments for one or several beneficiaries only, any requests
for payments and supporting documents relating to the participation of the
concerned beneficiary or beneficiaries in the action.
The corresponding requests for payments and supporting documents may be
submitted as soon as possible after resumption of payments or may be included in
the first request for payment due following resumption of payments in accordance
with the schedule laid down in Article 4.1.
II.24.6 Notification of amounts due
The Agency shall formally notify the amounts due, specifying whether it is a further pre-
financing payment, an interim payment or the payment of the balance. In the case of payment
of the balance, it shall also specify the final amount of the grant determined in accordance
with Article II.25.
II.24.7 Interest on late payment
On expiry of the time limits for payment specified in Articles 4.2 and II.24.1, and without
prejudice to Articles II.24.4 and II.24.5, the beneficiaries are entitled to interest on late
payment at the rate applied by the European Central Bank for its main refinancing operations
in euros ("the reference rate"), plus three and a half points. The reference rate shall be the rate
in force on the first day of the month in which the time limit for payment expires, as
published in the C series of the Official Journal of the European Union.
The first subparagraph shall not apply where all beneficiaries are Member States of the
Union, including regional and local government authorities and other public bodies acting in
the name and on behalf of the Member State for the purpose of this Agreement.
The suspension of the time limit for payment in accordance with Article II.24.4 or of
payment by the Agency in accordance with Article II.24.5 may not be considered as late
payment.
Interest on late payment shall cover the period running from the day following the due date
for payment, up to and including the date of actual payment as established in Article II.24.9.
The interest payable shall not be considered for the purposes of determining the final amount
of grant within the meaning of Article II.25.3.
By way of derogation from the first subparagraph, when the calculated interest is lower than
or equal to EUR 200, it shall be paid only upon request submitted by the coordinator within
two months of the late payment.
II.24.8 Currency for payments
Payments by the Agency shall be made in euro.
II.24.9 Date of payment
Payments by the Agency shall be deemed to be effected on the date when they are debited to
51
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
the Agency's account.
II.24.10 Costs of payment transfers
Costs of the payment transfers shall be borne in the following way:
(a) costs of transfer charged by the bank of the Agency shall be borne by the Agency;
(b) costs of transfer charged by the bank of a beneficiary shall be borne by the beneficiary;
(c) all costs of repeated transfers caused by one of the parties shall be borne by the party
which caused the repetition of the transfer.
II.24.11 Payments to the coordinator
The Agency shall make all payments to the coordinator. Payments to the coordinator shall
discharge the Agency from its payment obligation.
ARTICLE II.25 – DETERMINING THE FINAL AMOUNT OF THE GRANT
II.25.1 Calculation of the final amount
Without prejudice to Articles II.25.2, II.25.3 and II.25.4, the final amount of the grant shall
be determined as follows:
(a) where, in accordance with Article 3(a), the grant takes the form of the reimbursement
of eligible costs, the amount obtained by application of the reimbursement rate(s)
specified in that Article to the eligible costs of the action approved by the Agency for
the corresponding categories of costs, beneficiaries, affiliated entities and implementing
bodies;
(b) where, in accordance with Article 3(b), the grant takes the form of a unit contribution,
the amount obtained by multiplying the unit contribution specified in that Article by the
actual number of units approved by the Agency for the corresponding beneficiaries,
affiliated entities and implementing bodies;
(c) where, in accordance with Article 3(c), the grant takes the form of a lump sum
contribution, the lump sum specified in that Article for the corresponding beneficiaries,
affiliated entities and implementing bodies, subject to approval by the Agency of the
proper implementation of the corresponding tasks or part of the action in accordance
with Annex I;
(d) where, in accordance with Article 3(d), the grant takes the form of a flat-rate
contribution, the amount obtained by applying the flat rate referred to in that Article to
the eligible costs or to the contribution accepted by the Agency for the corresponding
beneficiaries, affiliated entities and implementing bodies.
Where Article 3 provides for a combination of different forms of grant, these amounts shall
be added.
52
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
II.25.2 Maximum amount
The total amount paid by the Agency for the action may in no circumstances exceed the
maximum amount of the grant specified in Article 3.
Where the amount determined in accordance with Article II.25.1 exceeds this maximum
amount, the final amount of the grant shall be limited to the maximum amount specified in
Article 3.
II.25.3 No-profit rule and taking into account of receipts
II.25.3.1 The grant may not produce a profit for the beneficiaries, unless specified
otherwise in the Special Conditions. "Profit" shall mean a surplus of the receipts
over the eligible costs of the action.
II.25.3.2 The receipts to be taken into account are the consolidated receipts established,
generated or confirmed on the date on which the request for payment of the
balance is drawn up by the coordinator, which fall within one of the following
two categories:
(a) income generated by the action; or
(b) financial contributions specifically assigned by the donors to the financing
of the eligible costs of the action reimbursed by the Agency in accordance
with Article 3(a)(i).
II.25.3.3 The following shall not be considered as receipts to be taken into account for the
purpose of verifying whether the grant produces a profit for the beneficiaries:
(a) financial contributions referred to in point (b) of Article II.25.3.2, which
may be used by the beneficiaries to cover costs other than the eligible costs
under the Agreement;
(b) financial contributions referred to in point (b) of Article II.25.3.2, the
unused part of which is not due to the donors at the end of the period set out
in Article 2.2.
II.25.3.4 The eligible costs to be taken into account are the consolidated eligible costs
approved by the Agency for the categories of costs reimbursed in accordance
with Article 3(a).
II.25.3.5 Where the final amount of the grant determined in accordance with Articles
II.25.1 and II.25.2 would result in a profit for the beneficiaries, the profit shall be
deducted in proportion to the final rate of reimbursement of the actual eligible
costs of the action approved by the Agency for the categories of costs referred to
in Article 3(a)(i). This final rate shall be calculated on the basis of the final
amount of the grant in the form referred to in Article 3(a)(i), as determined in
accordance with Articles II.25.1 and II.25.2.
53
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
II.25.4 Reduction for poor, partial or late implementation, or breach of contractual
obligations
If the action is not implemented properly in accordance with Annex I, or if any beneficiary
fails to comply with any other obligations under this Agreement, the Agency may reduce the
grant amount set out in Article 3 in proportion to the improper implementation of the action
or to the seriousness of the breach of obligations.
ARTICLE II.26 – RECOVERY
II.26.1 Recovery at the time of payment of the balance
Where the payment of the balance takes the form of a recovery, the Agency shall formally
notify the coordinator of its intention to recover the amount unduly paid:
(a) specifying the amount due and the reasons for recovery;
(b) inviting the coordinator to make any observations within a specified period ; and
(c) requesting the coordinator to submit a report on the distribution of payments to the
beneficiaries within a specified period.
If no observations have been submitted or if, despite the observations submitted by the
coordinator, the Agency decides to pursue the recovery procedure, the Agency may confirm
recovery by formally notifying to the coordinator a debit note (“debit note”), specifying the
terms and the date for payment.
If the coordinator does not repay the Agency by the date specified in the debit note and has
not submitted the report on the distribution of payments, the Agency or the Commission shall
recover the amount due from the coordinator in accordance with Article II.26.3, even if it has
not been the final recipient of the amount due.
If the coordinator does not repay the Agency by the date specified in the debit note but has
submitted the report on the distribution of payments made to the beneficiaries, the Agency
shall recover the amount due from the beneficiary which has been the final recipient of the
amount due.
For that purpose, the Agency shall:
(a) where, in accordance with Article 3(a), the grant takes the form of the reimbursement
of eligible costs:
(i) identify the beneficiaries for which the amount calculated as follows is
negative:
{{{ {Beneficiary's costs (including the costs of its affiliated entities and
implementing bodies if applicable) declared in the final financial
statement and approved by the Agency multiplied by the
reimbursement rate(s) set out in Article 3(a) for the beneficiary
concerned}
54
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
divided by
the amount calculated according to Article II.25.1}
multiplied by
the final grant amount calculated according to Article II.25},
minus
the pre-financing and interim payments received by the beneficiary}
(ii) formally notify to each beneficiary identified according to point (i) a debit note
specifying the terms and date for payment. The amount of the debit note shall
be calculated as follows:
{ {amount calculated according to point (i) for the beneficiary
concerned
divided by
the sum of the amounts calculated according to point (i) for all the
beneficiaries identified according to point (i) }
multiplied by
the amount set out in the debit note formally notified to the
coordinator }
(b) where, in accordance with Article 3(b), (c) or (d) the grant takes the form of a unit,
lump sum or flat-rate contribution, formally notify to each beneficiary a debit note
specifying the terms and date for payment. The amount of the debit note shall be
calculated as follows:
{ {the pre-financing and interim payments received by the beneficiary
divided by
the total amount of pre-financing and interim payments paid by the Agency}
multiplied by
the amount set out in the debit note formally notified to the coordinator };
(c) where Article 3 provides for a combination of different forms of grant, these amounts
shall be added.
If the beneficiary concerned does not repay the Agency by the date specified in the debit
note, the Agency or the Commission shall recover the amount due from the beneficiary in
accordance with Article II.26.3.
II.26.2 Recovery after payment of the balance
Where an amount is to be recovered in accordance with Articles II.27.6, II.27.7 and II.27.8,
55
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
the beneficiary concerned by the audit or OLAF findings shall repay the Agency the amount
in question.
Where the audit findings do not concern a specific beneficiary, the coordinator shall repay the
Agency the amount in question, even if it has not been the final recipient of the amount due.
Before recovery, the Agency shall formally notify the beneficiary concerned or the
coordinator of its intention to recover the amount unduly paid:
(a) specifying the amount due (including any amount unduly paid by the Agency as a
contribution towards the costs incurred by its affiliated entities or its implementing
bodies) and the reasons for recovery;
(b) inviting the beneficiary concerned or the coordinator to make any observations within a
specified period.
If no observations have been submitted or if, despite the observations submitted by the
beneficiary concerned or the coordinator, the Agency decides to pursue the recovery
procedure, the Agency may confirm recovery by formally notifying to the beneficiary
concerned or the coordinator a debit note (“debit note”), specifying the terms and the date for
payment.
If the beneficiary concerned or the coordinator does not repay the Agency by the date
specified in the debit note, the Agency shall recover the amount due from the beneficiary
concerned or the coordinator in accordance with Article II.26.3.
II.26.3 Recovery procedure failing repayment by the date specified in the debit note
If payment has not been made by the date specified in the debit note, the Agency or the
Commission shall recover the amount due:
(a) by offsetting it against any amounts owed to the beneficiary concerned by the Union or
the European Atomic Energy Community (Euratom) (“offsetting”); in exceptional
circumstances, justified by the necessity to safeguard the financial interests of the Union,
the Agency may recover by offsetting before the due date; the beneficiary’s prior
consent shall not be required; an action may be brought against such offsetting before
the General Court of the European Union pursuant to Article 263 TFEU;
(b) by drawing on the financial guarantee where provided for in accordance with Article 4.1
(“drawing on the financial guarantee”);
(c) where provided for in the Special Conditions, by holding the beneficiaries jointly and
severally liable;
(d) by taking legal action in accordance with Article II.18.2 or with the Special Conditions
or by adopting an enforceable decision in accordance with Article II.18.3.
II.26.4 Interest on late payment
56
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
If payment has not been made by the date set out in the debit note, the amount due shall bear
interest at the rate established in Article II.24.7. Interest on late payment shall cover the
period running from the day following the due date for payment, up to and including the date
when the Agency or the Commission actually receives payment in full of the outstanding
amount.
Any partial payment shall first be appropriated against charges and interest on late payment
and then against the principal.
II.26.5 Bank charges
Bank charges incurred in connection with the recovery of the sums owed to the Agency shall
be borne by the beneficiary concerned except where Directive 2007/64/EC of the European
Parliament and of the Council of 13 November 2007 on payment services in the internal
market amending Directives 97/7/EC, 2002/65/EC, 2005/60/EC and 2006/48/EC and
repealing Directive 97/5/EC applies.
ARTICLE II.27 – CHECKS, AUDITS AND EVALUATION
II.27.1 Technical and financial checks, audits, interim and final evaluations
The Commission or the Agency may carry out technical and financial checks and audits in
relation to the use of the grant. It may also check the statutory records of the beneficiaries for
the purpose of periodic assessments of lump sum, unit cost or flat-rate amounts.
Information and documents provided in the framework of checks or audits shall be treated on
a confidential basis.
In addition, the Commission or the Agency may carry out interim or final evaluation of the
impact of the action measured against the objective of the Union programme concerned, in
order to assess whether the objectives, including those relating to environmental protection,
have been attained.
Checks, audits or evaluations made by the Commission or the Agency may be carried out
either directly by its own staff or by any other outside body authorised to do so on its behalf.
Such checks, audits or evaluations may be initiated during the implementation of the
Agreement and for a period of five years starting from the date of payment of the balance.
This period shall be limited to three years if the maximum amount specified in Article 3 is
not more than EUR 60 000.
The check, audit or evaluation procedure shall be deemed to be initiated on the date of receipt
of the letter of the Commission or the Agency announcing it.
II.27.2 Duty to keep documents
The beneficiaries shall keep all original documents, especially accounting and tax records,
stored on any appropriate medium, including digitalised originals when they are authorised
by their respective national law and under the conditions laid down therein, for a period of
57
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
five years starting from the date of payment of the balance.
This period shall be limited to three years if the maximum amount specified in Article 3 is
not more than EUR 60 000.
The periods set out in the first and second subparagraphs shall be longer if there are on-going
audits, appeals, litigation or pursuit of claims concerning the grant, including in the case
referred to in Article II.27.7. In such cases, the beneficiaries shall keep the documents until
such audits, appeals, litigation or pursuit of claims are closed.
II.27.3 Obligation to provide information
Where a check or audit is initiated before the payment of the balance, the coordinator shall
provide any information, including information in electronic format, requested by the
Commission or the Agency, or by any other outside body authorised by it. Where
appropriate, the Commission or the Agency may request such information to be provided
directly by a beneficiary. Where a check or audit is initiated after payment of the balance,
such information shall be provided by the beneficiary concerned.
For an evaluation, the coordinator shall provide any information, including information in
electronic format, requested by the Commission or the Agency, or by any other outside body
authorised by it. Where appropriate, the Commission or the Agency may request such
information to be provided directly by a beneficiary.
In case the beneficiary concerned does not comply with the obligations set out in the first and
second subparagraphs, the Commission or the Agency may consider:
(a) any cost insufficiently substantiated by information provided by the beneficiary as
ineligible;
(b) any unit, lump sum or flat-rate contribution insufficiently substantiated by information
provided by the beneficiary as undue.
II.27.4 On-the-spot visits
During an on-the-spot visit, the beneficiaries shall allow Commission or Agency staff and
outside personnel authorised by the Commission or the Agency to have access to the sites and
premises where the action is or was carried out, and to all the necessary information,
including information in electronic format.
They shall ensure that the information is readily available at the moment of the on-the-spot
visit and that information requested is handed over in an appropriate form.
In case a beneficiary refuses to provide access to the sites, premises and information in
accordance with the first and second subparagraphs, the Commission or the Agency may
consider:
(a) any cost insufficiently substantiated by information provided by the beneficiary as
ineligible;
58
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
(b) any unit, lump sum or flat-rate contribution insufficiently substantiated by information
provided by the beneficiary as undue.
II.27.5 Contradictory audit procedure
On the basis of the findings made during the audit, a provisional report (“draft audit report”)
shall be drawn up. It shall be sent by the Commission or the Agency or its authorised
representative to the beneficiary concerned, which shall have 30 days from the date of receipt
to submit observations. The final report (“final audit report”) shall be sent to the beneficiary
concerned within 60 days of expiry of the time limit for submission of observations.
II.27.6 Effects of audit findings
On the basis of the final audit findings, the Commission or the Agency may take the
measures which it considers necessary, including recovery at the time of payment of the
balance or after payment of the balance of all or part of the payments made by it, in
accordance with Article II.26.
In the case of final audit findings made after the payment of the balance, the amount to be
recovered shall correspond to the difference between the revised final amount of the grant,
determined in accordance with Article II.25, and the total amount paid to the beneficiaries
under the Agreement for the implementation of the action.
II.27.7 Correction of systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of
obligations
II.27.7.1 The Commission or the Agency may take all measures which it considers
necessary, including recovery at the time of payment of the balance or after
payment of the balance of all or part of the payments made by it under the
Agreement, in accordance with Article II.26, where the following conditions are
fulfilled:
(a) the beneficiary is found, on the basis of an audit of other grants awarded to
it under similar conditions, to have committed systemic or recurrent errors,
irregularities, fraud or breach of obligations that have a material impact on
this grant; and
(b) the final audit report containing the findings of the systemic or recurrent
errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of obligations is received by the
beneficiary within the period referred to in Article II.27.1.
II.27.7.2 The Commission or the Agency shall determine the amount to be corrected under
the Agreement:
(a) wherever possible and practicable, on the basis of costs unduly declared as
eligible under the Agreement.
For that purpose, the beneficiary concerned shall revise the financial
59
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
statements submitted under the Agreement taking account of the findings
and resubmit them to the Commission or the Agency within 60 days from
the date of receipt of the final audit report containing the findings of the
systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of obligations.
In the case of systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of
obligations found after the payment of the balance, the amount to be
recovered shall correspond to the difference between the revised final
amount of the grant, determined in accordance with Article II.25 on the
basis of the revised eligible costs declared by the beneficiary and approved
by the Commission or the Agency, and the total amount paid to the
beneficiaries under the Agreement for the implementation of the action;
(b) where it is not possible or practicable to quantify precisely the amount of
ineligible costs under the Agreement, by extrapolating the correction rate
applied to the eligible costs for the grants for which the systemic or
recurrent errors or irregularities have been found.
The Commission or the Agency shall formally notify the extrapolation
method to be applied to the beneficiary concerned, which shall have 60 days
from the date of receipt of the notification to submit observations and to
propose a duly substantiated alternative method.
If the Commission or the Agency accepts the alternative method proposed
by the beneficiary, it shall formally notify the beneficiary concerned thereof
and determine the revised eligible costs by applying the accepted alternative
method.
If no observations have been submitted or if the Commission or the Agency
does not accept the observations or the alternative method proposed by the
beneficiary, the Commission or the Agency shall formally notify the
beneficiary concerned thereof and determine the revised eligible costs by
applying the extrapolation method initially notified to the beneficiary.
In the case of systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of
obligations found after the payment of the balance, the amount to be
recovered shall correspond to the difference between the revised final
amount of the grant, determined in accordance with Article II.25 on the
basis of the revised eligible costs after extrapolation, and the total amount
paid to the beneficiaries under the Agreement for the implementation of the
action; or
(c) where ineligible costs cannot serve as a basis for determining the amount to
be corrected, by applying a flat rate correction to the maximum amount of
the grant specified in Article 3 or part thereof, having regard to the principle
of proportionality.
The Commission or the Agency shall formally notify the flat rate to be
applied to the beneficiary concerned, which shall have 60 days from the
60
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
date of receipt of the notification to submit observations and to propose a
duly substantiated alternative flat rate.
If the Commission or the Agency accepts the alternative flat rate proposed
by the beneficiary, it shall formally notify the beneficiary concerned thereof
and correct the grant amount by applying the accepted alternative flat rate.
If no observations have been submitted or if the Commission or the Agency
does not accept the observations or the alternative flat rate proposed by the
beneficiary, the Commission or the Agency shall formally notify the
beneficiary concerned thereof and correct the grant amount by applying the
flat rate initially notified to the beneficiary.
In the case of systemic or recurrent errors, irregularities, fraud or breach of
obligations found after the payment of the balance, the amount to be
recovered shall correspond to the difference between the revised final
amount of the grant after flat-rate correction and the total amount paid to the
beneficiaries under the Agreement for the implementation of the action.
II.27.8 Checks and inspections by OLAF
The European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) shall have the same rights as the Commission and
the Agency, notably right of access, for the purpose of checks and investigations.
By virtue of Council Regulation (Euratom, EC) No 2185/961 of 11 November 1996
concerning on-the-spot checks and inspections carried out by the Commission in order to
protect the European Communities' financial interests against fraud and other irregularities
and Regulation (EU) No 883/20132 of the European Parliament and the Council of 11
September 2013 concerning investigations conducted by the European Anti-Fraud Office
(OLAF), OLAF may also carry out on-the-spot checks and inspections in accordance with the
procedures laid down by Union law for the protection of the financial interests of the Union
against fraud and other irregularities.
Where appropriate, OLAF findings may lead to recovery by the Agency. They may also lead
to criminal prosecution under national law.
II.27.9 Checks and audits by the European Court of Auditors
The European Court of Auditors shall have the same rights as the Agency and the
Commission, notably right of access, for the purpose of checks and audits.
1
OJ L 292, 15.11.1996, p.2
2
OJ L 248, 18.09.2013, p.1
61
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ANNEX III
ESTIMATED BUDGET OF THE ACTION
Table 1: Planned sources of financing of the eligible costs of the action
Financing sources Amount of financial Amount of financial Amount of financial Amount of financial
contribution to the contribution to the contribution to the contribution to the
action eligible costs action eligible costs action eligible costs action eligible costs
(EUR) (EUR) (EUR) (EUR)
HWISC EHIF ESIB EMSA
1. CEF-Telecom financing 316,046 375,000 340,892 117,148
2. Beneficiary's own resources 105,348.65 125,000 113,630.62 39,049.28
3. State budget(s) 0 0 0 0
4. Regional/ local budget(s) 0 0 0 0
5. Income generated by the 0 0 0 0
action
6. Other sources 0 0 0 0
TOTAL 421,394.65 500,000 454,522.62 156,197.28
62
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
Table 2: Indicative breakdown per activity and per beneficiary of estimated eligible costs of the action (EUR)
Direct eligible costs
Indirect eligible Total eligible Estimated CEF
Subcontracting costs costs contribution
Personnel costs Other costs Total
costs
Activity 1 12,507 8,448 50,000 70,955 4,375.49 75,330.49 56,497.87
HWISC 12,507 8,448 50,000 70,955 4,375.49 75,330.49 56,497.87
Activity 2 57,888 799,059 0 856,947 4,052.16 860,999.16 645,749.37
EHIF 0 500,000 0 500,000 0 500,000 375,000
ESIB 57,888 299,059 0 356,947 4,052.16 360,999.16 270,749.37
Activity 3 62,545 80,688 0 143,233 4,378.15 147,611.15 110,708.36
HWISC 38,592 30,000 0 68,592 2,701.44 71,293.44 53,470.08
ESIB 23,953 50,688 0 74,641 1,676.71 76,317.71 57,238.28
Activity 4 151,152 0 9,600 160,752 11,252.64 172,004.64 129,003.48
HWISC 135,072 0 9,600 144,672 10,127.04 154,799.04 116,099.28
ESIB 16,080 0 0 16,080 1,125.6 17,205.6 12,904.2
Activity 5 61,254 26,146 60,289 147,689 8,508.01 156,197.01 117,147.76
EMSA 61,254 26,146 60,289 147,689 8,508.01 156,197.01 117,147.76
Activity 6 72,038 0 40,085 112,123 7,848.61 119,971.61 89,978.71
HWISC 72,038 0 40,085 112,123 7,848.61 119,971.61 89,978.71
TOTAL 417,384 914,341 159,974 1,491,699 40,415.06 1,532,114.06 1,149,085.54
HWISC 258,209 38,448 99,685 396,342 25,052.58 421,394.58 316,045.94
EHIF 0 500,000 0 500,000 0 500,000 375,000
ESIB 97,921 349,747 0 447,668 6,854.47 454,522.47 340,891.85
EMSA 61,254 26,146 60,289 147,689 8,508.01 156,197.01 117,147.76
63
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ANNEX IV
MANDATE 1
I, the undersigned,
Rain Laane, Chairman of the Management Board of the Estonian Health Insurance Fund,
representing,
Estonian Health Insurance Fund (EHIF)
Public law body
Registration No 74000091
Lastekodu 48
10144 Tallinn
Estonia
VAT No EE100859517,
hereinafter referred to as "the beneficiary",
for the purposes of the signature and the implementation of the grant agreement
No INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560 for the Action No 2017-EE-IA-0009 entitled "Estonian
integration with the EESSI system" with the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency
(hereinafter referred to as "the grant agreement")
hereby mandate:
Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre (HWISC)
Public law body
Registration No 70009770
Uus-Tatari 25 / Veerenni 13
10134 Tallinn
Estonia
VAT No EE101941259,
represented by Katrin Reinhold, Director General of the Health and Welfare Information
Systems Centre (hereinafter referred to as "the coordinator”)
1. to sign in my name and on my behalf the grant agreement and its possible subsequent
amendments with the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency,
and
2. to act on behalf of the beneficiary in compliance with the grant agreement.
I hereby confirm that the beneficiary accepts all terms and conditions of the grant agreement
and, in particular, all provisions affecting the coordinator and the other beneficiaries. In
particular, I acknowledge that, by virtue of this mandate, the coordinator alone is entitled to
receive funds from the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency and distribute the
amounts corresponding to the beneficiary's participation in the action.
64
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
I hereby accept that the beneficiary will do everything in its power to help the coordinator
fulfil its obligations under the grant agreement, and in particular, to provide to the
coordinator, on its request, whatever documents or information may be required.
I hereby declare that the beneficiary agrees that the provisions of the grant agreement,
including this mandate, shall take precedence over any other agreement between the
beneficiary and the coordinator which may have an effect on the implementation of the grant
agreement.
This mandate shall be annexed to the grant agreement and shall form an integral part thereof.
SIGNATURE
Rain Laane, Chairman of the Management Board of the Estonian Health Insurance Fund
Done at Tallinn, on
In duplicate in English
65
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
MANDATE 2
I, the undersigned,
Egon Veermäe, Director General of Estonian Social Insurance Board,
representing,
Estonian Social Insurance Board (ESIB)
Public law body
Registration No 70001975
Endla 8
15092 Tallinn
Estonia
VAT No EE100675490,
hereinafter referred to as "the beneficiary",
for the purposes of the signature and the implementation of the grant agreement
No INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560 for the Action No 2017-EE-IA-0009 entitled "Estonian
integration with the EESSI system" with the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency
(hereinafter referred to as "the grant agreement")
hereby mandate:
Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre (HWISC)
Public law body
Registration No 70009770
Uus-Tatari 25 / Veerenni 13
10134 Tallinn
Estonia
VAT No EE101941259,
represented by Katrin Reinhold, Director General of the Health and Welfare Information
Systems Centre (hereinafter referred to as "the coordinator”)
1. to sign in my name and on my behalf the grant agreement and its possible subsequent
amendments with the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency,
and
2. to act on behalf of the beneficiary in compliance with the grant agreement.
I hereby confirm that the beneficiary accepts all terms and conditions of the grant agreement
and, in particular, all provisions affecting the coordinator and the other beneficiaries. In
particular, I acknowledge that, by virtue of this mandate, the coordinator alone is entitled to
receive funds from the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency and distribute the
amounts corresponding to the beneficiary's participation in the action.
66
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
I hereby accept that the beneficiary will do everything in its power to help the coordinator
fulfil its obligations under the grant agreement, and in particular, to provide to the
coordinator, on its request, whatever documents or information may be required.
I hereby declare that the beneficiary agrees that the provisions of the grant agreement,
including this mandate, shall take precedence over any other agreement between the
beneficiary and the coordinator which may have an effect on the implementation of the grant
agreement.
This mandate shall be annexed to the grant agreement and shall form an integral part thereof.
SIGNATURE
Egon Veermäe, Director General of Estonian Social Insurance Board
Done at Tallinn, on
In duplicate in English
67
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
MANDATE 3
I, the undersigned,
Marika Priske, Secretary General,
representing,
Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs (EMSA)
Registration No 70001952
Suur-Ameerika 1
10122 Tallinn
Estonia
VAT No EE100535271,
hereinafter referred to as "the beneficiary",
for the purposes of the signature and the implementation of the grant agreement
No INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560 for the Action No 2017-EE-IA-0009 entitled "Estonian
integration with the EESSI system" with the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency
(hereinafter referred to as "the grant agreement")
hereby mandate:
Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre (HWISC)
Public law body
Registration No 70009770
Uus-Tatari 25 / Veerenni 13
10134 Tallinn
Estonia
VAT No EE101941259,
represented by Katrin Reinhold, Director General of the Health and Welfare Information
Systems Centre (hereinafter referred to as "the coordinator”)
1. to sign in my name and on my behalf the grant agreement and its possible subsequent
amendments with the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency,
and
2. to act on behalf of the beneficiary in compliance with the grant agreement.
I hereby confirm that the beneficiary accepts all terms and conditions of the grant agreement
and, in particular, all provisions affecting the coordinator and the other beneficiaries. In
particular, I acknowledge that, by virtue of this mandate, the coordinator alone is entitled to
receive funds from the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency and distribute the
amounts corresponding to the beneficiary's participation in the action.
68
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
I hereby accept that the beneficiary will do everything in its power to help the coordinator
fulfil its obligations under the grant agreement, and in particular, to provide to the
coordinator, on its request, whatever documents or information may be required.
I hereby declare that the beneficiary agrees that the provisions of the grant agreement,
including this mandate, shall take precedence over any other agreement between the
beneficiary and the coordinator which may have an effect on the implementation of the grant
agreement.
This mandate shall be annexed to the grant agreement and shall form an integral part thereof.
SIGNATURE
Marika Priske, Secretary General
Done at Tallinn, on
In duplicate in English
69
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ANNEX V
MODEL TECHNICAL REPORT(S)
The templates for technical report(s) as referred to in Article II.23 are those provided by the
Agency, and are available on the Agency website at the following link:
http://ec.europa.eu/inea/en/connecting-europe-facility/cef-telecom/beneficiaries-info-point
ANNEX VI
MODEL FINANCIAL STATEMENT(S)
The templates for financial statements as referred to in Article II.23 are those provided by the
Agency, and are available on the Agency website at the following link:
http://ec.europa.eu/inea/en/connecting-europe-facility/cef-telecom/beneficiaries-info-point
70
Agreement number: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2017/1442560
Action No: 2017-EE-IA-0009
ANNEX VII
MODEL TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR THE CERTIFICATE ON THE FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
The model terms of reference for the certificate on the financial statements as referred to in
Article II.23 are those provided by the Agency, and are available on the Agency website at
the following link:
http://ec.europa.eu/inea/en/connecting-europe-facility/cef-telecom/beneficiaries-info-point
The model terms of reference for the certificate on the financial statements include templates
for:
the Terms of Reference for an Independent Report of Factual Findings on costs
declared under a Grant Agreement financed under the Connecting Europe Facility
(CEF), and
the independent report of factual findings on costs declared under a grant agreement
financed under the Connecting Europe Facility (CEF), including its annex.
71